Let him choose which he likes of
these alternatives: whichever it is I do not see how he can avoid the
inevitable crime of blasphemy: whether he says the Spirit is subject in the
manner of the brute creation, as fish and birds and sheep, to man, or
were to fetch Him a captive to a superior power after the manner of a
rebel. Or does he mean neither of these ways, but uses the word in a
different signification altogether to the scripture meaning? What,
then, is that signification? Does he lay down that we must rank Him as
inferior and not as equal, because He was given by our Lord to His
disciples third in order? By the same reasoning he should make the
Father inferior to the Son, since the Scripture often places the name
of our Lord first, and the Father Almighty second. “I and My
Father,” our Lord says. “The grace of our Lord Jesus
Christ, and the love of God John x. 30; 2 Cor. xiii.
13.,” and other
passages innumerable which the diligent student of Scripture
testimonies might collect: for instance, “there are differences
of gifts, but it is the same Spirit: and there are differences of
administration, but it is the same Lord: and there are differences of
operations, but it is the same God.” According to this, then, let
the Almighty Father, who is mentioned third, be made
‘subject’ to the Son and the Spirit. However we have never
yet heard of a philosophy such as this, which relegates to the category
of the inferior and the dependent that which is mentioned second or
third only for some particular reason of sequence: yet that is what our
author wants to do, in arguing to show that the order observed in the
transmission of the Persons amounts to differences of more and less in
dignity and nature. In fact he rules that sequence in point of order is
indicative of unlikeness of nature: whence he got this fancy, what
necessity compelled him to it, is not clear. Mere numerical rank does
not create a different nature: that which we would count in a number
remains the same in nature whether we count it or not. Number is a mark
only of the mere quantity of things: it does not place second those
things only which have an inferior natural value, but it makes the
sequence of the numerical objects indicated in accordance with the
intention of those who are counting. ‘Paul and Silvanus and
Timotheus’ are three persons mentioned according to a particular
intention. Does the place of Silvanus, second and after Paul, indicate
that he was other than a man? Or is Timothy, because he is third,
considered by the writer who so ranks him a different kind of being?
Not so. Each is human both before and after this arrangement. Speech,
which cannot utter the names of all three at once, mentions each
separately according to an order which commends itself, but unites them
by the copula, in order that the juncture of the names may show the
harmonious action of the three towards one end.