Elucidations.
————————————
I.
(The Second Commandment, p. 64
.)
Tertullian’s
teaching agrees with that of Clement of Alexandria
346
and with all the Primitive Fathers. But
compare the Trent Catechism, (chapter ii., quest. 17.)—“Nor
let any one suppose that this commandment prohibits the arts of
painting, modelling or sculpture,
for
, in the Scriptures we are
informed that God himself commanded images of cherubim, and
also of
the brazen serpent
, to be made, etc.” So far, the comparison
is important, because while our author limits any inference from this
instance as an
exception
, this Catechism turns it into a
rule
: and so far, we are only looking at the matter with
reference to Art. But, the Catechism, (quest. xxiii. xxiv.), goes on to
teach that images of the Saints,
etc
. ought to be made and
honoured “as a holy practice.” It affirms, also, that it is
a practice which has been
attended with the greatest advantage to
the faithful
: which admits of a doubt, especially when the
honour
thus mentioned is everywhere turned into
worship
,
precisely like that offered to the Brazen Serpent, when the People
“burned incense to it,” and often much more. But even this
is not my point; for that Catechism, with what verity need not be
argued, affirms, also, that this doctrine “
derives
confirmation
from the monuments of the Apostolic age, the general
Councils of the Church, and the writings of so many most holy and
learned Fathers,
who are of one accord upon the subject.
”
Doubtless they are “of one accord,” but all the other
way.
II.
(Military service, cap. xix., p. 73.)
This chapter must prepare us for a much more sweeping
condemnation of the military profession in the
De Spectaculis
and the
De Corona
; but Neander’s judgment seems to
me very just. The
Corona
, itself, is rather Montanistic
than Montanist, in the opinion of some critics, among whom Gibbon is
not to count for much, for the reasons given by Kaye (p. 52), and
others hardly less obvious. Surely, if this ascetic opinion and some
similar instances were enough to mark a man as a heretic, what are we
to say of the thousand crotchets maintained by good Christians, in our
day?
III.
(Passive idolatry, cap. xxii., pp. 74, 75.)
Neander’s opinion as to the freedom of
De
Idololatria
from Montanistic taint, is mildly questioned by Bp.
Kaye, chiefly on the ground of the agreement of this chapter with the
extravagances of the
Scorpiace
. He thinks “the utmost
pitch” of such extravagance is reached in the positions here
taken. But Neander’s judgment seems to me preferable. Lapsers
usually give tokens of the bent of their minds, and unconsciously
betray their inclinations before they themselves see whither they are
tending. Thus they become victims of their own plausible
self-deceptions.
IV.
(Tacit consents and reservations, cap. xxiii., p.
75.)
It cannot be doubted that apart from the specific
case which Tertullian is here maintaining, his appeal to conscience is
maintained by reason, by the Morals of the Fathers and by Holy
Scripture. Now compare with this the Morality which has been made
dogmatic, among Latins, by the elevation of Liguori to the dignities of
a “Saint” and a “Doctor of the Church.” Even
Cardinal Newman cannot accept it without
reservations
, so
thoroughly does it commit the soul to fraud and hypocrisy. See
Liguori,
Opp. Tom.
II., pp. 34–44, and Meyrick,
Moral
Theology of the Church of Rome
, London, 1855. Republished,
with an Introduction, by the Editor of this Series, Baltimore, 1857.
Also Newman,
Apologia
, p. 295
et seqq.
346
See vol. II., p. 186,
this series.