Plato accordingly having learned this in
Egypt, and being greatly taken with what was
said about one God, did indeed consider it un-
safe to mention the name of Moses, on account
of his teaching the doctrine of one only God,
for he dreaded the Areopagus ; but what is very
well expressed by him in his elaborate treatise,
the Timceus, he has written in exact correspond-
ence with what Moses said regarding God,
though he has done so, not as if he had learned
it from him, but as if he were expressing his
own opinion. For he said, " In my opinion,
then, we must first define what that is which
exists eternally, and has no generation,' and
what that is which is always being generated,
but never really is." Does not this, ye men of
Greece, seem to those who are able to under-
stand the matter to be one and the same thing,
saving only the difference of the article? For
Moses said, ''He who is," and Plato, "That
which is." But either of the expressions seems
to apply to the ever-existent God. For He is
the only one who eternally exists, and has no
generation. What, then, that other thing is
which is contrasted with the ever-existent, and
of which he said, " And what that is which is
always being generated, but never really is," we
must attentively consider. For we shall find
him clearly and evidently saying that He who is
unbegotten is eternal, but that those that are
begotten and made are generated and perish^ —
as he said of the same class, " gods of gods, of
whom I am maker" — for he speaks in the fol-
lowing words : " In my opinion, then, we must
first define what that is which is always existent
and has no birth, and what that is which is
always being generated but never really is. The
former, indeed, which is apprehended by reflec-
tion combined with reason, always exists in the
same way ; ^ while the latter, on the other hand,
is conjectured by opinion formed by the percep-
tion of the senses unaided by reason, since it
never really is, but is coming into being 'and
perishing." These expressions declare to those
who can rightly understand them the death and
destruction of the gods that have been brought
into being. And I think it necessary to attend
to this also, that Plato never names him the
creator, but the fashioner * of the gods, although,
in the opinion of Plato, there is considerable
difference between these two. For the creator
creates the creature by his own capability and