Dialogue I.—The
Immutable.
Orthodoxos and
Eranistes.
Orth.
—Better were it for us to agree and abide by the apostolic
doctrine in its purity. But since, I know not how, you have broken the
harmony, and are now offering us new doctrines, let us, if you please,
with no kind of quarrel, investigate the truth.
Eran.
—We need no investigation, for we exactly hold the
truth.
Orth.
—This is what every heretic supposes. Aye, even Jews and
Pagans reckon that they are defending the doctrines of the truth; and
so also do not only the followers of Plato and Pythagoras, but
Epicureans too, and they that are wholly without God or belief. It
becomes us, however, not to be the slaves of a priori assumption, but
to search for the knowledge of the truth.
Eran.
—I admit the force of what you say and am ready to act on
your suggestion.
Orth.
—Since then you have made no difficulty in yielding to this
my preliminary exhortation, I ask you in the next place not to suffer
the investigation of the truth to depend on the reasonings of men, but
to track the footprints of the apostles and prophets, and saints who
followed them. For so wayfarers when they wander from the high-road are
wont to consider well the pathways, if haply they shew any prints of
men or horses or asses or mules going this way or that, and when they
find any such they trace the tracks as dogs do and leave them not till
once more they are in the right road.
Eran.
—So let us do. Lead on yourself, as you began the
discussion.
Orth
—Let us, therefore, first make careful and thorough
investigation into the divine names,—I mean substance, and
essences, and persons and proprieties, and let us learn and define how
they differ the one from the other. Then let us thus handle afterwards
what follows.
Eran.
—You give us a very admirable and proper introduction to our
argument. When these points are clear, our discussion will go forward
without let or obstacle.
Orth.
—Since we have decided then that this must be our course of
procedure, tell me, my friend, do we acknowledge one substance of God,
alike of Father and of the only begotten Son and of the Holy Ghost, as
we have been taught by Holy Scripture, both Old and New, and by the
Fathers in Council in Nicæa, or do we follow the blasphemy of
Arius?
Eran.
—We confess one substance of the Holy Trinity.
Orth.
—And do we reckon hypostasis to signify anything else than
substance, or do we take it for another name of substance?
Eran.
—Is there any difference between substance and hypostasis?
972
Orth
—In extra Christian philosophy there is not, for
οὐσία
signifies
τὸ ὄν
, that which
is, and
ὑπόστασις
that which subsists. But according to the doctrine of
the Fathers there is the same difference between
οὐσία
and
ὑπόστασις
as between the common and the particular, and the species
and the individual.
Eran.
—Tell me more clearly what is meant by race or kind, and
species and individual.
Orth.
—We speak of race or
kind with regard to the animal, for it means many things at once. It
indicates both the rational and the irrational; and again there are
many species of irrational, creatures that fly, creatures that are
amphibious, creatures that go on foot, and creatures that swim. And of
these species each is marked by many subdivisions; of creatures that go
on foot there is the lion, the leopard, the bull, and countless others.
So, too, of flying creatures and the rest there are many species; yet
all of them, though the species are the aforesaid, belong to one and
the same animal race. Similarly the name man is the common name of
mankind; for it means the Roman, the Athenian, the Persian, the
Sauromatian,
973
the Egyptian, and, in a word, all
who are human, but the name Paulus or Petrus does not signify what is
common to the kind but some particular man; for no one on hearing of
Paul turns in thought to Adam or Abraham or Jacob, but thinks of him
alone whose name he has heard. But if he hears the word man simply, he
does not fix his mind on the individual, but bethinks him of the
Indian, the Scythian, and the Massagete, and of all the race of men
together, and we learn this not only from nature, but also from Holy
Scripture, for God said, we read, “I will destroy man from the
face of the earth,”
974
and this he spake
of countless multitudes, and when more than two thousand and two
hundred years had gone by after Adam, he brought universal destruction
on men through the flood, and so the blessed David says: “Man
that is in honour and understandeth not,”
975
accusing not one here nor one there, but all men in common. A thousand
similar examples might be found, but we must not be tedious.
Eran.
—The difference between the common and the proper is shewed
clearly. Now let us return to discussion about
οὐσία
and
ὑπόστασις
Orth.
—As then the name man is common to human nature, so we
understand the divine substance to indicate the Holy Trinity; but the
hypostasis denotes any person, as the Father, the Son and the Holy
Ghost; for, following the definitions of the Holy Fathers, we say that
hypostasis and individuality mean the same thing.
Eran.
—We agree that this is so.
Orth.
—Whatever then is predicated of the divine nature is common
both to the Father, to the Son, and to the Holy Ghost, as for instance
“God,” “Lord,” “Creator,”
“Almighty,” and so forth.
Eran.
—Without question these words are common to the
Trinity.
Orth.
—But all that naturally denotes the hypostasis ceases to be
common to the Holy Trinity, and denotes the hypostasis to which it is
proper, as, for instance, the names “Father,”
“Unbegotten,” are peculiar to the Father; while again the
names “Son,” “Only Begotten,” “God the
Word,” do not denote the Father, nor yet the Holy Ghost, but the
Son, and the words “Holy Ghost,” “Paraclete,”
naturally denote the hypostasis of the Spirit.
Eran.
—But does not Holy Scripture call both the Father and the
Son “Spirit”?
Orth.
—Yes, it calls both the Father and the Son
“Spirit,” signifying by this term the incorporeal
illimitable character of the divine nature. The Holy Scripture only
calls the hypostasis of the Spirit “Holy Ghost.”
Eran.
—This is indisputable.
Orth.
—Since then we assert that some terms are common to the Holy
Trinity, and some peculiar to each hypostasis, do we assert the term
“immutable” to be common to the substance or peculiar to
any hypostasis?
Eran.
—The term “immutable” is common to the Trinity,
for it is impossible for part of the substance to be mutable and part
immutable.
Orth.
—You have well said, for as the term mortal is common to
mankind, so are “immutable” and “invariable” to
the Holy Trinity. So the only-begotten Son is immutable, as are both
the Father that begat Him and the Holy Ghost.
Eran.
—Immutable.
Orth.
—How then do you advance the statement in the gospel
“the word became flesh,”
976
and
predicate mutation of the immutable nature?
Eran.
—We assert Him to have been made flesh not by mutation, but
as He Himself knows.
Orth.
—If He is not said to have become flesh by taking flesh, one
of two things must be asserted, either that he underwent the mutation
into flesh, or was only so seen in appearance, and in reality was God
without flesh.
Eran.
—This is the doctrine of the disciples of Valentinus,
Marcion, and of the Manichees, but we have been taught without dispute
that the divine Word was made flesh.
Orth.
—But in what sense do
you mean “was made flesh”? “Took flesh,” or
“was changed into flesh”?
Eran.
—As we have heard the evangelist say, “the word was
made flesh.”
Orth.
—In what sense do you understand “was
made”?
Eran.
—He who underwent mutation into flesh was made flesh, and,
as I said just now, as He knows. But we know that with Him all things
are possible,
977
for He changed the water of the
Nile into blood, and day into night, and made the sea dry land, and
filled the dry wilderness with water, and we hear the prophet saying
“Whatsoever the Lord pleased that did He in heaven, and in earth,
in the seas and all deep places.”
978
Orth.
—The creature is transformed by the Creator as He will, for
it is mutable and obeys the nod of Him that fashioned it. But His
nature is immutable and invariable, wherefore of the creature the
prophet saith “He that maketh and transformeth all
things.”
979
But of the divine Word the great
David says “Thou art the same and thy years shall not
fail.”
980
And again the same God says of
Himself “For I am the Lord and I change not.”
981
Eran.
—What is hidden ought not to “be enquired
into.”
Orth.
—Nor yet what is plain to be altogether ignored.
Eran.
—I am not aware of the manner of the incarnation. I have
heard that the Word was made flesh.
Orth.
—If He was made flesh by mutation He did not remain what He
was before, and this is easily intelligible from several analogies.
Sand, for instance, when it is subjected to heat, first becomes fluid,
then is changed and congealed into glass, and at the time of the change
alters its name, for it is no longer called sand but glass.
Eran.
—So it is.
Orth.
—And while we call the fruit of the vine grape, when once we
have pressed it, we speak of it no longer as grape, but as
wine.
Eran.
—Certainly.
Orth.
—And the wine itself, after it has undergone a change, it is
our custom to name no longer wine, but vinegar.
Eran.
—True.
Orth.
—And similarly stone when burnt and in solution is no longer
called stone, but lime. And innumerable other similar instances might
be found where mutation involves a change of name.
Eran.
—Agreed.
Orth.
—If therefore you assert that the Divine Word underwent the
change in the flesh, why do you call Him God and not flesh? for change
of name fits in with the alteration of nature. For if where the things
which undergo change have some relation to their former condition (for
there is a certain approximation of vinegar to wine and of wine to the
fruit of the vine, and of glass to sand) they receive another name
after their alteration, how, where the difference between them is
infinite and as wide as that which divides a gnat from the whole
visible and invisible creation (for so wide, nay much wider, is the
difference between the nature of flesh and of Godhead) is it possible
for the same name to obtain after the change?
Eran.
—I have said more than once that He was made flesh not by
mutation, but continuing still to be what He was, He was made what He
was not.
Orth.
—But unless this word “was made” becomes quite
clear it suggests mutation and alteration, for unless He was made flesh
by taking flesh He was made flesh by undergoing mutation.
Eran.
—But the word “take” is your own invention. The
Evangelist says the Word was made flesh.
982
Orth.
—You seem either to be ignorant of the sacred Scripture, or
to do it wrong knowingly. Now if you are ignorant, I will teach you; if
you are doing wrong, I will convict you. Answer then; do you
acknowledge the teaching of the divine Paul to be of the
Spirit?
Eran.
—Certainly.
Orth.
—And do you allow that the same Spirit wrought through both
Evangelists and Apostles?
Eran.
—Yes, for so have I learnt from the Apostolic Scripture
“There are diversities of gifts but the same spirit,”
983
and again “All these things
worketh that one and the selfsame spirit, dividing to every man
severally as He will,”
984
and again
“Having the same Spirit of the Faith.”
985
Orth.
—Your introduction of the apostolic testimony is in season.
If we assert that the instruction alike of the evangelists and of the
apostles is of the same spirit, listen how the apostle interprets the
words of the Gospel, for in the Epistle to the Hebrews he says,
“Verily he took not on him the
nature of angels, but he took
on him the seed of Abraham.”
986
Now tell me
what you mean by the seed of Abraham. Was not that which was naturally
proper to Abraham proper also to the seed of Abraham?
Eran.
—No; not without exception, for Christ did no
sin.
Orth.
—Sin is not of nature, but of corrupt will.
987
On this very account, therefore, I did
not say indefinitely what Abraham had, but what he had according to
nature, that is to say, body and reasonable soul. Now tell me plainly;
will you acknowledge that the seed of Abraham was endowed with body and
reasonable soul? If not, in this point you agree with the ravings of
Apollinarius. But I will compel you to confess this by other means.
Tell me now; had the Jews a body and a reasonable soul?
Eran.
—Of course they had.
Orth.
—So when we hear the prophet saying, “But thou,
Israel, art my servant, Jacob whom I have chosen, the seed of Abraham
my friend,”
988
are we to
understand the Jews to be bodies only? Are we not to understand them to
be men consisting of bodies and souls?
Eran.
—True.
Orth.
—And the seed of Abraham not without soul nor yet
intelligence, but with everything which characterizes the seed of
Abraham?
Eran.
—He who so says puts forward two sons.
Orth.
—But he who says that the Divine Word is changed into the
flesh does not even acknowledge one Son, for mere flesh by itself is
not a son; but we confess one Son who took upon Him the seed of
Abraham, according to the divine apostle, and wrought the salvation of
mankind. But if you do not accept the apostolic preaching, say so
openly.
Eran.
—But we maintain that the utterances of the apostles are
inconsistent, for there appears to be a certain inconsistency between
“the Word was made flesh” and “took upon Him the seed
of Abraham.”
Orth.
—It is because you lack intelligence, or because you are
arguing for arguing’s sake, that the consistent seems
inconsistent. It does not so appear to men who use sound reasoning; for
the divine apostle teaches that the Divine Word was made Flesh, not by
mutation, but by taking on Him the seed of Abraham. At the same time,
too, he recalls the promise given to Abraham. Or do you not remember
the promises given to the Patriarch by the God of the
Universe?
Eran.
