It should be noted here that Baronius, Bellarmine,
Binius, and Surius all question the authenticity of the Caroline Books
altogether. (Vide Baron, Annal., a.d., 794.) But this extreme position seems to be
refuted by the fact that certain quotations made by Hincmar are found
in the books as we have them. (Cf. Sirmond in Mansi, Tom.
XIII., 905, Labbe, Tom. VII., col. 1054.)