First of all, however, I think
it advisable to run briefly over our own doctrinal views and our
opponent’s disagreement with them, so that our review of the
propositions in question may proceed methodically. Now the main point
of Christian orthodoxy εὐσεβείας. That this is the predominant idea in the word will be
seen from the following definitions: “Piety is a devout life
joined with a right faith” (Œcumenius on 1 Tim. iv.
p. 754). “Piety is the looking up to the one only God, Who is
believed to be and is the true God, and the life in accordance with
this” (Eusebius, P. E. i. p. 3). “Piety is the
science of adoration” (Suidas). is to believe that
the Only-begotten God, Who is the truth and the true light, and the
power of God and the life, is truly all that He is said to be, both in
other respects and especially in this, that He is God and the truth,
that is to say, God in truth, ever being what He is conceived to be and
what He is called, Who never at any time was not, nor ever will cease
to be, Whose being, such as it is essentially, is beyond the reach of
the curiosity that would try to comprehend it. But to us, as saith the
word of Wisdom, Wisdom of Solomon xiii.
5.
“For by the greatness and beauty of the creatures proportionately
(ἀναλόγως) the maker of them is seen.” Compare Romans i. 20. He makes Himself
known that He is “by the greatness and beauty of His creatures
proportionately” to the things that are known, vouchsafing to us
the gift of faith by the operations of His hands, but not the
comprehension of what He is. Whereas, then, such is the opinion
prevailing among all Christians, (such at least as are truly worthy of
the appellation, those, I mean, who have been taught by the law to
worship nothing that is not very God, and by that very act of worship
confess that the Only-begotten is God in truth, and not a God falsely
so called,) there arose this deadly blight of the Church, bringing
barrenness on the holy seeds of the faith, advocating as it does the
errors of Judaism, and partaking to a certain extent in the impiety of
the Greeks. For in its figment of a created God it advocates the error
of the Greeks, and in not accepting the Son it supports that of the
Jews. This school, then, which would do away with the very Godhead of
the Lord and teach men to conceive of Him as a created being, and not
that which the Father is in essence and power and dignity, since these
misty ideas find no support when exposed on all sides to the light of
truth, have overlooked all those names supplied by Scripture for the
glorification of God, and predicated in like manner of the Father and
of the Son, and have betaken themselves to the word “ungenerate,”
a term fabricated by themselves to throw contempt on the greatness of
the Only-begotten God. For whereas an orthodox confession teaches us to
believe in the Only-begotten God so that all men should honour the Son
even as they honour the Father, these men, rejecting the orthodox terms
whereby the greatness of the Son is signified as on a par with the
dignity of the Father, draw from thence the beginnings and foundations
of their heresy in regard to His Divinity. For as the Only-begotten
God, as the voice of the Gospel teaches, came forth from the Father and
is of Him, misrepresenting this doctrine by a change of terms, they
make use of them to rend the true faith in pieces. For whereas the
truth teaches that the Father is from no pre-existing cause, these men
have given to such a view the name of “ungeneracy,” and
signify the substance of the Only-begotten from the Father by the term
“generation,”—then comparing the two terms
“ungenerate” and “generate” as contradictories
to each other, they make use of the opposition to mislead their
senseless followers. For, to make the matter clearer by an
illustration, the expressions, He was generated and He was not
generated, are much the same as, He is seated and He is not seated, and
all such-like expressions. But they, forcing these expressions away
from the natural significance of the terms, are eager to put another
meaning upon them with a view to the subversion of orthodoxy. For
whereas, as has been said, the words “is seated” and
“is not seated” are not equivalent in meaning (the one
expression being contradictory of the other), they pretend that this
formal contradiction in expression indicates an essential difference,
ascribing generation to the Son and non-generation to the Father as
their essential attributes. Yet, as it is impossible to regard a
man’s sitting down or not as the essence of the man (for one
would not use the same definition for a man’s sitting as for the
man himself), so, by the analogy of the above example, the
non-generated essence is in its inherent idea something wholly
different from the thing expressed by “not having been
generated.” But our opponents, with an eye to their evil object,
that of establishing their denial of the Godhead of the Only-begotten,
do not say that the essence of the Father is ungenerate, but,
conversely, they declare ungeneracy to be His essence, in order that by
this distinction in regard to generation they may establish, by the
verbal opposition, a diversity of natures. In the direction of impiety
they look with ten thousand eyes, but with regard to the
impracticability of their own contention they are as incapable of
vision as men who deliberately close their eyes. For who but one whose
mental optics are utterly purblind can fail to discern the loose and
unsubstantial character of the principle of their doctrine, and that
their argument in support of ungeneracy as an essence has nothing to
stand upon? For this is the way in which their error would establish
itself.