And if he who is subject to control cannot create free beings (for he cannot of his own will
confer on others what he does not possess himself), then the Saviour, since He made us free,
cannot Himself be under the control of any.”
“If the Son could do nothing of Himself, and could only act at the bidding of the Father,
He is neither good nor bad. He was not responsible for anything that was done. Consider
the absurdity of the position that men should be free agents both of good and evil, while the
Son, who is God, should be able to do nothing of His own authority!”
On John xv. 1. “I am the Vine.”
“If, say they, the Saviour is a vine, and we are branches, but the Father is husbandman;
and if the branches are of one nature with the vine, and the vine is not of one nature with
the husbandman; then the Son is of one nature with us, and we are a part of Him, but the
Son is not of one nature with, but in all respects of a nature foreign to, the Father, I shall
reply to them that He called us branches not of His Godhead, but of His flesh, as the Apostle
says, we are ‘the body of Christ, and members in particular,’397 and again, ‘know ye not that
xl
your bodies are the members of Christ?’398 and in other places, ‘as is the earthy, such are
they that are earthy; and as is the heavenly, such are they also that are heavenly. And as we
have borne the image of the earthy, let us all bear the image of the heavenly.’399 If the head
of the ‘man is Christ, and the head of Christ is God,’400 and man is not of one substance
with Christ, Who is God (for man is not God), but Christ is of one substance with God (for
He is God) therefore God is not the head of Christ in the same sense as Christ is the head
of man. The natures of the creature and the creative Godhead do not exactly coincide. God
is head of Christ, as Father; Christ is head of us, as Maker. If the will of the Father is that
we should believe in His Son (for this is the will of Him that sent me, that every one which
seeth the Son, and believeth on Him, may have everlasting life),401 the Son is not a Son of
will. That we should believe in Him is (an injunction) found with Him, or before Him.”402
397 1 Cor. xii. 27.
398 1 Cor. vi. 15.
399 1 Cor. xv. 48, 49: in the last clause Basil reads φορέσωμεν, instead of the φορέσομεν of A.V., with , A,
C, D, E, F, G, K, L, P.
400 1 Cor. xi. 3.
401 John vi. 40.
402 i.e.simultaneous with, or even anterior to, His advent. Maran hesitates as to the meaning of the phrase,
and writes: “Suspicor tamen intelligi sic posse. Quanquam voluntas patris est ut in Filium credamus, non tamen
propterea sequitur, Filium ex voluntate esse. Nam credere nos oportet in Filium, ut primum in hunc mundum
venit, imo antequam etiam naturam humanam assumeret, cum patriarchæ et Judæi prisci ad salutem consequendam
in Christum venturum credere necesse habuerint. Itaque cum debeamus necessario credere in Filium omni ætate
et tempore; hinc efficitur, Filium esse natura, non voluntate, neque adoptione. Si voluntas est Patris ut nos in
66
Dogmatic.