The history of the Council of Nice has been so often
written by so many brilliant historians, from the time of its sitting
down to to-day, that any historical notice of the causes leading to its
assembling, or account of its proceedings, seems quite
unnecessary. The editor, however, ventures to call the attention
of the reader to the fact that in this, as in every other of the Seven
Ecumenical Councils, the question the Fathers considered was not what
they supposed Holy Scripture might mean, nor what they, from à
priori arguments, thought would be consistent with the mind of God,
but something entirely different, to wit, what they had received.
They understood their position to be that of witnesses, not that of
exegetes. They recognized but one duty resting upon them in this
respect—to hand down to other faithful men that good thing the
Church had received according to the command of God. The first
requirement was not learning, but honesty. The question they were
called upon to answer was not, What do I think probable, or even
certain, from Holy Scripture? but, What have I been taught, what has
been intrusted to me to hand down to others? When the time came,
in the Fourth Council, to examine the Tome of Pope St. Leo, the
question was not whether it could be proved to the satisfaction of the
assembled fathers from Holy Scripture, but whether it was the
traditional faith of the Church. It was not the doctrine of Leo
in the fifth century, but the doctrine of Peter in the first, and of
the Church since then, that they desired to believe and to teach, and
so, when they had studied the Tome, they cried out: This is clearly set
forth by Pope Vigilius as follows: “No one can doubt that
our fathers believed that they should receive with veneration the
letter of blessed Leo if they declared it to agree with the doctrines
of the Nicene and Constantinopolitan Councils, as also with those of
blessed Cyril, set forth in the first of Ephesus. And if that
letter of so great a Pontiff, shining with so bright a light of the
orthodox Faith, needed to be approved by these comparisons, how can
that letter to Maris the Persian, which specially rejects the First
Council of Ephesus and declares to be heretics the expressed doctrines
of the blessed Cyril, be believed to have been called orthodox by these
same Fathers, condemning as it does those writings, by comparison with
which, as we have said, the doctrine of so great a Pontiff deserved to
be commended?”—Vigil., Constitutum pro dammatione Trium
Capitulorum. Migne, Pat. Lat., tom. lxix., col.
162.