This fragment gives us our only information in regard to this
Alexander. That there may be some truth in the story told by Apollonius
cannot be denied. It is possible that Alexander was a bad man, and that
the Montanists had been deceived in him, as often happens in all
religious bodies. Such a thing might much more easily happen after the
sect had been for a number of years in a flourishing condition than in
its earlier years; and the exactness of the account, and the challenge
to disprove it, would seem to lend it some weight. At the same time
Apollonius is clearly as unprincipled and dishonest a writer as the
anonymous, and hence little reliance can be placed upon any of his
reports to the discredit of the Montanists. If the anonymous made so
many accusations out of whole cloth, Apollonius may have done the same
in the present instance; and the fact that many still
“worshiped” him would seem to show that Apollonius’
accusations, if they possessed any foundation, were at any rate not
proven.