SECT. V.
That Sincerity of Desires and Endeavours, which is supposed to excuse in the non-perform-
ance of things in themselves good, particularly considered.
It is much insisted on by many, that some men, though they are not able to perform
spiritual duties, such as repentance of sin, love to God, a cordial acceptance of Christ as ex-
hibited and offered in the gospel, &c. yet may sincerely desire and endeavor after these
things; and therefore must be excused; it being unreasonable to blame them for the omission
of those things, which they sincerely desire and endeavour to do, but cannot. Concerning
this matter, the following things may be observed.
1. What is here supposed, is a great mistake, and gross absurdity; even that men may
sincerely choose and desire those spiritual duties of love, acceptance, choice, rejection, &c.
consisting in the exercise of the Will itself, or in the disposition and inclination of the heart;
and yet not able to perform or exert them. This is absurd, because it is absurd to suppose
that a man should directly, properly, and sincerely incline to have an inclination, which at
the same time is contrary to his inclination: for that is to suppose him not to be inclined to
that which he is inclined to. If a man, in the state and acts of his Will and inclination,
properly and directly falls in with those duties, he therein performs them: for the duties
themselves consist in that very thing; they consist in the state and acts of the Will being so
formed and directed. If the soul properly and sincerely falls in with a certain proposed act
of Will or choice, the soul therein makes that choice its own. Even as when a moving body
falls in with a proposed direction of its motion, that is the same thing as to move in that
52
direction.
2. That which is called a Desire and Willingness for those inward duties, in such as do
not perform them, has respect to these duties only indirectly and remotely, and is improperly
so called; not only because (as was observed before) it respects those good volitions only in
the good antecedents, whereby good events, following by the necessity of consequence, are infallibly secured.
Besides, 5. It is highly absurd, as must appear from the nature of law and obligation, to suppose that the sincerity
of legislative or inviting will should depend on the event of compliance or non-compliance. Surely the sincerity
of a lawgiver is not affected, whether all obey, or only some, or even none. Legislation is a testimony with sanctions,
that the thing prohibited is evil, or the thing commanded is good, to the party. Hence, 6. The consequent,
whether good or bad, is objectively established, or hypothethically proposed, by the legislator: and the antecedent
is supposed to be within the reach, or, physically considered, placed within the power, of the agent. Therefore,
7. The agent’s abuse of his physical power, in reference to the antecedent, constitutes the criminality, and the
right use of it constitutes the virtue, of an action. And then alone is physical power, in fact, used aright when it
is the instrument of moral rectitude, or a right state of mind. Do men gather grapes of thorns, or figs of thistles?
Even so, every good tree bringeth forth good fruit; but a corrupt tree bringeth forth evil fruit. A good tree (as
such ) cannot bring forth evil fruit; neither can a corrupt tree (as such ) bring forth good fruit.—W.
SECTION V. That Sincerity of Desires and Endeavours, which is supposed to excuse in the non-performance of things in themselves good, particularly considered.
653
SECTION V. That Sincerity of Desires and Endeavours, which is supposed…