—What promises?
Orth.
—When He brought him out of his father’s house, and
ordered him to come into Palestine, did He not say to him “I will
bless them that bless thee, and curse him that curseth thee, and in thy
seed
989
shall all families of the earth be
blessed”?
Eran.
—I remember these promises.
Orth.
—Remember, too, the covenants made by God with Isaac and
Jacob, for He gave them, too, the same promises, confirming the former
by the second and the third.
Eran.
—I remember them too.
Orth.
—It is in relation to these covenants that the divine
apostle writes in his Epistle to the Galatians “Now to Abraham
and his seed were the promises made.” He saith not
“seeds” as of many, but as of one…which is Christ,
990
very plainly showing that the manhood of
Christ sprang from the seed of Abraham, and fulfilled the promise made
to Abraham.
Eran.
—So the apostle says.
Orth.
—Enough has been said to remove all the controversy raised
on this point. But I will nevertheless remind you of another
prediction. The blessing given to the Patriarch Jacob and to his father
and his grandfather was given by him to his son Judah alone. He said
“A Prince shall not fail Judah, nor a leader from his loins,
until he shall have come to whom it is in store, and he is the
expectation of the Gentiles.”
991
Or do you not
accept this prediction as spoken of the Saviour Christ?
Eran.
—Jews give erroneous interpretations of prophecies of this
kind, but I am a Christian; I trust in the Divine word; and I receive
the prophecies without doubt.
Orth.
—Since then you confess that you believe the prophecies and
acknowledge the predictions have been divinely uttered about our
Saviour, consider what follows as to the intention of the words of the
apostle, for while pointing out that the promises made to the
patriarchs have reached their fulfilment, he uttered those remarkable
words
992
“He
took not on Him the nature of
angels,” all but saying the promise is true; the Lord has
fulfilled His pledges; the fount of blessing is open to the gentiles;
God had taken on Him the seed of Abraham; through it He brings about
the promised salvation; through it He confirms the promise of the
gentiles.
Eran.
—The words of the Prophet fit in admirably with those of the
apostle.
Orth.
—So again the divine apostle, reminding us of the blessing
of Judah, and pointing out how it received its fulfilment exclaims
993
“For it is evident that our Lord
sprang out of Judah.” So too the Prophet
994
Micah and the evangelist
995
Matthew. For the
former spoke his prediction, and the latter connects the prophecy with
his narrative. What is extraordinary is that he says that the open
enemies of the truth plainly told Herod that the Christ is born in
Bethlehem, for it is written, he says, “And thou Bethlehem in the
land of Judah art not the least among the Princes of Judah for out of
thee shall come a Governor who shall rule my people Israel.”
996
Now let us subjoin what the Jews in their
malignity omitted and so made the witness imperfect. For the prophet,
after saying “Out of thee shall he come forth unto me that is to
be Ruler in Israel” adds “Whose goings forth have been of
old, from everlasting.”
997
Eran.
—You have done well in adducing the whole evidence of the
Prophet, for he points out that He who was born in Bethlehem was
God.
Orth.
—Not God only but also Man; Man as sprung from Judah after
the flesh and born in Bethlehem; and God as existing before the ages.
For the words “Out of thee shall he come forth unto me that is to
be Ruler,” shew his birth after the flesh which has taken place
in the last days; while the words “Whose goings forth have been
of old, from everlasting” plainly proclaim His existence before
the ages. In like manner also the divine apostle in his Epistle to the
Romans bewailing the change to the worse of the ancient felicity of the
Jews, and calling to mind their divine promises and legislation, goes
on to say “Whose are the fathers, and of whom concerning the
flesh Christ came, who is over all God blessed for ever Amen,”
998
and in this same passage he exhibits Him
both as Creator of all things and Lord and Ruler as God and as sprung
from the Jews as man.
Eran.
—Well; you have explained these passages, what should you
say to the prophecy of Jeremiah? For this proclaims him to be God
only.
Orth.
—Of what prophecy do you speak?
Eran.
—“This is our God and there shall none other be
accounted of in comparison to him—he hath found out all the way
of knowledge, and hath given it unto Jacob his servant and to Israel
his beloved. Afterward did he shew himself upon earth and conversed
with men.”
999
In these words the Prophet
speaks neither of the flesh, nor of manhood, nor of man, but of God
alone.
Orth.
—What then is the good of reasoning? Do we say that the
Divine nature is invisible? or do we dissent from the Apostle when he
says
1000
“Immortal, invisible, the only
God.”
Eran.
—Indubitably the Divine nature is invisible.
Orth.
—How then was it possible for the invisible nature to be
seen without a body? Or do you not remember those words of the apostle
in which he distinctly teaches the invisibility of the divine nature?
He says “Whom no man hath seen nor can see.”
1001
If therefore the Divine Nature is invisible to
men, and I will add too to Angels, tell me how he who cannot be seen or
beheld was seen upon earth?
Eran.
—The Prophet says
1002
he was seen on the
earth.
Orth.
—And the apostle says
1003
“Immortal, invisible, the only God” and
1004
“Whom no man hath seen and can
see.”
Eran.
—What then? is the Prophet lying?
Orth.
—God forbid. Both utterances are the words of the Holy
Ghost.
Eran.
—Let us inquire then how the invisible was seen.
Orth.
—Do not, I beg you, bring in human reason. I shall yield to
scripture alone.
Eran.
—You shall receive no argument unconfirmed by Holy
Scripture, and if you bring me any solution of the question deduced
from Holy Scripture I will receive it, and will in no wise gainsay
it.
Orth.
—You know how a moment ago we
made the word of the
evangelist clear by means of the testimony of the apostle; and that the
divine apostle showed us how the Word became Flesh, saying plainly
“for verily He took not on Him the nature of angels but He took
on Him the seed of Abraham.”
1005
The same teacher
will teach us how the divine Word was seen upon the earth and dwelt
among men.
Eran.
—I submit to the words both of apostles and of prophets.
Shew me then in accordance with your promise the interpretation of the
prophecy.
Orth.
—The divine apostle, writing to Timothy, also says
“without controversy great is the mystery of godliness. God was
manifest in the flesh, justified in the spirit, seen of angels,
preached unto the Gentiles, believed on in the world, received up into
glory.”
1006
It is therefore plain that the
divine nature is invisible, but the flesh visible, and that through the
visible the invisible was seen, by its means working wonders and
unveiling its own power, for with the hand He fashioned the sense of
seeing and healed him that was blind from birth. Again He gave the
power of hearing to the deaf, and loosed the fettered tongue, using his
fingers for a tool and applying his spittle like some healing medicine.
So again when He walked upon the sea He displayed the almighty power of
the Godhead. Fitly, therefore, did the apostle say “God was
manifest in the flesh.” For through it appeared the invisible
nature beheld by its means by the angel hosts, for “He was
seen,” he says, “of angels.”
The nature then of bodiless
beings has shared with us the enjoyment of this boon.
Eran.
—Then did not the angels see God before the manifestation of
the Saviour?
Orth.
—The apostle says that He “was made manifest in the
flesh and seen of angels.”
Eran.
—But the Lord said, “Take heed that ye despise not one
of these little ones, for I say unto you that their angels do always
behold the face of my Father which is in heaven.”
1007
Orth.
—But the Lord said again, “Not that any man hath seen
the Father save he which is of God, he hath seen the Father.”
1008
Wherefore the evangelist plainly exclaims,
“No man hath seen God at any time,”
1009
and
confirms the word of the Lord, for he says, “The only begotten
Son which is in the bosom of the Father He hath declared Him,”
and the great Moses, when he desired to see the invisible nature, heard
the Lord God saying, “There shall no man see me and
live.”
1010
Eran.
—How then are we to understand the words, “Their
angels do always behold the face of my Father which is in
heaven”?
Orth.
—Just as we commonly understand what is said about men who
have been supposed to see God.
Eran.
—Pray make this plainer, for I do not understand. Can God be
seen of men also?
Orth.
—Certainly not.
Eran.
—Yet we hear the divine scripture saying God appeared unto
Abraham at the oak of Mamre;
1011
and Isaiah says
“I saw the Lord sitting upon a throne high and lifted
up,”
1012
and the same thing is said by Micah,
by Daniel and Ezekiel. And of the lawgiver Moses it is related that
“The Lord spake to Moses face to face as a man speaketh unto his
friend,”
1013
and the God of the
universe Himself said, “With him will I speak mouth to mouth,
even apparently and not in dark speeches.”
1014
What then shall we say; did they behold the
divine nature?
Orth.
—By no means, for God Himself said, “There shall no
man see me and live.”
Eran.
—Then they who say that they have seen God are
liars?
Orth.
—God forbid—they saw what it was possible for them to
see.
Eran.
—Then the loving Lord accommodates his revelation to the
capacity of them that see Him?
Orth.
—Yes; and this He has shewn through the Prophet, “for
I,” He says, “have multiplied visions and by the hands of
the Prophets was made like.”
1015
He does not say “was
seen” but “was made like.” And making like does not
shew the very nature of the thing seen. For even the image of the
emperor does not exhibit the emperor’s nature, though it
distinctly preserves his features.
Eran.
—This is obscure and not suffi
ciently plain. Was not then
the substance of God seen by them who beheld those
revelations?
Orth.
—No; for who is mad enough to dare to say so?
Eran.
—But yet it is said that they saw.
Orth.
—Yes; it is said; but we both in the exercise of reverent
reason, and in reliance on the Divine utterances, which exclaim
distinctly, “No man hath seen God at any time,” affirm that
they did not see the Divine Nature, but certain visions adapted to
their capacity.
Eran.
—So we say.
Orth.
—So also then let us understand of the angels when we hear
that they daily see the face of your Father.
1016
For what they see is not the divine substance which cannot be
circumscribed, comprehended, or apprehended, which embraces the
universe, but some glory made commensurate with their
nature.
Eran.
—This is acknowledged.
Orth.
—After the incarnation, however, He was seen also of angels,
as the divine apostle says, not however by similitude of glory, but
using the true and living covering of the flesh as a kind of screen.
“God,” he says, “was made manifest in the flesh,
justified in the Spirit, seen of angels.”
1017
Eran.
—I accept this as Scripture, but I am not prepared to accept
the novelties of phrase.
Orth.
—What novelties of phrase have we introduced?
Eran.
—That of the “screen.” What Scripture calls the
flesh of the Lord a screen?
Orth.
—You do not seem to be a very diligent reader of your Bible;
if you had been you would not have found fault with what we have said
as in a figure. For first of all the fact that the divine apostle says
that the invisible nature was made manifest through the flesh allows us
to understand the flesh as a screen of the Godhead. Secondly, the
divine apostle in his Epistle to the Hebrews, distinctly uses the
phrase, for he says, “Having therefore, brethren, boldness to
enter into the Holiest by the blood of Jesus by a new and living way,
which he hath consecrated for us, through the veil, that is to say his
flesh; and having an High Priest over the House of God. Coming with
truth drawing near with a true heart in fulness of faith.”
1018
Eran.
—Your demonstration is unanswerable, for it is based on
apostolic authority.
Orth.
—Do not then charge us with innovation. We will adduce for
you yet another prophetic authority, distinctly calling the
Lord’s flesh a robe and mantle.
Eran.
—Should it not appear obscure and ambiguous we will say
nothing against it, and be thankful for it.
Orth.
—I will make you yourself testify to the truth of the
promise. You know how the Patriarch Jacob, when he was addressing
Judah, limited the sovereignty of Judah by the birth of the Lord.
1019
“A prince shall not fail Judah, nor a
leader from his loins until he shall have come to whom it is in store
and he is the expectation of the Gentiles.” You have already
confessed that this prophecy was uttered about the saviour.
Eran.
—I have.
Orth.
—Remember then what follows; for he says “And unto him
shall the gathering of the people be…he shall wash his robe in
wine and his mantle in the blood of the grape.”
1020
Eran.
—The Patriarch spoke of garments, not of a body.
Orth.
—Tell me, then, when or where he washed his cloak in the
blood of the grape?
Eran.
—Nay; tell me you when he reddened his body in
it?
Orth.
—Answer I beseech you more reverently.
1021
Perhaps some of the uninitiated are within
hearing.
Eran.
—I will both hear and answer in mystic language.
Orth.
—You know that the Lord called himself a vine?
Eran.
—Yes I know that he said “I am the true vine.”
1022
Orth.
—Now what is the fruit of a vine called after it is
pressed?
Eran.
