Now the fathers of this council could not make such a profession if they had condemned
the Sacrosant Synod of Nice, which had been confirmed by the Apostolic See. For as I have
shown above they could not have been misled by false information upon this point. If
therefore knowingly and through heretical pravity they did these things, so too they did
them out of pertinacity and heresy; and so concerning the authority of the Apostolic See
one way they had thought and another way spoken. But in my judgment such things are
not to be imputed to so great and to such an assembly of bishops, for it is not likely that the
fathers of this council, in the presence of the legates of the Supreme Pontiff and of a Catholic
Prince, would have condemned the Seventh Synod, confirmed as it was by the authority of
the Pontiff and have referred the matter to Hadrian the Supreme Pontiff.
Moreover it would have surely come to pass that if the Nicene Council had been con-
demned by the authority of this synod, and so the error of the Iconoclasts had been approved
through erroneous information, before our days some follower of that error would have
tried to back up himself and his opinion by its authority: but no one did this, and this is all
the more noteworthy since, only shortly after the time of Charlemagne, Claudius of Turin
sprang up in that very Gaul, and wished to introduce that error into the Western Church,
and he could have confirmed his teaching in the highest manner if he could have shewn
that that plenary council of the West had confirmed his error. But as a matter of fact
Claudius did not quote it in his favour; nor did Jonas of Orleans, who wrote against him at
that time, and overthrew his foundations, make any mention in this respect of the Council
of Frankfort in his response.
Lastly I add that the Roman Church never gave its approbation and received any pro-
vincial synod, so far as one part of its action was concerned while in another part it was
persistently heretical. But this provincial council so far as it defined concerning the servitude
and filiation of Christ was received and approved by the Church, it is not then credible that
in the same council the Nicene Synod would have been condemned.
586
I need only add that every proposed theory is so full of difficulties as to seem to involve
more absurdities and improbabilities than it explains. The reader is referred especially to
Vasquez (De adorat. imag., Lib. II., Dispt. VII., cap. vij.) and to Suarez (Tom. I, Disp. LIV.,
Sec. iij.), for learned and instructive discussions of the whole matter.
1077
Excursus on the Council of Frankfort, A.D. 794.