That
Mark wrote the second Gospel under the influence of Peter, or as a
record of what he had heard from him, is the universal tradition of
antiquity. Papias, in the famous and much-disputed passage (quoted by
Eusebius, III. 39, below), is the first to record the tradition. Justin
Martyr refers to Mark’s Gospel under the name “Memoirs
(ἀπομνημονεύματα) of Peter” (Dial. c. Tryph. 106; the
translation in the Ante-Nicene Fathers, Am. Ed. Vol. I. p. 252,
which refers the αὐτοῦ to
Christ, is incorrect; compare Weiss, N. T. Einleitung, p. 44,
note 4). Irenæus (Adv. Hær. III. 11. 1, quoted below,
V. 8. 2), Tertullian (Adv. Marcionem, IV. 5), and Origen (quoted
below, VI. 25) confirm the tradition, which is repeated over and over
again by the Fathers.
The question as to the
real authorship of our second Gospel, or rather as to its composition
and its relation to Matthew and Luke, is a very difficult one. The
relationship of the three synoptical Gospels was first discussed by
Augustine (De Consensu Evangelistarum), who defended the
traditional order, but made Mark dependent upon Matthew. This view
prevailed until the beginning of the present century, when the problem
was attacked anew, and since then it has been the crux of the literary
criticism of the Bible. The three have been held to be dependent upon
each other, and every possible order has found its advocates; a common
source has been assumed for the three: the Hebrew Matthew, the
Gospel according to the Hebrews (see Bk. III. chap. 25, note
24), our canonical Gospel of Mark, or an original Mark, resembling the
present one; a number of fragmentary documents have been assumed; while
others, finally, have admitted only oral tradition as the basis.
According to Baur’s tendency theory, Matthew (polemically
Jewish-Christian) came first, followed by an original Luke (polemically
Pauline-Christian), then by our Mark, which was based upon both and
written in the interest of neutrality, and lastly by our present Luke,
designed as a final irenicum. This view now finds few advocates. The
whole matter is still unsettled, but criticism seems to be gradually
converging toward a common ground type (or rather two independent
types) for all three while at the same time maintaining the relative
independence of the three, one toward the other. What these ground
types were, is a matter of still sharper dispute, although criticism is
gradually drawing their larger features with more and more certainty
and clearness. (The latest discussion upon the subject by Handmann,
das Hebräer-Evangelium, makes the two types the
“Ur-Marcus” and the Gospel of the Hebrews.) That in the
last analysis, however, some space must still be left for floating
tradition, or for documents irreducible to the one or two types, seems
absolutely certain. For further information as to the state of
discussion upon this intricate problem, see among recent works,
especially Weiss, Einleitung, p. 473 sqq., Holtzmann,
Einleitung, p. 328 sqq., and Schaff, Ch. Hist. I. 575
sqq., where the literature down to 1882 is given with great fullness.
Conservative opinion puts the composition of all the synoptic Gospels
before the destruction of Jerusalem (for the date of Luke, see III. 4,
note 12); but the critical school, while throwing the original type
back of that date, considers the composition of our present Gospels to
have been the gradual work of years, assuming that they were not
finally crystallized into the form in which we have them before the
second century.