—It is called wine.
Orth.
—When the soldiers wounded the Saviour’s side with the
spear, what did the evangelist say was poured out from it?
Eran.
—Blood and water.
1023
Orth.
—Well, then; he called the Saviour’s blood blood of
the grape, for if the Lord is called a vine, and the fruit of the vine
wine, and from the Lord’s side streams of blood and water flowed
downwards over the rest of his body, fitly and appropriately the
Patriarch foretells “He shall wash his robe in wine and his
mantle in blood of the grape.” For as we after the consecration
call the mystic fruit of the vine
the Lord’s blood, so he
called the blood of the true vine blood of the grape.
Eran.
—The point before us has been set forth in language at once
mystical and clear.
Orth.
—Although what has been said is enough for your faith, I
will, for confirmation of the faith, give you yet another
proof.
Eran.
—I shall be grateful to you for so doing, for you will
increase the favour done me.
Orth.
—You know how God called His own body bread?
Eran.
—Yes.
Orth.
—And how in another place he called His flesh
corn?
Eran.
—Yes, I know. For I have heard Him saying “The hour is
come that the Son of man should be glorified,”
1024
and “Except a corn of wheat fall into
the ground and die, it abideth alone; but if it die it bringeth forth
much fruit.”
1025
Orth.
—Yes; and in the giving of the mysteries He called the
bread, body, and what had been mixed, blood.
Eran.
—He so did.
Orth.
—Yet naturally the body would properly be called body, and
the blood, blood.
Eran.
—Agreed.
Orth.
—But our Saviour changed the names, and to His body gave the
name of the symbol and to the symbol that of his body. So, after
calling himself a vine, he spoke of the symbol as blood.
Eran.
—True. But I am desirous of knowing the reason of the change
of names.
Orth.
—To them that are initiated in divine things the intention
is plain. For he wished the partakers in the divine mysteries not to
give heed to the nature of the visible objects, but, by means of the
variation of the names, to believe the change wrought of grace. For He,
we know, who spoke of his natural body as corn and bread, and, again,
called Himself a vine, dignified the visible symbols by the appellation
of the body and blood, not because He had changed their nature, but
because to their nature He had added grace.
1026
Eran.
—The mysteries are spoken of in mystic language, and there
is a clear declaration of that which is not known to all.
Orth.
—Since then it is agreed that the body of the Lord is called
by the patriarch “robe” and “mantle”
1027
and we have reached the discussion of the
divine mysteries, tell me truly, of what do you understand the Holy
Food to be a symbol and type? Of the godhead of the Lord Christ, or of
His body and His blood?
Eran.
—Plainly of those things of which they received the
names.
Orth.
—You mean of the body and of the blood?
Eran.
—I do.
Orth.
—You have spoken as a lover of truth should speak, for when
the Lord had taken the symbol, He did not say “this is my
godhead,” but “this is my body;” and again
“this is my blood”
1028
and in another
place “the bread that I will give is my flesh which I will give
for the life of the world.”
1029
Eran.
—These words are true, for they are the divine
oracles.
Orth.
—If then they are true, I suppose the Lord had a
body.
Eran.
—No; for I maintain him to be bodiless.
Orth.
—But you confess that He had a body?
Eran.
—I say that the Word was made flesh, for so I have been
taught.
Orth.
—It seems, as the proverb has it, as if we are drawing water
in a pail with a hole in it.
1030
For after all our
demonstrations and solutions of difficulties, you are bringing the same
arguments round again.
Eran.
—I am not giving you my arguments, but those of the
gospels.
Orth.
—And have I not given you the interpretation of the words of
the gospels from those of prophets and apostles?
Eran.
—They do not serve to clear up the point at
issue.
Orth.
—And yet we shewed how, being invisible, He was made
manifest through flesh, and the relationship of this very flesh we have
been taught by the sacred writers—“He took on Him the seed
of Abraham.”
1031
And the Lord God
said to the patriarch, “in thy seed shall all the nations of the
earth be blessed,”
1032
and the apostle,
“It is evident our Lord sprang out of Judah.”
1033
We adduced further several similar
testimonies; but, since you are desirous of hearing yet others, listen
to the apostle when he says, “For every high priest taken from
among men is ordained that he may offer both gifts and sacrifices,
wherefore it is of necessity that this man have somewhat also to
offer.”
1034
Eran.
—Point out, then, how
He offered after taking a body.
Orth.
—The divine apostle himself clearly teaches in the very
passage, for after a few words he says: “Wherefore, when He
cometh into the world, He saith, sacrifice and offering thou wouldst
not, but a body hast thou prepared me.”
1035
He does not say “into a body hast thou changed,” but
“a body hast thou prepared,” and he shows plainly that the
formation of the body was wrought by the Spirit in accordance with the
utterance of the gospel, “Fear not to take unto thee Mary thy
wife; for that which is generated in her is of the Holy Ghost.”
1036
Eran.
—The virgin then gave birth only to a body?
Orth.
—It appears that you do not even understand the composition
of words, much less their meaning, for he is teaching Joseph the
manner, not of the generation, but of the conception. For he does not
say that which is generated
of
her, i.e. made, or formed, is of
the Holy Ghost. Joseph, ignorant of the mystery, was suspicions of
adultery; he was therefore plainly taught the formation by the Spirit.
It is this which He signified through the prophet when He said “A
body hast thou prepared me”
1037
for the
divine Apostle being full of the Spirit interpreted the prediction. If
then the offering of gifts is the special function of priests and
Christ in His humanity was called priest and offered no other sacrifice
save
1038
His own body, then the Lord Christ had a
body.
Eran.
—This even I have repeatedly affirmed, and I do not say that
the divine Word appeared without a body. What I maintain is not that He
took a body but that He was made flesh.
Orth.
—So far as I see our contest lies with the supporters of
Valentinus, of Marcion, and of Manes; but even they never had the
hardihood to say that the immutable nature underwent mutation into
flesh.
Eran.
—Reviling is unchristian.
Orth.
—We do not revile, but we are fighting for truth, and we are
vexed at your arguing about the indisputable as though it could be
disputed. However, I will endeavour to put an end to your ungracious
contention. Answer now; do you remember the promises which God made to
David?
Eran.
—Which?
Orth.
—Those which the prophet inserted in the 88th
Psalm.
Eran.
—I know that many promises were made to David. Which are you
enquiring about now?
Orth.
—Those which refer to the Lord Christ.
Eran.
—Recall the utterances yourself, for you promised to adduce
your proofs.
Orth.
—Listen now how the prophet praises God at the very
beginning of the Psalm. He saw with his prophetic eyes the future
iniquity of his people, and the captivity that was in consequence
foredoomed; yet he praised his own Lord for unfailing promises.
“I will sing,” he says, “of the mercies of the Lord
forever, with my mouth will I make known Thy faithfulness to all
generations, for thou hast said, Mercy shall be built up for ever, Thy
faithfulness shalt Thou establish in the very heavens.”
1039
Through all this the prophet
teaches that the promise was made by God on account of lovingkindness,
and that the promise is faithful. Then he goes on to say what He
promised, and to whom, introducing God Himself as the speaker.
(“I have made a covenant with my chosen.”
1040
) It is the Patriarchs that He called chosen;
then He goes on “I have sworn unto David my servant,”
1041
and He states concerning what He swore,
“Thy seed will I establish for ever, and build up thy throne to
all generations.”
1042
Now whom do you suppose to be
called the seed of David?
Eran.
—The promise was made about Solomon.
Orth.
—Then he made his covenant with the Patriarchs about
Solomon, for before what was said about David he mentioned the promises
made to the Patriarchs “I have made a covenant with my
chosen,” and He promised the Patriarchs that in their seed He
would bless all nations. Kindly point out how the nations were blessed
through Solomon.
Eran.
—Then God fulfilled
this promise, not by means of Solomon, but of our Saviour.
Orth.
—So then our Lord Christ gave the fulfilment to the promises
made to David.
Eran.
—I hold that these promises were made by God, either about
Solomon, or about Zerubbabel.
Orth.
—Just now you used the arguments of Marcion and Valentinus
and of Manes. Now you have gone over to the directly opposite faction,
and are advocating the impudence of the Jews. This is just like all
those who turn out of a straight road; they err and stray first one way
and then another, wandering in a wilderness.
Eran.
—Revilers are excluded by the Apostle from the kingdom.
1043
Orth.
—Yes, if their revilings are vain. Sometimes the divine
Apostle himself opportunely uses this mode of speech. He calls the
Galatians “foolish,”
1044
and of others
he says “men of corrupt minds, reprobate concerning the
faith,”
1045
and again of
another set, “Whose God is their belly, whose glory is in their
shame,”
1046
and so
forth.
Eran.
—What occasion did I give you for reviling?
Orth.
—Do you really not think that the willing advocacy of the
declared enemies of the truth furnishes the pious with very reasonable
ground of indignation?
Eran.
—And what enemies of the truth have I patronized?
Orth.
—Now, Jews.
Eran.
—How so?
Orth.
—Jews connect prophecies of this kind with Solomon and
Zerubbabel, in order to exhibit the groundlessness of the Christian
position; but the mere words are quite enough to convict them of their
iniquity, for it is written “I will establish my throne for
ever.”
1047
Now not only Solomon and Zerubbabel,
to whom such prophecies are applied by the Jews, have lived out their
appointed time, and reached the end of life, but the whole race of
David has become extinct; for who ever heard of any one at the present
day descended from the root of David?
Eran.
—But are not, then, those who are called Patriarchs of the
Jews of the family of David?
Orth.
—Certainly not.
Eran.
—Whence, then, are they sprung?
Orth.
—From the foreigner Herod, who, on his father’s side,
was an Ascalonite, and on his mother’s an Idumæan;
1048
but they, too, have all disappeared, and
many years have gone by since their sovereignty came to an end. But our
Lord God promised not only to maintain the seed of David for ever, but
to establish his kingdom undestroyed; for He said, “I will build
up my throne to all generations.”
But we see that his race is
gone, and his kingdom come to an end. Yet though we see this, we know
that the God of the Universe is true.
Eran.
—That God is true is plain.
Orth.
—If, then, God is true, as in truth He is, and promised
David that He would establish His race for ever, and keep his kingdom
through all time, and if neither race nor kingdom are to be seen, for
both have come to an end, how can we convince our opponents that God is
true?
Eran.
—I suppose, then, the prophecy really points to the Lord
Christ.
Orth.
—If, then, you confess this, let us investigate together a
passage in the middle of the Psalm; we shall then more clearly see what
the prophecy means.
Eran.
—Lead on; I will religiously follow in your
footsteps.
Orth.
—After making many promises about this seed that it should
be Lord both by sea and land
1049
and higher than
the kings of the earth and be called the first begotten of God,
1050
and should boldly call God, Father
1051
God also added this, “My mercy will I
keep for him for evermore and my covenant shall stand fast with him.
His seed also will I make to endure for ever and his throne as the days
of heaven.”
1052
Eran.
—The promise goes beyond the bounds of human nature, for
both the life and the honour are indestructible and eternal. But men
endure but for a season; their nature is short lived and their kingdom
even during its lifetime undergoes many and various vicissitudes, so
that truly the greatness of the prophecy befits none but the Saviour
Christ.
Orth.
—Go on then to what follows and your opinion upon this point
will be in every way confirmed, for again saith the God of the
universe, “Once have I sworn by my
holiness, if I lie unto David,
his seed shall endure for ever and his throne as the sun before me. It
shall be established for ever as the moon.”
1053
Then, pointing out the truth of
the promise He adds, “And the witness is faithful in
heaven.”
Eran.
—We must believe without doubt in the promises given by the
faithful witness, for, if we are wont to believe men who have promised
to speak the truth even if they do not confirm their words with an
oath, who can be so mad as to disbelieve the Creator of the Universe,
when He adds an oath to his words? For He who forbids others to swear
confirmed the immutability of his counsel by an oath,
1054
“that by two immutable things in which
it was impossible for God to lie we might have a strong consolation who
have fled for refuge to lay hold upon the hope set before us.”
1055
Orth.
—If then the promise is irrefragable, and among the Jews
there is now neither family nor kingdom of the prophet David to be
seen, let us believe that our Lord Jesus Christ is plainly called seed
of David in His humanity, for of Him the life and the kingdom are both
alike eternal.
Eran.
—We have no doubt; and this I own to be the
truth.
Orth.
