Known as Sixtus II. in the list of Roman bishops. On Sixtus I. see
above, Bk. IV. chap. 4, note 3. That Xystus (or Sixtus) was martyred
under Valerian we are told not only by the Liberian catalogue, but also
by Cyprian, in an epistle written shortly before his own death, in 258
(No. 81, al. 80), in which he gives a detailed account of it.
There is no reason to doubt the date given by the Liberian catalogue
(Aug. 6, 258); for the epistle of Cyprian shows that it must have taken
place just about that time, Valerian having sent a very severe rescript
to the Senate in the summer of 258. This fixed point for the martyrdom
of Xystus enables us to rectify all the dates of the bishops of this
period (cf. Lipsius, l.c.). As to the duration of his
episcopate, the ancient authorities differ greatly. The Liberian
catalogue assigns to it two years eleven months and six days, but this
is impossible, as can be gathered from Cyprian’s epistle. Lipsius
retains the months and days (twelve or six days), rejecting the two
years as an interpolation, and thus putting his accession on Aug. 24
(or 31), 257. According to Eusebius, chap. 27, and the Armenian
Chron., he held office eleven years, which is quite impossible,
and which, as Lipsius remarks, is due to the eleven months which stood
in the original source from which the notice was taken, and which
appears in the Liberian catalogue. Jerome’s version of the
Chron. ascribes eight years to his episcopate, but this, too, is
quite impossible, and the date given for his accession (the first year
of Valerian) is inconsistent with the notice which he gives in regard
to Stephen. Xystus upheld the Roman practice of accepting heretics and
schismatics without re-baptism, but he seems to have adopted a more
conciliatory tone toward those who held the opposite view than his
predecessor Stephen had done (cf. Pontius’ Vita Cypriani,
chap. 14).