Chapter 22.—30. Accordingly we agree with Cyprian that "heretics cannot give remission
of sins;"1540 but we maintain that they can give baptism,—which indeed in them, both when
they give and when they receive it, is profitable only to their destruction, as misusing so
great a gift of God; just as also the malicious and envious, whom Cyprian himself acknow-
ledges to be within the Church, cannot give remission of sins, while we all confess that they
can give baptism. For if it was said of those who have sinned against us, "If ye forgive not
men their trespasses, neither will your Father forgive your trespasses,"1541 how much more
impossible is it that their sins should be forgiven who hate the brethren by whom they are
loved, and are baptized in that very hatred; and yet when they are brought to the right way,
baptism is not given them anew, but that very pardon which they did not then deserve is
granted them in their true conversion? And so even what Cyprian wrote to Quintus, and
what, in conjunction with his colleagues Liberalis, Caldonius, Junius, and the rest, he wrote
to Saturninus, Maximus, and others, is all found, on due consideration, to be in no wise
meet to be preferred as against the agreement of the whole Catholic Church, of which they
rejoiced that they were members, and from which they neither cut themselves away nor al-
lowed others to be cut away who held a contrary opinion, until at length, by the will of the
Lord, it was made manifest, by a plenary Council many years afterwards, what was the more
perfect way, and that not by the institution of any novelty, but by confirming what was old.
1540 Cypr. Ep. lxx. 3.
1541 Matt. vi. 15.
Chapter 22
851
Chapter 22