—These proofs then are sufficient to show clearly the
manhood which our Lord and Saviour took of David’s seed. But to
remove all possibility of doubt by the witness of the majority, let us
hear how God makes mention of the promises given to David through the
voice of the prophet Isaiah. “I will make,” he says,
“an everlasting covenant with you,” and, signifying the
law-giver, he adds, “even the sure mercies of David.”
1056
Since He made this promise to
David, and spoke through Esaias, He will assuredly bring the promise to
pass. And what follows after the prophecy is in harmony with what I
say, for he saith “Behold I have given him for a witness to the
people, a leader and commander to the people. Behold nations that know
thee not shall call upon thee, and peoples that understand thee not
shall run unto thee.”
1057
Now this fits in
with none that are sprung from David, for who of David’s
descendants, as Esaias says, was made a ruler of nations? And what
nations in their prayers ever called on David’s descendants as
God?
Eran.
—About what is perfectly clear it is unbecoming to dispute,
and this plainly refers to the Lord Christ.
Orth.
—Then let us pass on to another prophetic testimony and let
us hear the same prophet saying “There shall come forth a rod out
of the stem of Jesse and a branch shall grow out of his roots.”
1058
Eran.
—I think this prophecy was delivered about
Zerubbabel.
Orth.
—If you hear what follows, you will not remain in your
opinion. The Jews have never so understood this prediction, for the
prophet goes on, “and the Spirit of the Lord shall rest upon him,
the spirit of wisdom and understanding, the spirit of counsel and
might, the spirit of knowledge and the fear of the Lord.”
1059
This would never be attributed by any one to
a mere man, for even to the very holy the gifts of the Spirit are given
by division, as the divine apostle witnesses when he says, “To
one is given by the Spirit the word of wisdom, to another the word of
knowledge by the same Spirit,”
1060
and so on. The
prophet describes Him who sprang from the root of Jesse as possessing
all the powers of the spirit.
Eran.
—To gainsay this were sheer folly.
Orth.
—Now hear what follows. You will see some things that
transcend human nature, he goes on. “He shall not judge after the
sight of His eyes, neither reprove after the hearing of His ears, but
with righteousness shall He judge the poor, and reprove with equity the
mighty
1061
of the earth, and He shall smite the
earth with the word of His mouth, and with the breath of His lips shall
he slay the wicked.”
1062
Now of these
predictions some are human and some divine. Justice, truth, equity, and
rectitude in giving judgment exhibit virtue in human nature.
Eran.
—We have so far clearly learned that the prophet predicts
the coming of our Saviour Christ.
Orth.
—The sequel will shew you yet more plainly the truth of the
interpretation. For he goes on, “The wolf shall dwell with the
lamb,”
1063
and so on, whereby he teaches at
once the distinction of modes of life and the harmony of faith; and
experience furnishes a proof of the prediction, for they that abound in
wealth, they that live in poverty, servants and masters, rulers and
ruled, soldiers and citizens and they that wield the sceptre of the
world are received in one font, are all taught one doctrine, are all
admitted to one
mystic table, and each of the believers enjoys an equal
share.
Eran.
—It is thus shewn that God is spoken of.
Orth.
—Not only God but man. So at the very beginning of this
prediction he says that a rod shall grow out of the root of Jesse. Then
at the conclusion of the prediction he takes up once more the strain
with which he began, for he says “There shall be a root of Jesse
which shall stand for an ensign of the people, to it shall the Gentiles
seek and his rest shall be glorious.”
1064
Now Jesse was the father of David, and the promise with an oath was
made to David. The prophet would not have spoken of the Lord Christ as
a rod growing out of Jesse if he had only known Him as God. The
prediction also foretold the change of the world, for “the
earth” he says “shall be full of the knowledge of the Lord
as the waters cover the sea.”
1065
Eran.
—I have heard the prophetic utterances. But I was anxious to
know clearly if the divine company of the apostles also says that the
Lord Christ sprang from the seed of David according to the
flesh.
Orth.
—You have asked for information which so far from being hard
is exceedingly easy to give you. Only listen to the first of the
apostles exclaiming “David being a prophet and knowing that God
had sworn an oath to him that of the fruit of his loins, according to
the flesh, He would raise up Christ to sit upon His throne; he seeing
this before spake of the resurrection of Christ, that His soul was not
left in hell neither His flesh did see corruption.”
1066
Hence you may perceive that of
the seed of David according to the flesh sprang the Lord Christ, and
had not flesh only but also a soul.
Eran.
—What other apostle preached this?
Orth.
—The great Peter alone was sufficient to testify to the
truth, for the Lord after receiving the confession of the truth given
by Peter alone confirmed it by a memorable approval. But since you are
anxious to hear others proclaiming this same thing, hear Paul and
Barnabas preaching in Antioch in Pisidia; for they, when they had made
mention of David, continued “Of this man’s seed hath God
according to his promise raised unto Israel a Saviour, Jesus,”
1067
and so on. And in a letter to Timothy the
divine Paul says “Remember that Jesus Christ of the seed of David
was raised from the dead according to my gospel.”
1068
And, when writing to the Romans, at the
very outset he calls attention to the Davidic kin, for he says
“Paul a servant of Jesus Christ, called to be an apostle,
separated unto the gospel of God which He had promised before by his
prophets in the holy scriptures concerning His Son which was made of
the seed of David according to the flesh,”
1069
and so on.
Eran.
—Your proofs are numerous and convincing; but tell me why
you have omitted what follows?
Orth.
—Because it is not about the Godhead, but about the manhood,
that you are in difficulties. Had you been in doubt about the Godhead,
I would have given you proof of it. It is enough to say
“according to the Flesh” to declare the Godhead which is
not expressed in terms. When speaking of a relationship of man in
general I do not say the son of such an one “according to the
flesh,” but simply “son,” so the divine Evangelist
writing his genealogy says “Abraham begat Isaac”
1070
and does not add according to the flesh, for
Isaac was merely man, and he mentions the rest in like manner, for they
were men and had no qualities transcending their nature. But when the
heralds of the truth are discoursing of our Lord Christ, and are
pointing out to the ignorant His lower relation, they add the words
“according to the flesh,” thus indicating His Godhead and
teaching that the Lord Christ was not only man but also Eternal
God.
Eran.
—You have adduced many proofs from the apostles and
prophets, but I follow the words of the Evangelist “The Word was
made Flesh.”
1071
Orth.
—I also follow this divine teaching, but I understand it in
a pious sense, as meaning that He was made Flesh by taking flesh and a
reasonable soul. But if the divine Word took nothing of our nature,
then the covenants made with the patriarchs by the God of all with
oaths were not true, and the blessing of Judah was vain, and the
promise to David was false, and the Virgin was superfluous, because she
did not contribute anything of our nature to the Incarnate God. Then
the predictions of the prophets have no fulfilment. Then vain is our
preaching, vain our faith and vain the hope of the resurrection
1072
for the Apostle, it appears, lies when he
says “and hath raised us up together and made us sit together in
heavenly places in Christ Jesus.”
1073
For if the Lord Christ had nothing
of our nature then He is
falsely described as our first fruits, and His bodily nature has not
risen from the dead and has not taken the seat in Heaven on the right
hand; and if He has obtained none of these things, how hath God raised
us up together and made us sit together with Christ, when we in no wise
belong to Him in Nature? But it is impious to say this, for the divine
apostle, though the general resurrection has not yet taken place,
though the kingdom of heaven has not yet been bestowed upon the
faithful, exclaims, “He hath raised us up together and made us
sit together in heavenly places in Christ Jesus,” in order to
teach that since the resurrection of our first fruits, and His sitting
on the right hand has come to pass, we too in general shall attain the
resurrection, and that all they who share in His nature and have
adopted His faith, share too in the first fruits of His
glory.
Eran.
—We have gone through many and sound arguments, but I was
anxious to know the force of the Gospel saying.
Orth.
—You stand in need of no interpretation from without. The
evangelist himself interprets himself. For after saying “the Word
was made flesh,” he goes on “and dwelt among us.”
1074
That is to say by dwelling in us, and
using the flesh taken from us as a kind of temple, He is said to have
been made flesh, and, teaching that He remained unchanged, the
evangelist adds “and we beheld His glory—the glory as of
the only begotten of the Father, full of grace and truth.”
1075
For though clad with flesh He exhibited His
Father’s nobility, shot forth the beams of the Godhead, and
emitted the radiance of the power of the Lord, revealing by His works
of wonder His hidden nature. A similar illustration is afforded by the
words of the divine apostle to the Philippians: “Let this mind be
in you which was also in Christ Jesus, who being in the form of God
thought it not robbery to be equal with God, but made Himself of no
reputation and took upon Him the form of a servant and was made in the
likeness of men, and being found in fashion as a man he humbled Himself
and became obedient unto death even the death of the cross.”
1076
Look at the relation of the
utterances. The evangelist says “the Word was made flesh and
dwelt among us,” the apostle, “took upon him the form of a
servant;” the evangelist “We beheld His glory, the glory as
of the only begotten of the Father”—the apostle, “who
being in the form of God thought it not robbery to be equal with
God.” To put the matter briefly, both teach that being God and
son of God, and clad with His Father’s glory, and having the same
nature and power with Him that begat Him, He that was in the beginning
and was with God, and was God, and was Creator of the world, took upon
Him the form of a servant, and it seemed that this was all which was
seen; but it was God clad in human nature, and working out the
salvation of men. This is what was meant by “The word was made
flesh” and “was made in the likeness of men and being found
in fashion as a man.” This is all that was looked at by the Jews,
and therefore they said to him “For a good work we stone Thee not
but for blasphemy and because that Thou being a man makest Thyself
God,”
1077
and again “This man is not of
God because He keepeth not the Sabbath Day.”
1078
Eran.
—The Jews were blind on account of their unbelief, and
therefore used these words.
Orth.
—If you find even the apostles before the resurrection thus
saying, will you receive the interpretation? I hear them in the boat,
after the mighty miracle of the calm, saying “what manner of man
is this, that even the winds and the sea obey Him?”
1079
Eran.
—This is made plain. But now tell me this;—the divine
apostle says that He “was made in the likeness of
man.”
Orth.
—What was taken of him was not man’s likeness, but
man’s nature. For “form of a servant” is understood
just as “the form of God” is understood to mean God’s
nature. He took this, and so was made in the likeness of man, and was
found in fashion as a man. For, being God, He seemed to be man, on
account of the nature which He took. The evangelist, however, speaks of
His being made in the likeness of man as His being made flesh. But that
you may know that they who deny the flesh of the Saviour are of the
opposite spirit, hear the great John in his Catholic Epistle saying
“Every spirit that confesses that Jesus Christ is come in the
flesh is of God, and every spirit that confesses not that Jesus Christ
is come in the flesh is not of God, and this is that spirit of
Anti-Christ.”
1080
Eran.
—You have given a plausible interpretation, but I was
anxious to know how the old teachers of the Church have understood the
passage “the word was made flesh.”
Orth.
—You ought to have been persuaded
by the apostolic and prophetic
proofs; but since you require further the interpretations of the holy
Fathers I will also furnish you, God helping me, this
medicine.
Eran.
—Do not bring me men of obscure position or doubtful
doctrine. I shall not receive the interpretation of such as
these.
Orth.
—Does the far famed Athanasius, brightest light of the
church of Alexandria, seem to you to be worthy of credit?
Eran.
—Certainly, for he ratified his teaching by the suffering he
underwent for the Truth’s sake.
Orth.
—Hear then how he wrote to Epictetus.
1081
“The expression of John ‘the
Word was made flesh’ has this interpretation, so far as can be
discovered from the similar passage which we find in St. Paul
‘Christ was made a curse for us.’
1082
It is not because He was made a curse but because He received the curse
on our behalf that He is said to have been made a curse, and so it is
not because He was turned into flesh, but because He took flesh on our
behalf, that He is said to have been made flesh.” So far the
divine Athanasius. Gregory, too, whose glory among all men is great,
who formerly ruled the Imperial city at the mouth of the Bosphorus and
afterwards dwelt at Nazianzus, thus wrote to Cledonius against the
specious fallacies of Apollinarius.
Eran.
—He was an illustrious man and a foremost fighter in the
cause of piety.
Orth.
—Hear him then. He says
1083
“the
expression ‘He was made Flesh’ seems to be parallel to His
being said to have been made sin and a curse,
1084
not because the Lord was transmuted into these,—for how could
He?—but because He accepted these when He took on Him our
iniquities and bore our infirmities.”
