The difficulty was to find a formula. The test of
Nicæa could not be superseded without putting something in its
place, which should include Arianism as effectually as the other
had excluded it. Such a test was eventually (after 357) found in the
word ὅμοιος We cannot
fix the date when this word was first adopted as a shibboleth. It
occurs, but not conspicuously, in the ‘Macrostich’ of 344,
but not in any other creed till the ‘dated’ symbol of 359.
But if (as Krüger, Lucif, p. 42, note, assumes)
the ὁμοιούσιον
was adopted as a protest against the bald ὅμοιον, the latter
must have been current long before 357, when the former was
proscribed. I incline to regard the ὅμοιον (as a
test word) as a later rival to the ὁμοιούσιον. It was
a word with a good Catholic history. We find it used freely by
Athanasius in his earlier anti-Arian writings, and it was thoroughly
current in conservative theology, as for example in Cyril’s
Catecheses (he has ὅμοιον κατὰ
τας γραφάς and
ὅμοιον κατὰ
πάντα). It would therefore permit even
the full Nicene belief. On the other hand many of the more earnest
conservative theologians had begun to reflect on what was involved in
the ‘likeness’ of the Son to the Father, and had formulated
the conviction that this likeness was essential, not, as the
Arians held, acquired. This was in fact a fair inference from the οὐσίας
ἀπαράλλακτον
εἰκόνα of the Dedication Creed.
This question made an agreement between men like Valens and Basil
difficult, but it could be evaded by keeping to the simple ὅμοιον, and deprecating
non-scriptural precision. Lastly, there were the Anomœans to be
considered. Now the ὅμοιον had the specious appearance
of flatly contradicting this repellent avowal of the extremists; but to
Valens and his friends it had the substantial recommendation of
admitting it in reality. ‘Likeness’ is a relative term. If
two things are only ‘like’ they are ipso facto to
some extent unlike; the two words are not contradictories but
correlatives, and if the likeness is not essential, the unlikeness is.
So far then as the ‘Homœan’ party rested on any
doctrinal principle at all, that principle was the principle of Arius;
and that is how Valens forwarded the Anomœan cause by putting
himself at the head of the Homœans. His plan of campaign had
steadily matured. The deposition of Photinus in 351 had sounded the
note of war, Arles and Milan (353–5) and the expulsion of
Athanasius (356) had cleared the field of opponents, George was now in
possession at Alexandria, and in the summer of 357 the triumph of
Arianism was proclaimed. A small council of bishops met at Sirmium and
published a Latin Creed, insisting strongly (1) on the unique Godhead
of the Father, (2) on the subjection of the Son ‘along with all
things subjected to Him by the Father,’ and (3) strictly
proscribing the terms ὁμοούσιον, ὁμοιούσιον,
and all discussion of οὐσία, as unscriptural and
inscrutable.