Chapter I.
The Arian argument from S. Mark x. 18, “There is none good but one, that is, God,” refuted
by explanation of these words of Christ.
15. The objection I have now to face, your sacred Majesty, fills me with bewilderment,
my soul and body faint at the thought that there should be men, or rather not men, but beings
with the outward appearance of men, but inwardly full of brutish folly—who can, after re-
ceiving at the hands of the Lord benefits so many and so great, say that the Author of all
good things is Himself not good.
16. It is written, say they, that “There is none good but God alone.” I acknowledge the
Scripture—but there is no falsehood in the letter; would that there were none in the Arians’
exposition thereof. The written signs are guiltless, it is the meaning in which they are
226
taken1141 that is to blame. I acknowledge the words as the words of our Lord and Sa-
viour—but let us bethink ourselves when, to whom, and with what comprehension He
speaks.
17. The Son of God is certainly speaking as man, and speaking to a scribe,—to him, that
is, who called the Son of God “Good Master,” but would not acknowledge Him as God.
What he believes not, Christ further gives him to understand, to the end that he may believe
in God’s Son not as a good master, but as the good God, for if, wheresoever the “One God”
is named, the Son of God is never sundered from the fulness of that unity, how, when God
alone is said to be good, can the Only-begotten be excluded from the fulness of Divine
Goodness? The Arians must therefore either deny that the Son of God is God, or confess
that God is good.
18. With divinely inspired comprehension, then, our Lord said, not “There is none good
but the Father alone,” but “There is none good but God alone,” and “Father” is the proper
name of Him Who begets. But the unity of God by no means excludes the Godhead of the
Three Persons, and therefore it is His Nature that is extolled. Goodness, therefore, is of the
nature of God, and in the nature of God, again, exists the Son of God—wherefore that which
the predicate expresses belongs not to one single Person, but to the [complete] unity [of the
Godhead].1142
19. The Lord, then, doth not deny His goodness—He rebukes this sort of disciple. For
when the scribe said, “Good Master,” the Lord answered, “Why callest thou Me
good?”—which is to say, “It is not enough to call Him good, Whom thou believest not to
1141 “Sensus in crimine.” The “sense of a passage” is not something in the passage itself so much as our un-
derstanding of it. In other words, the genitive after “sense” is objective, not possessive.
1142 Lat.—“non quod singularitatis, sed quod unitatis est, prædicatur.” The Son is “in the nature of God”
inasmuch as the eternal Fatherhood of God implies an Eternal Son—His eternal Love an eternal object of that
Love.
Chapter I. The Arian argument from S. Mark x. 18, “There is none good but one, that is, God,” refuted by explanation of these words of Christ.
500
Chapter I. The Arian argument from S. Mark x. 18, “There is none good but…