1085
Eran.
—The two interpretations agree.
Orth.
—We have shown you the pastors of the south and north in
harmony; now then let us introduce too the illustrious teachers of the
west, who have written their interpretation, if with another tongue,
yet with one and the same mind.
Eran.
—I am told that Ambrosius, who adorned the episcopal throne
at Milan, fought in the first ranks against all heresy, and wrote works
of great beauty and in agreement with the teaching of the
apostles.
Orth.
—I will give you his interpretation. Ambrosius says in his
work concerning the faith “It is written that the Word was made
flesh. I do not deny that it is written, but look at the terms used;
for there follows ‘and dwelt among us,’ that is to say
dwelt in human flesh. You are therefore astonished at the terms in
which it is written that the Word was made flesh, on the assumption of
flesh, by the divine Word, when also concerning sin which He had not,
it is said that He was made sin, that is to say not that He was made
the nature and operation of sin, but that he might crucify our sin in
the flesh; let them then give over asserting that the nature of the
Word has undergone change and alteration, for He who took is one and
that which was taken other.”
1086
It is now fitting that you
should hear the teachers of the east, this being the only quarter of
the east, this being the only quarter of the world which we have
hitherto left unnoticed, though they indeed might well have first
witnessed to the truth, for to them was first imparted the teaching of
the apostles. But since you have sharpened your tongues against the
first-born sons of piety by whetting them on the hone of falsehood, we
have reserved for them the last place, that after first hearing the
rest, you might lay witness by the side of witness, and so at once
admire their harmony, and cease from your own interminable talk. Listen
then to Flavianus who for a long time right wisely moved the tiller of
the church of Antioch, and made the churches which he guided ride safe
over the Arian storm, by expounding to them the word of the gospel.
“The Word was made flesh and dwelt among us; He is not turned
into flesh, nor yet did he cease from being God, for this he was from
all eternity and became flesh in the dispensation of the incarnation
1087
after himself building his own temple,
and taking up his abode in the passible creature.” And if you
desire to hear the ancients of Palestine, lend your ears to the
admirable Gelasius, who did diligent husbandry in the church of
Cæsarea. Now these are his words in his homily on the festival of
the Lord’s epiphany.
1088
“Learn the truth
from the words of John the Fisherman, ‘And the word was made
flesh,’ not having himself undergone change, but having taken up
his abode with us. The dwelling is one thing; the Word is another; the
temple is one thing, and God who dwells in it,
another.”
Eran.
—I am much struck by the agreement.
Orth.
—Now do you not suppose that the rule of the apostolic faith
was kept by John, who first nobly watered the field of the church of
the Antiochenes, and then was a wise husbandman of that of the imperial
city?
Eran.
—I hold this teacher to be in all respects an admirable
one.
Orth.
—Well, this most excellent man has interpreted this passage
of the Gospel. He writes,
1089
“When you
hear that the Word was made flesh, be not startled or cast down, for
the substance did not deteriorate into flesh—an idea of the
uttermost impiety—but continuing to be just what it is, so took
the form of a servant. For just as when the apostle says ‘Christ
hath redeemed us from the curse of the law, being made a curse for
us,’
1090
he does not say that the substance of
Christ departed from His own glory, and took the substance of a curse,
a position which not even devils would imagine, nor the utterly
senseless, and the naturally idiotic—so remarkable being the
connection between impiety and insanity. But what he does assert is
that after receiving the curse due to us, He does not suffer us to be
cursed for the future. It is in this sense that He is stated to have
been made flesh, not because he had changed the substance into flesh,
but because he had assumed the flesh, the substance remaining all the
while unimpaired.”
1091
You may like to hear also
Severianus, Bishop of Gabala.
1092
If so, I will
adduce his testimony and do you lend your ears.
“The text ‘the Word
was made flesh’ does not indicate a deterioration of nature but
the assumption of our nature. Suppose you take the word ‘was
made’ to indicate a change; then when you hear Paul saying
‘Christ hath redeemed us from the curse of the law, being made a
curse for us,’ do you understand him to mean a change into the
nature of a curse? Just as being made a curse had no other meaning than
that He took our curse upon Himself, so the words was made flesh and
dwelt among us mean nothing other than the assumption of
flesh.”
Eran.
—I admire the exact agreement
1093
of these men. For they are as unanimous in giving the same
interpretations of evangelical writings as if they had met in the same
place and written down their opinion together.
Orth.
—Mountains and seas separate them very far from one another,
yet distance does not damage their harmony, for they were all inspired
by the same gift of the spirit. I would also have offered you the
interpretations of the victorious champions of piety Diodorus and
Theodorus, had I not seen that you were ill disposed towards them, and
had inherited the hostility of Apollinarius; you would have seen that
they have expressed similar experiences, drawing water from the divine
Fount, and becoming themselves too, streams of the spirit. But I will
pass them by, for you have declared a truceless war against them. I
will, however, shew you the famous teacher of the Church, and his mind
about the divine incarnation, that you may know what opinion he held
concerning the assumed nature. You have no doubt heard of the
illustrious Ignatius, who received episcopal grace by the hand of the
great Peter,
1094
and after ruling the church of
Antioch, wore the crown of martyrdom. You have heard too of
Irenæus, who enjoyed the teaching of Polycarp, and became a light
of the western Gauls;—of Hippolytus and Methodius, bishops and
martyrs, and the rest, whose names I will append to their expressions
of opinion.
Eran.
—I am exceedingly desirous of hearing their testimony
too.
Orth.
—Hear them now bringing forward the apostolic teaching.
Testimony of Saint Ignatius, bishop of Antioch, and
martyr.
From the letter to the
Smyrnæans
(I.):—
“Having a full conviction
with respect to our Lord as being truly descended from David
according to the
flesh, son of God according to Godhead
1095
and power, born really of a virgin, baptized by John that all
righteousness might be fulfilled
1096
by Him,
really in the time of Pontius Pilate and of Herod the tetrarch
crucified for our sake in the flesh.”
1097
Of the same in the same
epistle:
—
“For what advantageth it
me if a man praises me but blasphemes my Lord, in not confessing him to
be a bearer of flesh? but he who does not make this confession really
denies Him and is himself bearer of a corpse.”
1098
Of the same from the same
epistle:
—
“For if these things were
done by our Lord in appearance only, then it is in appearance only that
I am a prisoner in chains; and why have I delivered myself to death, to
fire, to sword, to the beasts? But he who is near to the sword is near
to God.
1099
Only in the name of Jesus Christ that
I may share his sufferings I endure all things while He, Perfect Man
whom some in their ignorance deny, gives me strength.”
1100
From the same in the letter
to the Ephesians:
—
“For our God Jesus Christ
was born in Mary’s womb by dispensation of God of the seed of
David
1101
and of the Holy Ghost who was born and was
baptized that our mortality might be purified.”
1102
From the same
epistle:
—
“If ye all individually
come together by grace name by name in one faith, and in one Jesus
Christ according to the flesh of David’s race Son of God and Son
of man.
1103
Of the same from the same
epistle:
—
“There is one Physician of
flesh and of spirit generate and ingenerate, God in man, true life in
death, Son of Mary and of God, first passible and then impassible,
Jesus Christ our Lord.”
1104
Lastly of the same in his
epistle to the Trallians:
—
“Be ye made deaf therefore
when any man speaks to you apart from Jesus Christ, who was of
David’s race and of Mary, who was really born and really ate and
drank and was persecuted in the time of Pontius Pilate, was crucified
and died, while beings on earth and beings in heaven and beings under
the earth were looking on.”
1105
Testimony of Irenæus
bishop of Lyons, from his third book Against the
heresies:
—
“Why then did they add the
words ‘In the city of David,’
1106
save to proclaim the good news that the promise made by God to David,
that of the fruit of his loins should come an everlasting king, was
fulfilled; a promise which indeed the Creator of the world had
made.”
1107
Of the same from the same
book:
—
“And when he says
‘Hear ye now, Oh House of David’
1108
he means that the everlasting King whom God promised to David that he
would raise up from his body is He who was born of David’s
Virgin.”
Of the same from the same
book:
—
“If then the first Adam
had had a human father and had been begotten of seed, it would have
been reasonable to say that the second Adam had been begotten of
Joseph. But if the former was taken from earth, and his creator was
God, it was necessary also that He who renews in himself the man
created by God should have the same likeness of generation with that
former. Why then did not God again take dust? Why did he on the other
hand ordain that the formation should be made of Mary? That there might
be no other creation; that that which was being saved might be no other
thing; but that the former might himself be renewed without loss of the
likeness. For then do they too fall away who allege that He took
nothing from the Virgin, that they may repudiate the inheritance of the
flesh and cast off the likeness.”
1109
Of the same from the same
book:
—
“Since his going down into
Mary is useless; for why went He down into her if He was designed to
take nothing from her? And further, if He had taken nothing from Mary
He would not have accepted the food taken from earth whereby is
nourished the body taken from earth, nor would He like Moses and Elias,
after fasting forty days, have hungered, on account of His body
demanding its own food, nor yet would John his disciple when writing
about him have said—‘Jesus being wearied from his journey
sat,’
1110
nor would David have uttered the
prediction about him ‘And they added to
the pain of my
wounds,’
1111
nor would he have
wept over Lazarus,
1112
nor would He have
sweated drops of blood,
1113
nor would He have
said, ‘my soul is exceedingly sorrowful,’
1114
nor yet when He was pierced would blood and
water have issued from His side.
1115
For all these
things are proofs of the flesh taken from earth, which He had renewed
in Himself in the salvation of his own creature.”
1116
Of the same from the same
book:
—
“For as by the
disobedience of the one man who was first formed from rude earth the
many were made sinners
1117
and lost their
life, so also was it fitting that through obedience of one man, the
firstborn of a virgin, many should be made righteous and receive their
salvation.”
1118
Of the same from the same
work:
—
“‘I have said ye are
gods and all of you children of the Most High but ye shall die like
man.’
1119
This He says to them that did not
accept the gift of adoption, but dishonour the incarnation of the pure
generation of the word of God, deprive man of his ascent to God, and
are ungrateful to the Word of God who for their sakes was made flesh.
For this cause was the word made man that man receiving the word and
accepting the adoption should be made God’s son.
1120
”
Of the same from the same
book:
—
“Since then on account of
the foreordained dispensation
1121
the spirit came
down, and the only begotten Son of God, who also is Word of the Father,
when the fulness of time was come, was made flesh in man and our Lord
Jesus Christ—being one and the same—fulfilled all the human
dispensation as the Lord himself testifies, and the apostles confess,
all the teachings of men who invented the ogdoads and tetrads and
similitudes are proved plainly false.”
1122
Testimony of the Holy
Hippolytus, Bishop and Martyr, from his discourse on
1123
“The Lord is my
shepherd”:
—
“And an ark of
incorruptible wood was the Saviour Himself, for the incorruptibility
and indestructibility of His Tabernacle signified its producing no
corruption of sin. For the sinner who confesses his sin says ‘My
wounds stink and are corrupt because of my foolishness.’
1124
But the Lord was without sin, made in His
human nature of incorruptible wood, that is to say, of the Virgin and
the Holy Ghost, overlaid within and without, as it were, by purest gold
of the word of God.”
Of the same from his
discourse on Elkanah and Hannah:
—
“Bring me then, O Samuel,
the Heifer drawn to Bethlehem, that you may shew the King begotten of
David, and anointed King and Priest by the Father.”
From the same
discourse:
—
“Tell me, O Blessed Mary,
what it was that was conceived by thee in the womb; what it was that
was borne by thee in a Virgin’s womb. It was the Word of God,
firstborn from Heaven, on thee descending, and man firstborn being
formed in a womb, that the first born Word of God might be shewn united
to a firstborn man.”
From the same
discourse:
—
“The second, which was
through the prophets as through Samuel, he revokes, and turns his
people from the slavery of strangers. The third, in which He took the
manhood of the Virgin and was present in the flesh; who, when He saw
the city wept over it.”
Of the same from his
discourse on the beginning of Isaiah:
1125
—
“He likens the world to
Egypt; its idolatry, to images; its removal and destruction to an
earthquake. The Word he calls the ‘Lord’ and by a
‘swift cloud’ he means the right pure tabernacle enthroned
on which our Lord Jesus Christ entered into life to undo the
fall.”
