132
in that opposition, and a tendency to public benefit in the favour that excites his gratitude.
But how far is this from being true! For instance; a ship’s crew enter into a conspiracy against
the master, to murder him, and run away with the ship, and turn pirates: but before they
bring their matters to ripeness of execution, one of them repents, and opens the whole
design; whereupon the rest are apprehended and brought to justice. The crew are enraged
with him that has betrayed them, and earnestly seek opportunity to revenge themselves upon
him. And for an instance of gratitude: a gang of robbers that have long infested the neigh-
boring country, have a particular house whither they resort, and where they meet from time
to time, to divide their booty, and hold their consultations for carrying on their pernicious
designs. The magistrates and officers of the country, after many fruitless endeavours to
discover their secret place of resort, at length are well-informed where it is, and are prepared
with sufficient force to surprise them, and seize them all, at the place of rendezvous, at an
hour appointed, when they understand they will all be there. A little before the arrival of
the appointed hour, while the officers with their bands are approaching, some person is so
kind to these robbers, as to give them notice of their danger, so as just to give them oppor-
tunity to escape. They are thankful to him, and give him a handful of money for his kindness.
Now, in such instances, I think it is plain, that there is no supposition of a public injury in
that which is the occasion of their anger; yea, they know the contrary. Nor is there any
supposition of public good in that which excites their gratitude; neither has public benevol-
ence, or moral sense, consisting in a determination to approve of what is for the public good,
any influence at all in the affair. And though there be some affection, besides a sense of
uniformity and proportion, that has influence in such anger and gratitude, it is not public
affection or benevolence, but private affection; yea, that affection which is to the highest
degree private, consisting in a man’s love of his own person.
5. The passion of anger, in particular, seems to have been unluckily chosen as a medium
to prove a sense and determination to delight in virtue, consisting in benevolence natural
to all mankind. For if that moral sense which is exercised in anger, were that which arose
from a benevolent temper of heart, being no other than a sense or relish of the beauty of
benevolence, one would think, a disposition to anger should increase, at least in some pro-
portion, as a man had more of a sweet, benign, and benevolent temper: which seems contrary
to experience, which shows that the less men have of benevolence, and the more they have
of a contrary temper, the more are they disposed to anger and deep resentment of injuries.
And though gratitude be that which many speak of as a certain noble principle of virtue,
which God has implanted in the hearts of all mankind; and though it be true there is a
gratitude that is truly virtuous; and the want of gratitude, or an ungrateful temper, is truly
vicious, and argues an abominable depravity of heart; yet I think, what has been observed
may serve to convince such as impartially consider it, not only that not all anger, or hating
892
CHAPTER IV. Of self-love and its influence.