Against IV.—These statements, too, are akin to the preceding. On
the assumption that there has been a mixture, he means that there is a
distinction of terms as used both in the holy Gospels and in the
apostolic writings. And he uses this language while glorifying himself
that he is at war at once with Arius and Eunomius and the rest of the
heresiarchs. Let then this exact professor of theology tells us how he
would confute the blasphemy of the heretics, while applying to God the
Word what is uttered humbly and appropriately by the form of the
servant. They indeed while thus doing lay down that the Son of God is
inferior, a creature, made, and a servant. To whom then are we,
holding as
we do the opposite opinion to theirs, and confessing the Son to be of
one substance and co-eternal with God the Father, Creator of the
Universe, Maker, Beautifier, Ruler, and Governor, All-wise, Almighty,
or rather Himself, Power, Life and Wisdom, to refer the words “My
God, my God why hast thou forsaken me;” Matt. xxvii.
48
or “Father if it be possible let this cup pass from me;” Matt. xxvi.
39 or “Father save me from this
hour;” John xii. 27 or “That hour no man
knoweth, not even the Son of Man;” Matt. xxiv. 36 and Mk. xiii.
22.
There is no manuscript authority for the variation Son “of
Man.”
and all the other passages spoken and written in lowliness by Him and
by the holy apostles about Him? To whom shall we apply the weariness
and the sleep? To whom the ignorance and the fear? Who was it who stood
in need of angelic succour? If these belong to God the Word, how was
wisdom ignorant? How could it be called wisdom when affected by the
sense of ignorance? How could He speak the truth in saying that He had
all that the Father hath, John xvi. 15 when not having the
knowledge of the Father? For He says, “The Father alone knoweth
that day.” Matt. xxiv.
36 How could He be the
unchanged image of Him that begat Him if He has not all that the
Begetter hath? If then He speaks the truth when saying that He is
ignorant, any one might suppose this of Him. But if He knoweth the day,
but says that He is ignorant with the wish to hide it, you see in what
a blasphemy the conclusion issues. For the truth lies and could not
properly be called truth if it has any quality opposed to truth. But if
the truth does not lie, neither is God the Word ignorant of the day
which He Himself made, and which He Himself fixed, wherein He purposes
to judge the world, but has the knowledge of the Father as being
unchanged image. Not then to God the Word does the ignorance belong,
but to the form of the servant who at that time knew as much as the
indwelling Godhead revealed. The same position may be maintained about
other similar cases. How for instance could it be reasonable for God
the Word to say to the Father, “Father if it be possible let this
cup pass from me, nevertheless not as I will but as Thou wilt”? Matt. xxvi.
39 The absurdities which necessarily thence
follow are not a few. First it follows that the Father and the Son are
not of the same mind, and that the Father wishes one thing and the Son
another, for He said, “Nevertheless not as I will but as Thou
wilt.” Secondly we shall have to contemplate great ignorance in
the Son, for He will be found ignorant whether the cup can or cannot
pass from Him; but to say this of God the Word is utter impiety and
blasphemy. For exactly did He know the end of the mystery of the
œconomy Who for this very reason came among us, Who of His own
accord took our nature, Who emptied Himself. For this cause too He
foretold to the Holy Apostles, “Behold we go up to Jerusalem; and
the Son of Man shall be betrayed…into the hands of the Gentiles
to mock and to scourge and to crucify Him, and the third day He shall
rise again.” Matt. xx. 18,
19 How then can He
Who foretold these things, and, when Peter deprecated their coming to
pass, rebuked him, Himself deprecate their coming to pass, when He
clearly knows all that is to be? Is it not absurd that Abraham many
generations ago should have seen His day and have been glad, John viii. 26 and that Isaiah in like manner, and
Jeremiah, and Daniel, and Zechariah, and all the fellowship of the
prophets, should have foretold His saving passion, and He Himself be
ignorant, and beg release from and deprecate it, though it was destined
to come to pass for the salvation of the world? Therefore these words
are not the words of God the Word, but of the form of the servant,
afraid of death because death was not yet destroyed. For
the view that the cup deprecated by the Saviour was death there is no
direct Scriptural authority and to adopt the exegesis of Theodoret and
of many others would be to place the divine humanity of the Messiah on
a lower level than that not merely of many a martyr and patriot but of
many men unconscious of martyr’s or patriot’s high calling,
who have nevertheless faced death and pain with calm and cheerful
fortitude. The bitterness of the cup which the Saviour prayed might if
possible pass from Him seems rather to have lain in the culmination of
the sin of the race and nation with which His love for men had
identified Him; the greed, the treachery, the meanness, the cruelty,
the disloyalty, shewn by the Sons of Israel to the Son of David, by the
sons of men to the Son of Man.
Surely God the Word permitted the utterance of these expressions
allowing room for fear, that the nature of Him that had to be born may
be plain, and to prevent our supposing the Son of Abraham and David to
be an unreality or appearance. The crew of the impious heretics has
given birth to this blasphemy through entertaining these sentiments. We
shall therefore apply what is divinely spoken and acted to God the
Word; on the other hand what is said and done in humility we shall
connect with the form of a servant, lest we be tainted with the
blasphemy of Arius and Eunomius.