Testimony of the Holy
Methodius,
1126
bishop and martyr, from his discourse on the
martyrs:
—
“So wonderful and precious
is martyrdom that our Lord Jesus Christ Himself, the Son of God,
testified in its honour that He thought it not robbery to be equal with
God, that He might crown with this grace the Manhood into whom He had
come down.”
Testimony of the holy
Eustathius, bishop
of Antioch, confessor. From
his interpretation of the xvith Psalm:
—
“The soul of Jesus
experienced both. For it was in the place of the souls of men and being
made without the flesh, lives and survives. So it is reasonable and of
the same substance as the souls of men, just as the flesh is of the
same substance as the flesh of men, coming forth from
Mary.”
Of the same from his work
about the soul:
—
“On looking at the
education of the child, or at the increase of his stature, or at the
extension of time, or at the growth of the body, what would they say?
But, to omit the miracles wrought upon earth, let them behold the
raisings of the dead to life, the signs of the Passion, the marks of
the scourges, the bruises and the blows, the wounded side, the prints
of the nails, the shedding of the blood, the evidences of the death,
and in a word the actual resurrection of the very
body.”
From the same
work:
—
“Indeed if any one looks
to the generation of the body, he would clearly discover that after
being born at Bethlehem He was wrapped in swaddling clothes, and was
brought up for some time in Egypt, because of the evil counsel of the
cruel Herod, and grew to man’s estate at
Nazareth.”
From the same
work:
—
“For the tabernacle of the
Word and of God is not the same, whereby the blessed Stephen beheld the
divine glory.”
1127
Of the same from his sermon
on “the Lord created me in the beginning of His way”:
1128
—
“If the Word received a
beginning of His generation from the time when passing through His
mother’s womb He wore the human frame, it is clear that He was
made of a woman; but if He was from the first Word and God with the
Father, and if we assert that the universe was made by Him, then He who
is and is the cause of all created things was not made of a woman, but
is by nature God, self existent, infinite, incomprehensible; and of a
woman was made man, formed in the Virgin’s womb by the Holy
Ghost.”
From the same
work:
—
“For a temple absolutely
holy and undefiled is the tabernacle of the word according to the
flesh, wherein God visibly made his habitation and dwelt, and we assert
this not of conjecture, for He who is by nature the Son of this God
when predicting the destruction and resurrection of the temple
distinctly instructs us by His teaching when He says to the murderous
Jews, ‘Destroy this temple and in three days I will raise it
up.’”
1129
From the same
work:
—
“When then the Word built
a temple and carried the manhood, companying in a body with men, He
invisibly displayed various miracles, and sent forth the apostles as
heralds of His everlasting kingdom.”
Of the same from his
interpretation of Psalm xcii:
—
“It is plain then if
‘He that anointeth’ means God whose throne He calls
‘everlasting,’ the anointer is plainly by nature God,
begotten of God. But the anointed took an acquired virtue, being
adorned with a chosen temple of the Godhead dwelling in
it.”
The testimony of the holy
Athanasius, Bishop of Alexandria and Confessor. From the defence of
Dionysius Bishop of Alexandria:
—
“‘I am the vine, ye
are the branches. My Father is the husbandman.’
1130
For we according to the body are of kin to
the Lord, and for this reason He himself said ‘I will declare thy
name unto my brethren.’
1131
And just as the
branches are of one substance with the vine, and of it, so too we,
since we have bodies akin to the body of the Lord, receive them of His
fulness, and have it as a root for our resurrection and salvation. And
the Father is called a husbandman, for He Himself through the Word
tilled the vine which is the Lord’s body.”
Of the same from the same
treatise:
—
“The Lord was called a
vine on account of His bodily relationship to the branches which are
ourselves.”
Of the same from his greater
oration concerning the faith:
—
“The scripture ‘in
the beginning was the Word’
1132
clearly
indicates the Godhead. The passage ‘the Word was made
flesh’
1133
shews the human nature of the
Lord.”
From the same
discourse:
—
“‘He shall wash His
garments in wine’
1134
that is His
body, which is the vestment of the Godhead in His own
blood.”
Of the same from the same
discourse:
—
“The Word
‘was’
1135
is referred to
His divinity, the words ‘was made flesh’
1136
to His body, the Word was made flesh not
by being reduced to flesh, but by bearing flesh, just as any one might
say such an one became or was made an old man, though not so
born
from
the beginning, or the soldier became a veteran, not being previously
such as he became. John says, ‘I became,’ or ‘was in
the island of Patmos on the Lord’s day.’
1137
Not that he was made or born there, but
he says ‘I became or was in Patmos’ instead of saying
‘I arrived;’ so the Word ‘arrived’ at flesh, as
it is said ‘the Word was made flesh.’ Hear the words
‘I became like a broken vessel,’
1138
and ‘I became like a man that
hath no strength, free among the dead.’”
1139
Of the same from his letter
to Epictetus:
—
“Whoever heard such
things? Who taught them? Who learnt them? ‘Out of Zion shall go
forth the law and the Word of the Lord from Jerusalem.’
1140
But whence did these things come forth? What
hell vomited them out? To say that the body taken of Mary was of the
same substance as the Godhead of the Word, or that the Word was changed
into flesh and bones and hairs and a whole body; whoever heard in a
church or at all among Christians that God bore a body by adoption and
not by birth?”
1141
Of the same from the same
Epistle:
—
“But who, hearing that the
Word made for Himself a passible body, not of Mary, but of His own
substance, would call the sayer of these things a Christian? Who has
invented so unfounded an impiety, as even to think and to say that they
who affirm the Lord’s body to be of Mary, conceive no longer of a
Trinity, but of a quaternity in the godhead? As though they that are of
this opinion described the flesh which the Saviour clothed himself with
of Mary as of the substance of the Trinity.
“Whence further have some
men vomited forth an impiety as bad as the foregoing, and alleged that
the body is not of later time than the godhead of the Word, but has
always been co-eternal with it, since it is formed of the substance of
wisdom.”
Of the same from the same
letter:
—
“So the body taken of Mary
was human according to the scriptures, and real in that it was the same
as our own. For Mary was our sister, since we are all of Adam, a fact
which no one could doubt who remembers the words of Luke.”
1142
Testimony of the holy Basil,
bishop of Cæsarea:
—
From the interpretation of Psalm
LX.
“All strangers have
stooped and been put under the yoke of Christ, wherefore also
‘over Edom’ does he ‘cast out’ his
‘shoe.’
1143
Now the shoe of
the Godhead is the flesh which bore God whereby he came among
men.”
Of the same from his writings
about the Holy Ghost to Amphilochius:
—
“He uses the phrase
‘of whom’ instead of ‘through whom;’ as when
Paul says ‘made of a woman.’
1144
He clearly made this distinction for us in another place where he says
that the being made of the man is proper to a woman, but to a man the
being made by the woman, in the words ‘For as the woman is of the
man so is the man by the woman.’
1145
But with the object at once of pointing out the different use of these
expressions, and of correcting
obiter
an error of certain men
who supposed the body of the Lord to be spiritual, that he may shew how
the God-bearing flesh was composed of human matter, he gives prominence
to the more emphatic expression, for the expression ‘by a
woman’ was in danger of suggesting that the sense of the word
generation was merely in passing through, while the phrase ‘of
the woman’ makes the common nature of the child and of the mother
plain enough.”
Testimony of the holy Gregory
bishop of Nazianus. From the former exposition to
Cledonius:
—
“If any one says that the
flesh came down from heaven, and not from this earth, and from us, let
him be Anathema. For the words ‘The second man is from
heaven,’
1146
and ‘as is
the heavenly such are they also that are heavenly’
1147
and ‘no man hath ascended up to
heaven but the son of man that came down from heaven,’
1148
and any other similar passage, must be
understood to be spoken on account of the union with man, as also the
statement that ‘all things were made by Christ,’
1149
and that ‘Christ dwells in our
hearts,’
1150
must be understood
not according to the sensible, but according to the intellectual
conception of the Godhead, the terms being commingled together just as
are the natures.”
Of the same from the same
work:
—
“Let us see from their own
words what reason they give for the being made man, that is for the
incarnation. If indeed it was that God otherwise not contained in
space, might be contained in space and, as it were under a veil, might
converse with men in the flesh, then their mask and their stage play
are exquisite: not to say that it was possible for Him otherwise to
converse
with us, as of yore, in a burning bush and in human form, but if
that He might undo the damnation of sin by taking like to like
1151
then just as He required flesh on account of
the condemned flesh, and a soul on account of the soul, so too he
required a mind on account of the mind, which in Adam not only fell
but,—to employ a term which physicians are accustomed to use
about diseases—was affected with original malady.
1152
For that which did not keep the commandment
was what had received the commandment; and that which dared
transgression was what had not kept the commandment; and that which
specially needed salvation was what had transgressed, and that which
was assumed was what needed salvation; so the mind was assumed. Now
this point has been demonstrated, whether they will or no, by proofs
which are so to say mathematical and necessary. But you are doing just
as though, if a man were to have a diseased eye and a limping foot you
were to cure the foot but leave the eye uncured; or, if a painter had
painted a picture badly, were to alter the picture, but leave the
painter alone, as though he were doing his work well. But if they are
so constrained by these arguments as to take refuge in the statement
that it is possible for God to save man, even without a mind, why then
clearly He might have done so even without flesh, by the mere
expression of His will, just as He works and has worked in the universe
without a body. Away then with the flesh as well as with the mind! Let
there be no inconsistency in your absurdity.”
Testimony of the Holy
Gregory, bishop of Nyssa. From his sermon on Abraham:
—
“So the Word came down not
naked, but after having been made flesh, not in the form of God, but in
the form of a servant.
1153
This then is He
who said that He could do nothing of Himself.
1154
For the not being able is the part of powerlessness. For as darkness is
opposed to light, and death to life, so is weakness to power. But yet
Christ is Power of God. Power is wholly inconsistent with not being
able. For if power were powerless what is powerful? When then the Word
declares that He can do nothing it is plain that He does not attribute
his powerlessness to the Godhead of the Only-begotten, but connects his
not being able with the powerlessness of our nature. The flesh is weak,
as it is written, ‘The spirit is willing, but the flesh is
weak.’”
1155
Of the same from his Book
“on the Perfection of Life”:
—
“Again the true lawgiver,
of whom Moses was a type, hewed for Himself out of our earth the slabs
of nature. No wedlock fashioned for Him the flesh that was to receive
the godhead, but He Himself is made the hewer of His own flesh, graven
as it is by the finger of God. For the Holy Ghost came upon the Virgin,
and the power of the Highest overshadowed her.
1156
And when this had come to pass, nature once again took its
indestructible character, being made immortal by the marks of the
divine finger.”
Of the same from his Book
against Eunomius:
—
“We assert therefore that
when He said above that wisdom built for herself a house,
1157
he intimates by the phrase the formation
of the flesh of the Lord, for the very wisdom made its home in no
strange dwelling, but built itself its dwelling of the Virgin’s
body.”
Of the same from the same
treatise:
—
“The Word was before the
ages, but the flesh was made in the last times, and no one would say on
the contrary either that the flesh was before the ages, or the Word
made in the last times.”
Of the same from the same
treatise:
—
“The expression
‘created me’
1158
is not to be
understood of the divine and the undefiled, but, as has been said, of
our created nature, according to the dispensation of the
incarnation.”
1159
Of the same from the first
discourse on the Beatitudes:
—
“‘Who being in the
form of God, thought it not robbery to be equal with God, but emptied
himself, and took the form of a servant.’
1160
What poorer, in respect of God, than the form of a servant? What more
lowly, in respect of the King of all, than approach to fellowship in
our poor nature? The King of Kings and Lord of Lords
1161
voluntarily dons the form of
servitude.”
Testimony of the Holy
Flavianus, bishop of Antioch. From his sermon on John the
Baptist:
—
“Do not think of connexion
in any physical sense, nor entertain the idea of conjugal intercourse.
For thy Creator is creating His own bodily temple now being born of
thee.”
Of the same from his book on
“The Spirit of the Lord is upon me”:
—
“Hear Him saying, ‘The Spirit is upon me because He
hath anointed me.’
1162
You do not know,
He says, what you read, for I, the anointed with the Spirit, am come to
you. Now what is akin to us, and not the invisible nature, is anointed
with the Spirit.”
