Historical
Introduction.
(Bossuet,
Def. Cler. Gall
., Lib. vij., Cap. ix.
et seqq
. Abridged. Translation by Allies.)
The innovation of Nestorius, Bishop of Constantinople,
is known; how he divided into two the person of Christ. Pope St.
Celestine, watchful, according to his office, over the affairs of the
Church, had charged the blessed Cyril, Bishop of Alexandria, to send
him a certain report of the doctrine of Nestorius, already in bad
repute. Cyril declares this in his letter to Nestorius; and so he
writes to Celestine a complete account, and sets forth the doctrines of
Nestorius and his own; he sends him two letters from himself to
Nestorius, who likewise, by his own letters and explanations,
endeavoured to draw Celestine to his side. Thus the holy Pontiff,
having been most fully informed by letters from both sides, is thus
inquired of by Cyril. “We have not confidently abstained
from Communion with him (Nestorius) before informing you of this;
condescend, therefore, to unfold your judgment, that we may clearly
know whether we ought to communicate with him who cherishes such
erroneous doctrine.” And he adds, that his judgment should
be written to the other Bishops also, “that all with one mind may
hold firm in one sentence.” Here is the Apostolic See
manifestly consulted by so great a man, presiding over the second, or
at least the third, Patriarchal See, and its judgment awaited; and
nothing remained but that Celestine, being duly consulted, should
perform his Apostolic office. But how he did this, the Acts have
shewn. In those Acts he not only approves the letters and
doctrine of Cyril, but disapproves, too, the perverse dogma of
Nestorius, and that distinctly, because he was unwilling to call the
blessed Virgin Mother of God: and he decrees that he should be
deprived of the Episcopate and Communion unless, within ten days from
the date of the announcing of the sentence, he openly rejects this
faithless innovation, which endeavours to separate what Scripture
joineth together—that is, the Person of Christ. Here is the
doctrine of Nestorius expressly disapproved, and a sentence of the
Roman Pontiff on a matter of Faith most clearly pronounced under threat
of deposition and excommunication: then, that nothing be wanting,
the holy Pope commits his authority to Cyril to carry into execution
that sentence “associating,” he saith to Cyril, “the
authority of our See, and using our person, and place, with
power.” So to Cyril; so to Nestorius himself; so to the
clergy of Constantinople; so to John of Antioch, then the Bishop of the
third or fourth Patriarchal See; so to Juvenal, Bishop of the Holy
City, whom the Council of Nice had ordered to be especially
honoured: so he writes to the other Bishops also, that the
sentence given may be duly and in order made known to all. Cyril
proceeds to execute his office, and performs all that he had been
commanded. He promulgates and executes the decrees of Celestine;
declares to Nestorius, that after the ten days prescribed and set forth
by Celestine, he would have no portion, intercourse, or place with the
priesthood. Nothing evidently is wanting to the Apostolical
authority being most fully exercised.
But Nestorius, bishop of the royal city, possessed such
influence, had deceived men’s minds with such an appearance of
piety, had gained so many bishops and enjoyed such favour with the
younger Theodosius and the great men, that he could easily throw
everything into commotion; and thus there was need of an Ecumenical
Council, the question being most important, and the person of the
highest dignity; because many bishops, amongst these almost all of the
East—that is, of the Patriarchate of Antioch, and the Patriarch
John himself—were ill disposed to Cyril, and seemed to favour
Nestorius: because men’s feelings were divided, and the
whole empire of the East seemed to fluctuate between Cyril and
Nestorius. Such was the need of an Ecumenical Council.
The Emperor, moved by these and other reasons, wrote to
Cyril,—“It is our will that the
holy doctrine be discussed and examined in a
sacred Synod, and that be ratified which appeareth agreeable to the
right faith, whether the wrong party be pardoned by the Fathers or
no.”
Here we see three things: First, after the
judgment of St. Celestine, another is still required, that of the
Council; secondly, that these two things would rest with the Fathers,
to judge of doctrine and of persons; thirdly, that the judgment of the
Council would be decisive and final. He adds, “those who
everywhere preside over the Priesthood, and through whom we ourselves
are and shall be professing the truth, must be judges of this
matter.” See on whose faith we rest. See in whose
judgment is the final and irreversible authority.
Both the Emperor affirmed, and the bishops confessed,
that this was done according to the Ecclesiastical Canons. And so
all, and Celestine himself, prepared themselves for the Council.
Cyril does no more, though named by Celestine to execute the pontifical
decree, Nestorius remained in his original rank; the sentence of the
universal Council is awaited; and the Emperor had expressly decreed,
“that before the assembling and common sentence of the most holy
Council, no change should be made in any matter at all, on any private
authority.” Rightly, and in order; for this was demanded by
the majesty of an universal Council. Wherefore, both Cyril obeyed
and the bishops rested. And it was established, that although the
sentence of the Roman Pontiff on matters of Faith, and on persons
judged for violation of the Faith, had been passed and promulged, all
was suspended, while the authority of the universal Council was
awaited.
