390 ON THE TRINITY. [bOOK XV.
or the Son, or the Holy Spirit ; and in the same way that the
Son remembers neither Himself nor the Father, except by the
Father, nor loves them except by the Holy Spirit ; but that
by Himself He only understands both the Father and Son
and Holy Spirit : and in like manner, that the Holy Spirit
by the Father remembers both the Father and the Son and
Himself, and by the Son understands both the Father and
the Son and Himself; but by Himself only loves both Him-
self and the Father and the Son;— as though the Father
were both His own memory, and that of the Son and of
the Holy Spirit ; and the Son were the understanding of both
Himself, and the Father and the Holy Spirit ; but the Holy
Spirit were the love both of Himself, and of the Father and of
the Son ? "Who would presume to think or affirm this of that
Trinity ? For if therein the Son alone understands both for
Himself and for the Father and for the Holy Spirit, we have
returned to the old absurdity, that the Father is not wise from
Himself, but from the Son, and that wisdom has not begotten
wisdom, but that the Father is said to be wise by that wis-
dom which He begat. For where there is no understanding
there can be no wisdom ; and hence, if the Father does not
understand Himself for Himself, but the Son understands for
the Father, assuredly the Son makes the Father wise. But
if to God to be is to be wise, and essence is to Him the same
as wisdom, then it is not the Son that has His essence from
the Father, which is the truth, but rather the Father from the
Son, which is a most absurd falsehood. And this absurdity,
beyond all doubt, we have discussed, disproved, and rejected,
in the seventh book. Therefore God the Father is wise by
that wisdom by which He is His own wisdom, and the Son
is the wisdom of the Father from the wisdom which is the
Father, from whom the Son is begotten; whence it foUows
that the Father understands also by that understanding by
which He is His own understanding (for he could not be
wise that did not understand) ; and that the Son is the under-
standing of the Father, begotten of the understanding which
is the Father. And this same may not be unfitly said of
memory also. For how is he wise, that remembers nothing,
or does not remember himself? Accordingly, since the