It has been a much discussed question, whether Helena was
legitimate wife or not. Some (Zosimus 2. 8; Niceph. Callist. 7. 18)
have asserted that Helena was a woman “indifferent honest,”
and the birth of Constantine illegitimate. This view is simply
psychologically impossible regarding a woman of so much and such
strength of character. That she stood in the relation of legitimate
concubinage (cf. Smith and Cheetham, Dict. 1. 422) is not
improbable, since many (Hieron. Orosius, Zosimus 2.8; Chron. Pasch. p.
516, and others) assert this lesser relationship. This would have been
not unlike a modern morganatic marriage. The facts are: 1. That she is
often spoken of as concubine (cf. above). 2. That she is distinctly
called wife, and that by some of the most competent authorities
(Eutrop. 10. 2; Anon. Vales. p. 471; Euseb. H. E. 8. 13; Ephraem
p. 21, etc.), also in various inscriptions (compare collected
inscriptions in Clinton 2. 81). 3. That she was divorced (Anon. Vales.
p. 47). The weight of testimony is clearly in favor of the word
“wife,” though with divorce so easy it seems to have been a
name only. The view that she was married in the full legal sense, but
only after the birth of Constantine, is plausible enough, and has a
support more apparent than real, in the fact that he “first
established that natural children should be made legitimate by the
subsequent marriage of their parents” (Sandars Inst. Just.
(1865) 113; cf. Cod. Just. V. xxvii. 1 and 5 ed. Krueger 2 (1877)
216).
Of course the story of
her violation by and subsequent marriage to Constantius (Inc. auct. ed.
Heydenreich) is purely legendary, and the same may be said of the
somewhat circumstantial account of her relation as concubine, given by
Nicephorus Callistus 7, 18. For farther account of Helena, compare the
V. C. 3. 42 and notes.