17. But of the writings of John, not only his Gospel, but also the former of his epistles,
has been accepted without dispute both now and in ancient times.774 But the other two are
disputed.775
774 The testimony to the first Epistle of John goes hand in hand with that to the fourth Gospel (cf. note 1,
above). But we can find still clearer trace of the Epistle in the early part of the second century than of the Gospel
(e.g. in Polycarp’s Epistle, where traces of the Gospel are wanting; and so, too, in Papias, according to chap. 39,
below). The writings of the second century are full of the spirit of the Epistle as well as of the Gospel and exhibit
frequent parallels in language too close to be mistaken. The first express testimony as to its authorship occurs
in the Muratorian Fragment. The first systematic attack upon the Epistle was made by Bretschneider, in 1820,
in connection with the attack upon the Gospel. The Tübingen school likewise rejected both. Before Bretschneider
there had been a few critics (e.g. Lange, 1797) who had rejected the Epistle while accepting the Gospel, and since
then a few have accepted the Epistle while rejecting the Gospel; but these are exceptional cases. The Gospel and
Epistle have almost universally, and quite rightly, been regarded as the work of the same author, and may be
said to stand or fall together. Cf. the works cited in note 1, and also Westcott’s Epistles of St. John. (On the use
of πρότερα instead of πρώτη, see p. 388, note.)
775 The Muratorian Fragment expressly ascribes two epistles to John. Citations from the second Epistle appear
first in Irenæus, though he does not distinguish it from the first. Clement of Alexandria (Strom. II. 15) quotes
from 1 John under the formula “John says in his larger Epistle,” showing that he knew of a second. The lack of
citations from the second and third Epistles is easily explained by their brevity and the minor importance of
their doctrinal contents. The second and third Epistles belong to the seven Antilegomena. Origen cites the first
Epistle often, the second and third never, and of the latter he says “not all agree that they are genuine” (quoted
by Eusebius, VI. 25), and apparently he himself did not consider them of apostolic origin (cf. Weiss’ Einleitung,
p. 87). Origen’s treatment of the Catholic Epistles was implicitly followed by his pupil Dionysius and by succeeding
generations. Eusebius himself does not express his own judgment in the matter, but simply records the state of
tradition which was a mere repetition of Origen’s position in regard to them. Jerome (de vir. ill. 9 and 18) says
that most writers ascribe them to the presbyter John—an opinion which evidently arose upon the basis of the
author’s self-designation in 2 John 1, and 3 John 1, and some modern critics (among them Reuss and Wieseler)
have done the same. Eusebius himself in the next chapter implies that such an opinion existed in his day, though
he does not express his own view on the matter. He placed them, however, among the Antilegomena. (On the
presbyter John, see below chap. 39, note 4.) That the two epistles fell originally into the class of Antilegomena
was due doubtless to the peculiar self-designation mentioned, which seemed to distinguish the author from the
apostle, and also to their private and doctrinally unimportant character. But in spite of the slight external testimony
to the epistles the conclusion of Weiss seems correct, that “inasmuch as the second and third clearly betray the
same author, and inasmuch as the second is related to the first in such a manner that they must either be by the
same author or the former be regarded as an entirely aimless imitation of the latter, so everything favors the
ascription of them both to the author of the first, viz. to the apostle.” (ibid. p. 469.)
317
The Order of the Gospels.