Meanwhile, Athanasius had been peacefully
pursuing his diocesan duties, but not without a careful outlook as the
clouds gathered on the horizon. The prospect of a revival of the
charges against him moved him to set in order an unanswerable array of
documents, in proof, firstly of the unanimity, secondly of the good
reason, with which he had been acquitted of them (see p. 97). He had
also, in view of revived assertions of Arianism, drawn up the two
letters or memoranda on the rationale of the Nicene formula and on the
opinion ascribed to his famous predecessor, Dionysius (the
Apology was probably written about 351, the date of the de
Decr., and de Sent. Dion. In de
Sent. Dion. 23, 24, Arius is spoken of in a way consistent with his
being still alive. But the phase of the Arian controversy to which the
tract relates begins a decade after Arius’ death, and we
therefore follow the indications which class the de Sent. with
the de Decr. falls a little
later). In 353 he began to apprehend danger, from the hopes with which
the establishment of Constantius in the sole possession of the Empire
was inspiring his enemies, headed by Valens in the West, and Acacius of
Cæsarea in the East. Accordingly, he despatched a powerful
deputation to Constantius, who was then at Milan, headed by Serapion,
his most trusted suffragan (cf. p. 560, note 3a; p. 497, §3,
copied by Soz. iv. 9; Fest. Ind. xxv.). The legates sailed May
19, but on the 23rd Montanus, an officer of the Palace, arrived with an
Imperial letter, declining to receive any legates, but granting an
alleged request of Athanasius to be allowed to come to Italy (p. 245
sq.). As he had made no request of the kind, Athanasius
naturally suspected a plot to entice him away from his stronghold. The
letter of Constantius did not convey an absolute command, so
Athanasius, protesting his willingness to come when ordered to do so,
resolved to remain where he was for the present. ‘All the people
were exceedingly troubled,’ according to our chroniclers.
‘In this year Montanus was sent against the bishop, but a tumult
having been excited, he retired without effect.’ Two years and
two months later, i.e., in July–Aug. 355 (p. 497), force was
attempted instead of stratagem, which the proceedings of Arles had, of
course, made useless. ‘In this year Diogenes, the Secretary of
the Emperor, came with the intention of seizing the bishop,’ and
‘Diogenes pressed hard upon all, trying to dislodge the bishop
from the city, and he afflicted all pretty severely; but on Sept. 4 All the
following dates are affected by Leap-Year, 355–6, see Table C, p.
501, and correct p. 246, note 3, to Jan. 6. he pressed sharply, and stormed a Church, and
this he did continually for four months…until Dec. 23. But as the
people and magistrates vehemently withstood Diogenes, he returned back
without effect on the 23rd of December aforesaid’ (Fest.
Ind. xxvii., Hist. Aceph. iii.). The fatal blow was clearly
imminent. By this time the exiles had begun to arrive in the East, and
rumours came Definite
information came only after Feb. 8, see p. 248. that not even the powerful and popular
Liberius, not even ‘Father’ Hosius himself, had been
spared. Athanasius might well point out to Dracontius (p. 558) that in
declining the bishopric of the ‘country district of
Alexandria’ he was avoiding the post of danger. On the sixth of
January the ‘Duke’ Syrianus arrived in Alexandria,
concentrating in the city drafts from all the legions stationed in
Egypt and Libya. Rumour was active as to the intentions of the
commandant, and Athanasius felt justified in asking him whether he came
with any orders from the Court. Syrianus replied that he did not, and
Athanasius then produced the letter of Constantius referred to above
(written 350–351). The magistrates and people joined in the
remonstrance, and at last Syrianus protested ‘by the life of
Cæsar’ that he would remain quiet until the matter had been
referred to the Emperor. This restored confidence, and on Thursday
night, Feb. 8, Athanasius was presiding at a crowded service of
preparation for a Communion on the following morning (Friday after
Septuagesima) in the Church of Theonas, which with the exception of the
unfinished Cæsareum was the largest in the city (p. 243). Suddenly
the church was surrounded and the doors broken in, and just after
midnight Syrianus and the ‘notary’ Hilary ‘entered
with an infinite force of soldiers.’ Athanasius (his fullest
account is p. 263) calmly took his seat upon the throne (in the recess
of the apse), and ordered the deacon to begin the 136th psalm, the
people responding at each verse ‘for His mercy endureth for
ever.’ Meanwhile the soldiers crowded up to the chancel, and in
spite of entreaties the bishop refused to escape until the congregation
were in safety. He ordered the prayers to proceed, and only at the last
moment a crowd of monks and clergy seized the Archbishop and managed to
convey him in the confusion out of the church in a half-fainting state
(protest of Alexandrians, p. 301), but thankful that he had been able to secure
the escape of his people before his own (p. 264). From that moment
Athanasius was lost to public view for ‘six years and fourteen
days’ (Hist. Aceph., i.e., Mechir 13, 356–Mechir 27,
362), ‘for he remembered that which was written, Hide thyself as
it were for a little moment, until the indignation be overpast (pp.
288, 252, 262). Constantius and the Arians had planned their blow with
skill and delivered it with decisive effect. But they had won a
‘Cadmean Victory.’