1163
Testimony of Amphilochius,
bishop of Iconium. From his Discourse on “My Father is greater
than I:”
1164
—
“Distinguish me now the
natures, the Divine and the human. For man was not made from God by
falling away, nor was God made of man by advancement. I am speaking of
God and man. When, however, you attribute the passions to the flesh and
the miracles to God, you of necessity and involuntarily assign the
lowly titles to the man born of Mary, and the exalted and divine to the
Word Who in the beginning was God. Wherefore in some cases I utter
exalted words, in others lowly, to the end that by means of the lofty I
may shew the nature of the indwelling Word, and by the lowly, own the
weakness of the lowly flesh. Whence sometimes I call myself equal to
the Father and sometimes greater than the Father, not contradicting
myself, but shewing that I am God and man, for God is of the lofty, man
of the lowly; but if you wish to know how my Father is greater than I,
I spoke of the flesh and not of the person of the
Godhead.”
Of the same from his
discourse on “The Son, can do nothing of
Himself:”
1165
—
“How was Adam disobedient
in Heaven, and how of heavenly body was he formed first-formed beside
the first formation? But it was the Adam of the earth who was formed at
the beginning; the Adam of the earth disobeyed; the Adam of the earth
was assumed. Wherefore also the Adam of the earth was saved that thus
the reason of the incarnation
1166
may be proved
necessary and true.”
1167
Testimony of the Holy John
Bishop of Constantinople. From the speech which he made when the Gothic
envoy had spoken before him:
—
“See from the beginning
what He does. He clothes Himself in our nature, powerless and
vanquished, that by its means He may fight and struggle and from the
beginning He uproots the nature of rebellion.”
Of the same from his
discourse on
1168
The Festival of the Nativity:
—
“For is it not of the very
last stupidity for them to bring down their own gods into stones and
cheap wooden images, shutting them up as it were in a kind of prison,
and to fancy that there is nothing disgraceful in what they either say
or do, and then to find fault with us for saying that God made a living
temple for Himself of the Holy Ghost, by means of which he brought
succour to the world? For if it is disgraceful for God to dwell in a
human body, then in proportion as the stone and the wood are more
worthless than man is it much more disgraceful for him to dwell in
stone and wood. But perhaps mankind seems to them to be of less value
than these senseless objects. They bring down the substance of God into
stones and into dogs;
1169
but many heretics
into fouler things than these. But we could never endure even to hear
of these things.
1170
But what we say is
that of a virgin’s womb the Christ took pure flesh, holy and
without spot, and made impervious to all sin, and restored the body
1171
that was His own.”
A little further on: “And
we assert that when the divine Word had fashioned for Himself a holy
temple by its means he brought the heavenly state into our
life.”
Of the same from the oration:
That the lowly words and deeds of Christ were not spoken and done
through lack of power, but through distinctions of
dispensation.
“What then are the causes
of many humble things having been said about Him both by Himself and by
His apostles? The first and greatest cause is the fact of His having
clothed Himself with flesh, and wishing all his contemporaries and all
who have lived since, to believe that He was not a shadow, nor what was
seen merely a form, but reality of nature. For if when He Himself and
His apostles had spoken about Him so often in humble and in human
sense, the devil yet had power to persuade some wretched and miserable
men to deny the reason of the incarnation, and dare to say that He did
not take flesh and so to destroy all the ground of His love for man,
how many would not have fallen into this abyss if He had never said
anything of the kind?”
I have now produced for you a
few out of many authorities of the heralds of the truth,
not to stun you with too
many. They are quite enough to show the bent of the mind of the
excellent writers. It is now for you to say what force their writings
seem to have.
Eran.
—They have all spoken in harmony with one another, and the
workers in the vineyard of the West agree with them whose husbandry is
done in the region of the rising sun. Yet I perceived a considerable
difference in their sayings.
Orth.
—They are successors of the divine apostles; some even of
those apostles were privileged to hear the holy voice and see the
goodly sight. The majority of them too were adorned with the crown of
martyrdom. Does it seem right for you to wag the tongue of blasphemy
against them?
Eran.
—I shrink from doing this; at the same time I do not approve
of their great divergence.
Orth.
—But now I will bring you an unexpected remedy. I will
adduce one of your own beautiful heresy—your teacher
Apollinarius,
1172
and I will shew
you that he understood the text “The Word was made flesh”
just as the holy Fathers did. Hear now what he wrote about it in his
“Summary.”
The testimony of Apollinarius
from his “Summary”:
—
“If no one is turned into
that which he assumes, and Christ assumed flesh, then He was not turned
into flesh.”
And immediately afterward he
continues:—
“For also He gave himself
to us in relationship by means of the body to save us. Now that which
saves is far more excellent than that which is being saved. Far more
excellent then than we are, is He in the assumption of a body! But He
would not have been more excellent had He been turned into
flesh.”
A little further on he
says:—
“The simple is one, but
the complex cannot be one; he then that alleges that He was made flesh
affirms the mutation of the one Word. But if the complex is also one,
as man, then he who on account of the union with the flesh says the
Word was made flesh means the one in complexity.”
And again a little further on he
says—“To be made flesh is to be made empty,
1173
but the being made empty declares not
man, but the Son of man, who ‘emptied Himself’ not by
undergoing change, but by investiture.”
There; you see the teacher of
your own doctrines has introduced the word ‘investiture’
and indeed in his little work upon the faith he says—“We
then believe that he was made flesh, while His Godhead remained
unchanged for the renewal of the manhood. For in the holy power of God
there has been neither alteration nor change of place, nor
inclusion”—and then shortly again—“We worship
God who took flesh of the blessed virgin, and on this account in the
flesh is man, but in the spirit God.” And in another exposition
he says—“We confess the Son of God to have been made the
Son of man, not nominally but verily, on taking flesh of the Virgin
Mary.”
Eran.
—I did not suppose that Apollinarius held these sentiments.
I had other ideas about him.
Orth.
—Well; now you have learnt that not only the prophets and
apostles, and they who after them were ordained teachers of the world,
but even Apollinarius, the writer of heretical babbling, confesses the
divine Word to be immutable, states that He was not turned into flesh
but assumed flesh, and this over and over again, as you have heard. Do
not then struggle to throw your master’s blasphemy into the shade
by your own. For, says the Lord “the disciple is not above his
master.”
1174
Eran.
—Yes, I confess that the divine Word of God is immutable and
took flesh. It were the uttermost foolishness to withstand authorities
so many and so great.
Orth.
—Do you wish to have a solution of the rest of the
difficulties?
Eran.
—Let us put off their investigation until
to-morrow.
Orth.
—Very well; our synod is dismissed. Let us depart, and bear
in mind what we have agreed upon.
972
Cf.
note p. 36,
History.
973
“Sauromatas gentes Scytharum Græci vocant, quos
Sarmatas Romani.”
Pliny
iii.
974
Gen. vi. 7
975
Ps. xlix. 20
976
John i. 14
977
Matt. xix. 26
978
Ps. cxxxv. 6
979
The
reference in Schulze’s edition is to
Jeremiah x.
16
,
but here the Septuagint
ὁ πλάσας τὰ
πάντα
does not bear
out the point. The quotation is no doubt of
Amos v. 8
, where the LXX
is
ὁ ποιῶν
πάντα καὶ
μετασκευάζων
980
Ps. iii. 27
981
Mal. iii. 6
982
John i. 14
983
1 Cor. xii. 4
984
1 Cor. xii.
11
985
2 Cor. iv. 13
986
Heb. ii. 16
987
cf. Article ix. of the English Church. Sin is not part of
man’s nature, but the fault or corruption of it. If in one sense
the fallen Adam is the natural man, in a higher sense Christ, the Son
of man, is the natural man;
i.e.
in Him the manhood is seen
incorrupt. cf. p. 183 and note.
988
Isaiah xli. 8
989
Gen. xii. 3
. The lxx.
has
ἐνευλογηθήσονται
ἐν σοί
. In
Acts iii.
25
,
it is
τῷ
σπέρματί
σου
: in
Gal. iii. 8
,
ἐν
σοί
990
Gal. iii. 16
. There is here an
omission of the four words “
καὶ τῷ
σπέρματί
σου
.” Of the difficulty of
the passage a full discussion will be found in Bishop Lightfoot’s
“Galatians”
—page 141.
991
Gen. xlix. 10
. Here the text
follows the Alexandrine Septuagint substituting
ἕως
ἂν ἔλθῃ ᾧ
ἀπόκειται
for
ἕως ἂν
ἔλθῃ τὰ
ἀποκείμενα
αὐτῷ
The Vulgate runs
“Non auferetur sceptrum de Iuda, et dux de femore eius, donec
veniat qui mittendus est et ipse erit expectatio
gentium.”
992
Hebrews ii.
16
993
Hebrews vii.
14
994
Micah v. 2
995
Matthew ii. 5,
6
996
Matthew ii. 6
997
Micah v. 2
998
Romans ix. 5
999
Baruch iii. 35,
37
“The ascription of the
prophecy of Baruch to Jeremiah may be explained by the fact that in the
lxx. Baruch was placed either before or after Lamentations, and was
regarded in the early church as an appendix to, and of equal authority
with, Jeremiah. It is so quoted by Irenæus, Clemens Alexandrinus,
and Tertullian.”
Augustine de Civ. xviii,
33. quotes
Baruch iii. 16
. with the remark
“Hoc testimonium quidem non Hieremiæ sed Scribæ eius
attribuunt qui vocabatur Baruch, sed Hieremiæ celebratius
habetur.”
1000
1 Tim. i. 17
1001
1 Tim. vi. 16
1002
Baruch iii.
38
1003
1 Tim. i. 17
1004
1 Tim. vi. 16
1005
Heb. ii. 16
1006
1 Tim. iii.
16
.
Theodoretus shews no knowledge of the reading * for * in this famous
passage accepted by our revisers with the marginal comment “The
word
God
in place of
He who
rests on no sufficient
ancient evidence.” Macedonius II, patriarch of Constantinople, is
said to have been accused by his enemy the Emperor Anastasius of
falsifying this particular passage. But if Theodoretus, who died c.
458, really wrote * copies of the Epistles containing this reading must
have existed some half century before the dispute between Macedonius
and Anastasius. Gregory of Nyssa also uses the passage as does
Theodoretus; Greg. Nyss. cont. Eun. iv. i. The accepted opinion now
regards the Codex of Alexandrianus as reading
ὅς
1007
Matt. xviii.
10
.
Observe the omission of the words “In heaven,” which A.V.
inserts with
א
B D, etc.
1008
John vi. 46
1009
John i. 18
1010
Exodus xxxiii.
20
1011
Genesis xviii.
i.
Sept.
1012
Isaiah vi.
i
1013
Exodus xxxiii.
11
1014
Numbers xii.
8
1015
Hosea xii. 10
. Sept. A.V. has
“used similitudes.”
1016
Matthew xviii.
10
1017
1 Tim. iii.
16
1018
Hebrews x.
19–22
. In iii. 607. ed. Migne this passage is quoted by Theodoret
as in A.V.
1019
Gen. xlix. 10
. Compare note on
p. 6.
1020
Gen. xlix. 11
1021
μυστικώτερον
1022
John xv. 1
1023
John xix. 34
1024
John xii. 23
1025
John xii. 24
1026
This
passage and a parallel passage from Dial. II. were quoted with force in
the discussions of the English Reformation. Bp. Ridley on the foregoing
writes (
A Brief Declaration of the Lord’s Supper,
Parker
Soc. Ed. p. 35.) “What can be more plainly said than this that
this old writer saith? That although the Sacraments bear the name of
the body and blood of Christ, yet is not their nature changed, but
abideth still. And where is then the Papists’
transubstantiation?”
1027
Gen. xlix. 2
1028
Matt. xxvi.
28
1029
John vi. 51
1030
Aristotle (Œc: 1. 6. 1.) uses the proverb as we say in
English “to draw water in a sieve.”
1031
Heb. ii. 16
1032
Gen. ii. 18
1033
Heb. vii. 14
1034
Heb. v. 1
; viii.
3
1035
Heb. x. 5
1036
Matt. i. 20
. The rendering
of
γεννηθέν
by “conceived” in the A.V. somewhat obscures the
argument of Theodoret. The R.V. has “begotten” in the
margin.
1037
Ps. xl. 7
. Septuagint. The
difficulty how to account for the rendering of
אָןְמַסִ כָּרִיהלִו
i.e. “My ear hast thou dug” by
“
σῶμα
κατηρτίσω
” is an old one. Did
ΗΘΕΛΗCΑCΩΤΙΑΔΕΚΑΤΗΡΤΙCΩ
get altered by mistake into
ΗΘΕΛΗCΑCCΩΜΑΔΕΚΑΤΗΡΤΙCΩ
? “How the word
σῶμα
came into the lxx. we cannot say; but being there it is now
sanctioned for us by the citation here; not as the, or even a proper
rendering of the Hebrew, but as a prophetic utterance.” Alford ad
loc.
