(a) The Council of Alexandria in 362. The
eight months of undisturbed residence enjoyed by Athanasius under
Julian were well employed. One of his first acts was to convoke a Synod
at Alexandria to deal with the questions which stood in the way of the
peace of the Church. The Synod was one ‘of saints and
confessors,’ including as it did many of the Egyptian bishops who
had suffered under George (p. 483, note 3, again we miss the name of
the trusted Serapion), Asterius of Petra and Eusebius of Vercellae,
with legates from Lucifer of Calaris, Apollinarius of Laodicea, and
Paulinus the Presbyter who ruled the Eustathian community of Antioch.
Our knowledge of the proceedings of the Synod (with an exception to be
referred to later on) is derived entirely from its ‘Tome’
or Synodal letter addressed to the latter community and to the exiles
who were its guests. Rufinus, from whom or from the Tome itself
Socrates appears to derive his knowledge, follows the Tome closely,
with perhaps a faint trace of knowledge from some other He states
(1) That a rigorist party in the council were at first opposed to all
conciliatory measures; this is highly probable, see Hieron. adv.
Lucif. 20; (2) that former active Arians were to be admitted to lay
communion only; this is not unlikely; (3) by implication, that Eusebius
and Lucifer went first to Antioch, and agreed to take no step till
after the Council which Eus. was to attend in person, and Luc. by
deputy, at Alxa., but that Luc. broke his promise. This may contain a
grain of truth, i.e. that Lucifer promised to do nothing before he
heard from Alxa., but Eusebius can scarcely have gone to Antioch. I owe
these notices to the excellent analysis of our sources of information
in Krüger, Lucif. p. 46 sq.; but he makes an odd
slip, p. 48, in saying that Soz. ‘schweigt von der Synode zu
Alex. uberhaupt.’ source. Sozomen gives a short and inadequate
report (v. 12). But the importance of the Council is out of all
proportion either to the number of bishops who took part in it or to
the scale of its documentary records. Jerome goes so far as to say that
by its judicious conciliation it ‘snatched the whole world from
the jaws of Satan’ (Adv. Lucif. 20). If this is in any
measure true, if it undid both in East and West the humiliating results
of the twin Synods of 359, the honour of the achievement is due to
Athanasius alone. He saw that victory was not to be won by smiting men
who were ready for peace, that the cause of Christ was not to be
furthered by breaking the bruised reed and quenching the smoking flax.
(Best accounts of the Council, Newman, Arians V. i.,
Krüger, Lucif. 41–52, Gwatkin, p. 205, sqq.)
The details may be reserved for the Introduction to the Tome, p. 481.
But in the strong calm moderation of that document we feel that
Athanasius is no longer a combatant arduously contending for victory,
but a conqueror surveying the field of his triumph and resolving upon
the terms of peace. The Council is the ripe first-fruits of the de
Synodis, the decisive step by which he placed himself at the head
of the reuniting forces of Eastern Christendom; forces which under the
recognised headship of the ‘Father of Orthodoxy’ were able
successfully to withstand the revived political supremacy of Arianism
under Valens, and after his death to cast it out of the Church. The
Council then is justly recognised as the crown of the career of
Athanasius, for its resolutions and its Letter unmistakably proceed
from him alone, and none but he could have tempered the fiery zeal of
the confessors and taught them to distinguish friend from foe.