“These are the
circumstances which I had to communicate respecting the published
formulary of the faith. To it we all agreed, not without investigation,
but, after having subjected the views submitted to us to thorough
examination in the presence of our most beloved emperor, for the above
reasons we all acquiesced in it. We also allowed that the anathema
appended by them to their formulary of faith should be accepted,
because it prohibits the use of words which are not scriptural; through
which almost all the disorder and troubles of the Church have arisen.
And since no passage of the inspired Scripture uses the terms
‘out of the non-existent,’ or that ‘there was a time
when He was not,’ nor indeed any of the other phrases of the same
class, it did not appear reasonable to assert or to teach such things.
In this opinion, therefore, we judged it right to agree; since, indeed,
we had never, at any former period, been accustomed to use such terms The
genuineness of the following sentence is doubted. It is not found in
Socrates or in Epiphanius. But it is not unreasonably held by Valesius
that Socrates, who seems to have undertaken to clear the character of
Eusebius of all heretical taint, purposely suppressed the passage as
inconsistent with orthodoxy. Soc. i. 8. Dr. Newman writes of this
passage, “It is remarkable as shewing his (Constantine’s)
utter ignorance of doctrines which were never intended for discussion
among the unbaptized heathen, or the secularized Christian, that, in
spite of bold avowal of the orthodox faith in detail” (i.e. in
his letter to Arius), “yet shortly after he explained to Eusebius
one of the Nicene declarations in a sense which even Arius would
scarcely have allowed, expressed as it is almost after the manner of
Paulus. “Arians,” 3rd ed., p. 256.. Moreover, the condemnation of the
assertion that before He was begotten He was not, did not appear to
involve any incongruity, because all assent to the fact that He was the
Son of God before He was begotten according to the flesh. And here our
emperor, most beloved by God, began to reason concerning His
divine origin, and His existence before all ages. He was virtually in
the Father without generation Here it has been proposed to read for ἀγεννήτως, without generation, which does not admit of an orthodox
interpretation, ἀειγεννήτως, i.e. by eternal generation., even before He
was actually begotten, the Father having always been the Father, just
as He has always been a King and a Saviour, and, virtually, all things,
and has never known any change of being or action.