their faction takes its name; as it was possible that they had written to some bishop named
Donatus belonging to another section [heresy], especially since in these names no mention
had been made of Africa. How then, I asked, could it be proved that we must believe the
Donatus here named to be the Donatist bishop, when it could not even be proved that this
letter had been specially directed to bishops in Africa? For although Donatus is a common
African name, there is nothing improbable in the supposition, that either some one in other
countries should be found bearing an African name, or that a native of Africa should be
made a bishop there. We found, moreover, no day or name of consul given in the letter,
from which any certain light might have been furnished by comparison of dates. I had indeed
once heard that the Arians, when they had separated from the Catholic communion, had
endeavoured to ally the Donatists in Africa with themselves; and my brother Alypius recalled
this to me at the time in a whisper. Having then taken up the volume itself, and glancing
over the decrees of the said Council, I read that Athanasius, Catholic bishop of Alexandria,
who was so conspicuous as a debater in the keen controversies with the Arians, and Julius,
bishop of the Roman Church, also a Catholic, had been condemned by that Council of
Sardica; from which we were sure that it was a Council of Arians, against which heretics
these Catholic bishops had contended with singular fervour. I therefore wished to take up
and carry with me the volume, in order to give more pains to find out the date of the
Council. He refused it, however, saying that I could get it there if I wished to study anything
in it. I asked also that he would allow me to mark the volume; for I feared, I confess, lest, if
perchance necessity arose for my asking to consult it, another should be substituted in its
room. This also he refused.
Chap. IV.
7. Thereafter he began to insist upon my answering categorically this question:
Whether I thought the persecutor or the persecuted to be in the right? To which I answered,
that the question was not fairly stated: it might be that both were in the wrong, or that the
persecution might be made by the one who was the more righteous of the two parties; and
therefore it was not always right to infer that one is on the better side because he suffers
persecution, although that is almost always the case. When I perceived that he still laid great
stress upon this, wishing to have the justice of the cause of his party acknowledged as beyond
dispute because they had suffered persecution, I asked him whether he believed Ambrose,
bishop of the Church of Milan, to be a righteous man and a Christian? He was compelled
to deny expressly that that man was a Christian and a righteous man; for if he had admitted
this, I would at once have objected to him that he esteemed it necessary for him to be rebap-
tized. When, therefore, he was compelled to pronounce concerning Ambrose that he was
not a Christian nor a righteous man, I related the persecution which he endured when his
church was surrounded with soldiers. I also asked whether Maximianus, who had made a
schism from their party at Carthage, was in his view a righteous man and a Christian. He
650
To Eleusius, Glorius, and the Two Felixes