1038
I
have no hesitation in translating
ἀλλὰ
here by
“save,” in spite of the purist prejudice which has led even
the revisers of 1881 to retain something of the awkward periphrasis by
which the meaning of
Matt. xx. 23
and
Mark x. 40
. is confused in A.V.,
and an Arian sense given to our Lord’s declaration, “To sit
on my right hand and my left is not mine to give save to them for whom
it is prepared.” i.e. It is His to give, but not to give
arbitrarily or of caprice. Liddell and Scott, Ed. 1883, recognise and
illustrate this use of
ἀλλὰ
(Vide s.v. I. 3.)
which in classical Greek is vindicated by such a passage as Soph. O.T.
1331.
ἔπαισε δ᾽
αὐτόχειρ νιν
οὔτις ἀλλ᾽
ἐγώ
, and in N.T. Greek, as
well as by the crucial passage in question, in
Mark ix. 8
οὐκέτι
οὐδένα εἶδον
ἀλλὰ τὸν
Ιησοῦν
μόνον
, “They no
longer saw any one
save
Jesus only.”
1039
Ps. lxxxix. 1,
2
1040
Ps. lxxxix. 3
1041
Ps. lxxxix. 3
1042
Ps. lxxxix. 4
1043
1 Cor. vi. 10
1044
Gal. iii. 1
1045
2 Tim. iii. 8
1046
Phil. iii. 19
1047
Ps. lxxxix. 4
1048
Antipater or Antipas, a = Cypros, an Idumæan,
wealthy Idumæan.
|
Herod the Great =
Mariamne, Princess of the Maccabees.
|
_____________________
| |
Alexander.
Aristobulus.
|
__________________________________
| |
Herod Agrippa I. Herod K. of
Chalcis. Herodias.
|
__________________________
| |
Herod Agrippa II. Bernice.
Drusilla.
1049
Ps. lxxxix.
25
1050
Ps. lxxxix.
27
1051
Ps. lxxxix.
26
1052
Ps. lxxxix. 28,
29
1053
Ps. lxxxix. 35, 36,
37
1054
Heb. vi. 17
1055
Heb. vi. 18
1056
Is. lv. 3
1057
Is. lv. 4, 5
, lxx.
1058
Isaiah xi. 1
1059
Isaiah xi. 2
1060
1 Cor. xii. 8
1061
A.V.
“reprove with equity for the meek of the earth;”
Sept.
ἐλέγξει
τοὺς
ταπεινους
τῆς γῆς
1062
Isaiah xi. 4
1063
Is. xi. 6
1064
Isaiah xi. 10
1065
Isaiah xi. 9
1066
Acts ii.
30–31
1067
Acts xiii. 23
1068
2 Tim. ii. 8
1069
Romans i.
1–3
1070
Matt. i. 2
1071
John i. 14
1072
A
κενὴ
ἐλπίσο
πίστις
would be
a faith which could not possibly be realized; and
ματαία
ἐλπίς
a hope of not
impossible but very improbable fulfilment. But the distinction
between
κενός
and
ματαῖος
is hardly borne out by their use in the text.
1073
Ephes. ii. 6
1074
John i. 14
1075
John i. 14
1076
Phil. ii. 5,
8
1077
John x. 33
1078
John ix. 16
1079
Matt. viii.
27
1080
1 John iv. 2,
3
1081
Ed.
Ben. I. 2. 207.
1082
Gal. iii. 13
1083
I
Ep. ad Cled. i. Ed. Paris. p. 744.
1084
2 Cor. v. 21
.
Gal. iii.
13
1085
Isaiah liii.
4
1086
de
Incar. Dom. Sac. vi. II. Ed. Ben. p. 716. The Latin of Ambrose, which
is not exactly rendered by Theodoret, is as follows:—
"Sic
scriptum est, inquiunt, quia Verbum caro factum est (Ioan 1, 14).
Scriptum est, non nego: sed considera quid sequatur; sequitur enim: Et
habitavit in nobis, hoc est, illud Verbum quod carnem suscepit, hoc
habitavit in nobis, hoc est, in carue habitavit humana.
"Miraris ergo quia scriptum est:
Verbum caro factum est, cum caro assumpta sit a Dei Verbo: quando de
peccato quod non habuit, scriptum est quia peccatum factus est, hoc
est, non natura operationeque peccati, utpote in similitudinem carnis
peccati factus: sed ut peccatum nostrum in sua carne crucifigeret,
susceptionem pro nobis infirmitatum obnoxii jam corporis peccati
carnalis assumpsit.
Desinant ergo dicere
naturam Verbi in corporis naturam esse mutatam; ne pari interpretatione
videatur natura Verbi in contagium mutata peccati Aliud est enim quod
assumpsit, et aliud quod assumptum est.”
1087
Compare note on page 72.
1088
“In the Eastern church till nearly the end of the fourth
century we find, as has been said, the divine celebration of
Christ’s nativity and baptism on January 6th. The date of the
severance of the two can be approximately fixed, for Chrysostom refers
to it as a matter of merely a few years’ standing, in a sermon
probably delivered on the Christmas day of 386
a.d.
How far back we are to refer the origin of this
two-fold festival it is not easy to determine, the earliest mention of
any kind being the allusion by Clement of Alexandria to the annual
commemoration of Christ’s baptism by the Basilidians (Stromata,
lib. i. c. 21). At any rate by the latter part of the fourth century
the Epiphany had become one of the most important and venerable
festivals in the Eastern church.”
Dict. Christ. Ant. i.
617.
1089
Chrys. Ed. Sav. II. p. 598.
1090
Gal. iii. 13
1091
The
modern reader will not omit to note the bearing of these patristic
interpretations of the scriptural statements that the word was
“made” flesh and that Christ was “made” a curse
on later controversies concerning Transubstantiation.
1092
On
the northern seaboard of Syria. Severianus was at one time
Chrysostom’s commissary and afterwards his determined
opponent.
1093
The
value of Chrysostom and Severianus as independent witnesses is somewhat
weakened by the fact, pointed out by Schulze, that among the writings
of the former some are attributed to the latter.
1094
The
Apost. Const. vii. 46. represent Ignatius as ordained by St. Paul.
Malalas describes St. Peter as ordaining Ignatius on the death of
Euodius. Vide article “Euodius” in Dict. Christ.
Biog.
1095
Bp.
Lightfoot (
Ap. Fathers pt. II. ii. 290
.) adopts the
reading
κατὰ
θέλημα καὶ
δύναμιν
for
κατὰ
θεότητα
,
and notes “Theodoret strangely substitutes
θεότητα
for
θέλημα
.
This reading…may be due to…ignorance of the absolute use
of
θελημα
. The
Armenian translator likewise has substituted another word.
1096
Matt. iii. 15
1097
Ig.
ad Smyrn. I.
1098
There is a play here on the
σαρκοφόρος, νεκροφόρος
, and, possibly,
θεοφόρος
. Vide Pearson and Lightfoot ad loc. (Ignat. ad Smyrn.
V.)
1099
“A saying to this effect is attributed to Our Lord by
Didymus on
Ps. lxxxviii. 8
. It is mentioned also by Origen Hom. XX. In
Jerem. Sec. III.” Bp. Lightfoot l. c.
1100
Ignat.
ad Smyrn. IV.
1101
Compare note on page 72.
1102
Bp.
Lightfoot adopts the reading of Cod. Med. “that by his passion he
might cleanse the water.” Ig. ad Eph. XVIII.
1103
Ig.
ad Eph. XX.
1104
Ignat. ad Eph. VII.
1105
Ig. ad
Trall. ix.
1106
Luke ii. 4
1107
Ps. cxxxii.
11
1108
Is. vii. 13
1109
Cont.
Hær. iii. 31.
1110
John iv. 6
1111
Ps. lxix. 26
. A.V. They talk
to the grief of those whom thou hast wounded. lxx. R.V. They tell of
the sorrow of those whom thou hast wounded.
1112
John xi. 35
1113
Luke xxii. 44
1114
Mat. xxvi. 28
1115
John xix. 34
1116
Cont. Hær. iii. 32.
1117
Rom. v. 19
1118
Cont. Hær. iii. 20.
1119
Ps. lxxxii.
67
1120
Cont.
Hær. iii. 21.
1121
Vide
note on page 72.
1122
Adv. Hær. iii. 26. The allusion is to the gnostics and mainly
to Valentinus and his school who imagined seven heavens, and a
supercelestial space termed “Ogdoad.” “The doctrine
of an Ogdoad of the commencement of finite existence having been
established by Valentinus, those of his followers who had been imbued
with the Pythagorean philosophy introduced a modification. In that
philosophy the tetrad was regarded with peculiar veneration, and held
to be the foundation of the sensible world.” Cf. Hippolytus Ref.
vi. 23, p. 179 “We read there (Iren. i. xi.) of Secundus as a
Valentinian who divided the Ogdoad into a right hand and a left hand
tetrad, and in the case of Marcus who largely uses Pythagorean
speculations about numbers, the tetrad holds the highest place in the
system.” Dr. Salmon, Dict. Christ. Biog. iv. 72. Irenæus
wrote a work, no longer extant, “on the Ogdoad.” Euseb.
H.E. v. 20.
1123
Ps. xxiii. 1
1124
Ps. xxxviii.
5
1125
Vide
Isaiah xix. 1
1126
Bishop first of Olympus and then of Patara at the beginning of the
4th c. This is the only fragment preserved by Theodoret.
1127
Acts vii. 57
1128
Prov. viii.
22
.
Sept.
1129
John ii. 19
1130
John xv. 5
and 1
1131
Ps. xii. 22
1132
John i. 1
1133
John i. 14
1134
Gen. xlix. 11
, lxx.
1135
John i. 1
1136
John i. 14
1137
Rev. i. 9
1138
Ps. xxi. 12
1139
Ps. lxxxviii. 4,
5
1140
Isaiah ii. 13
1141
The
antithesis is between the Greek words
θέσις
and
φύσις
. cf. “
Κρινοτέλην
Πινδάρου,
θέσὲι δὲ
Φιλοξένου
.” Corp. Ins. (add.) 2480. d.
1142
Luke iii. 38
1143
Ps. lx. 8
1144
Gal. iv. 4
1145
1 Cor. xi. 12
1146
1 Cor. xv. 47
1147
1 Cor. xv. 48
1148
John iii. 13
1149
John i. 3
1150
Ephes. iii.
17
1151
The
original for
ἁρπάσας
, “seizing” has
ἁγιάσας
i.e.
hallowing.
1152
The
word used is
πρωτοπαθεῖν
, a late and rare one. Galen uses the correlative
πρωτοπὰθεια
to express a condition distinguished from
συμπάθεια
1153
Phil. ii. 7
1154
John v. 19
1155
Matt. xxvi.
41
1156
Luke i. 35
1157
Prov. ix. 1
1158
Prov. viii.
22
;
lxx. “
ἔκτισε
.”
1159
οἰκονομὶα
. cf. note on p. 72.
1160
Phil. ii. 6,
7
1161
Deut. x. 17
;
Rev. xvii. 14
. and
xix. 16
1162
Is. lxi. 1
1163
Of
these two works no fragments exist but these two preserved by
Theodoretus.
1164
John xiv. 28
1165
John v. 19
1166
οἰκονουία
. cf. note on p. 72.
1167
cf.
1 Cor. xv. 47
1168
Migne II. 356.
1169
e.g. Anubis, the barker Anubis—cf. Virg. Æn. viii. 698,
and the common oath “by the dog,” unless indeed the common
adjuration of Socrates
νὴ
τὸν κύνα
may have been only a vernacular substitute for
νὴ τὸν
Διὰ
, like the vulgar
“law” for “Lord.” The Benedictine Ed. adds
“cats.”
1170
cf.
Ephes. v. 12
1171
σκεῦος
. cf.
2 Cor.
iv. 7
.
1 Thess. iv. 4
.
1 Peter iii. 7
. Cicero. Tusc. 1. 22
calls the body “vas animi.”
1172
cf. p. 132.
1173
σάρκωσις
κένωσις
.
cf.
Phil. ii. 7
1174
Matt. x. 24