We believe that what was formerly decreed was
brought about both by God’s command and by order of your piety.
For we the bishops, from all the Western cities, assembled together at
Ariminum, both that the Faith of the Catholic Church might be made
known, and that gainsayers might be detected. For, as we have found
after long deliberation, it appeared desirable to adhere to and
maintain to the end, that faith which, enduring from antiquity, we have
received as preached by the prophets, the Gospels, and the Apostles
through our Lord Jesus Christ, Who is Keeper of your Kingdom and Patron
of your power. For it appeared wrong and unlawful to make any change in
what was rightly and justly defined, and what was resolved upon in
common at Nicæa along with the Emperor your father, the most
glorious Constantine,—the doctrine and spirit of which
[definition] went abroad and was proclaimed in the hearing and
understanding of all men. For it alone was the conqueror and destroyer
of the heresy of Arius, by which not that only but the other heresies The
Hilarian Latin is much briefer here. also were destroyed, to which of a truth it
is perilous to add, and full of danger to minish aught from it, since
if either be done, our enemies will be able with impunity to do
whatever they will. Accordingly Ursacius and Valens, since they had
been from of old abettors and
sympathisers of the Arian dogma, were properly declared separate from
our communion, to be admitted to which they asked to be allowed a place
of repentance and pardon for the transgressions of which they were
conscious, as the documents drawn up by them testify. By which means
forgiveness and pardon on all charges has been obtained. Now the time
of these transactions was when the council was assembled at Milan 347., the presbyters of the Roman Church being
also present. But knowing at the same time that Constantine of worthy
memory had with all accuracy and deliberation published the Faith then
drawn up; when he had been baptized by the hands of men, and had
departed to the place which was his due, [we think it] unseemly to make
a subsequent innovation and to despise so many saints, confessors,
martyrs, who compiled and drew up this decree; who moreover have
continued to hold in all matters according to the ancient law of the
Church; whose faith God has imparted even to the times of your reign
through our Master Jesus Christ, through whom also it is yours to reign
and rule over the world in our day The
whole passage is either much expanded by Athan., or much condensed by
Hilary.. Once more
then the pitiful men of wretched mind with lawless daring have
announced themselves as the heralds of an impious opinion, and are
attempting to upset every summary of truth. For when according to your
command the synod met, those men laid bare the design of their own
deceitfulness. For they attempted in a certain unscrupulous and
disorderly manner to propose to us an innovation, having found as
accomplices in this plot Germinius, Auxentius Auxentius, omitted in Hilary’s copy. A few words are wanting
in the Latin in the commencement of one of the sentences which follow.
[See above, note 3.],
and Gaius, the stirrers up of strife and discord, whose teaching by
itself has gone beyond every pitch of blasphemy. But when they
perceived that we did not share their purpose, nor agree with their
evil mind, they transferred themselves to our council, alleging that it
might be advisable to compile something instead. But a short time was
enough to expose their plans. And lest the Churches should have a
recurrence of these disturbances, and a whirl of discord and confusion
throw everything into disorder, it seemed good to keep undisturbed the
ancient and reasonable institutions, and that the above persons should
be separated from our communion. For the information therefore of your
clemency, we have instructed our legates to acquaint you with the
judgment of the Council by our letter, to whom we have given this
special direction, to establish the truth by resting their case upon
the ancient and just decrees; and they will also assure your piety that
peace would not be accomplished by the removal of those decrees as
Valens and Ursacius alleged. For how is it possible for peace-breakers
to bring peace? on the contrary, by their means strife and confusion
will arise not only in the other cities, but also in the Church of the
Romans. On this account we ask your clemency to regard our legates with
favourable ears and a serene countenance and not to suffer aught to be
abrogated to the dishonour of the dead; but allow us to abide by what
has been defined and laid down by our forefathers, who, we venture to
say, we trust in all things acted with prudence and wisdom and the Holy
Spirit; because by these novelties not only are the faithful made to
disbelieve, but the infidels also are embittered The
Greek here mistranslates ‘credulitatem’ as though it were
‘crudelitatem.’ The original sense is the heathen are kept
back from believing.. We pray also that you would give orders
that so many Bishops who are detained abroad, among whom are numbers
who are broken with age and poverty, may be enabled to return to their
own country, lest the Churches suffer, as being deprived of their
Bishops. This, however, we ask with earnestness, that nothing be
innovated upon existing creeds, nothing withdrawn; but that all remain
incorrupt which has continued in the times of your Father’s piety
and to the present time; and that you will not permit us to be
harassed, and estranged from our sees; but that the Bishops may in
quiet give themselves always to prayers and worship, which they do
always offer for your own safety and for your reign, and for peace,
which may the Divinity bestow on you for ever. But our legates are
conveying the subscriptions and titles of the Bishops, and will also
inform your piety from the Holy Scriptures themselves.