Having gone over what preceded the Council, we review
the acts of the Council itself, and begin with the first course of
proceeding. After, therefore, the bishops and Nestorius himself
were come to Ephesus, the universal Council began, Cyril being
president, and representing Celestine, as being appointed by the
Pontiff himself to execute his sentence. In the first course of
proceeding this was done. First, the above-mentioned letter of
the Emperor was read, that an Ecumenical Council should be held, and
all proceedings in the mean time be suspended; this letter, I say, was
read, and placed on the Acts, and it was approved by the Fathers, that
all the decrees of Celestine in the matter of Nestorius had been
suspended until the holy Council should give its sentence. You
will ask if it was the will of the Council merely that the Emperor
should be allowed to prohibit, in the interim, effect being given to
the sentence of the Apostolic See. Not so, according to the Acts;
but rather, by the intervention of a General Council’s authority
(the convocation of which, according to the discipline of those times,
was left to the Emperor), the Council itself understood that all
proceedings were of course suspended, and depended on the sentence of
the Council. Wherefore, though the decree of the Pontiff had been
promulged and notified, and the ten days had long been past, Nestorius
was held by the Council itself to be a bishop, and called by the name
of most religious bishop, and by that name, too, thrice cited and
summoned to take his seat with the other bishops in the holy Council;
for this expression, “to take his seat,” is distinctly
written; and it is added, “in order to answer to what was charged
against him.” For it was their full purpose that he should
recognise in whatever way, the Ecumenical Council, as he would then
afterwards be, beyond doubt, answerable to it; but he refused to come,
and chose to have his doors besieged with an armed force, that no one
might approach him.
Thereupon, as the Emperor commanded, and the Canons
required, the rule of Faith was set forth, and the Nicene Creed read,
as the standard to which all should be referred, and then the letters
of Cyril and Nestorius were examined in order. The letter of
Cyril was first brought before the judgment of the Council. That
letter, I mean, concerning the Faith, to Nestorius, so expressly
approved by Pope Celestine, of which he had declared to Cyril,
“We
see that you hold and
maintain all that we hold and maintain”; which, by the decree
against Nestorius, published to all Churches, he had approved, and
wishes to be considered as a canonical monition against
Nestorius: that letter, I repeat, was examined, at the
proposition of Cyril himself, in these words: “I am
persuaded that I have in nothing departed from the orthodox Faith, or
the Nicene Creed; wherefore I beseech your Holiness to set forth openly
whether I have written this correctly, blamelessly, and in accordance
with that holy Council.”
And are there those who say that questions concerning
the Faith, once judged by the Roman Pontiff on his Apostolical
authority, are examined in general Councils, in order to understand
their contents, but not to decide on their substance, as being still a
matter of question? Let them hear Cyril, the President of the
Council; let them attend to what he proposes for the inquiry of the
Council; and though he were conscious of no error in himself yet, not
to trust himself, he asked for the sentence of the Council in these
words “whether I have written correctly and blamelessly, or
not.” This Cyril, the chief of the Council, proposes for
their consideration. Who ever even heard it whispered that, after
a final and irreversible judgment of the Church on a matter of Faith,
any such inquiry or question was made? It was never done, for
that would be to doubt about the Faith itself, when declared and
discussed. But this was done after the judgment of Pope
Celestine; neither Cyril, nor anyone else, thought of any other
course: that, therefore, was not a final and irreversible
judgment.
In answer to this question the Fathers in order give
their judgment—“that the Nicene Creed, and the letter of
Cyril, in all things agree and harmonise.” Here is inquiry
and examination, and then judgment. The Acts speak for
themselves—we say not here a word.
Next that letter of Nestorius was produced, which
Celestine had pronounced blasphemous and impious. It is
read: then at the instance of Cyril it is examined,
“whether this, too, be agreeable to the Faith set forth by the
holy Council of the Nicene Fathers, or not.” It is
precisely the same form according to which Cyril’s letter was
examined. The Fathers, in order, give judgment that it disagreed
from the Nicene Creed, and was, therefore, censurable. The letter
of Nestorius is disapproved in the same manner, by the same rule, by
which that of Cyril was approved. Here, twice in the same
proceeding of the Council of Ephesus, a judgment of the Roman Pontiff
concerning the Catholic Faith, uttered and published, is
reconsidered. What he had approved, and what he had disapproved,
is equally examined, and, only after examination, confirmed.
In the mean time, the bishops Arcadius and Projectus,
and the presbyter Philip, had been chosen by Celestine to be present at
the Council of Ephesus, with a special commission from the Apostolic
See, and the whole Council of the West. So they come from Rome to
Ephesus, and appear at the holy Council, and here the second procedure
commences.
After reading the letter of Celestine, the Legates, in
pursuance, say to the bishops: “Let your Holiness consider
the form of the letters of the holy and venerable Pope Celestine the
Bishop, who hath exhorted your Holiness, not as instructing those who
are ignorant, but as reminding those who are aware: in order that
you may command to be completely and finally settled according to the
Canon of our common Faith, and the utility of the Catholic Church, what
he has before determined, and has now the goodness to remind you
of.” This is the advantage of a Council; after whose
sentence there is no new discussion, or new judgment, but merely
execution. And this the Legates request to be commanded by the
Council, in which they recognise that supreme authority.
It behoved, also, that the Legates, sent to the Council
on a special mission, should understand whether the proceedings against
Nestorius had been pursued according to the requisition of the Canons,
and due respect to the Apostolic See. This we have already often
said. Wherefore, with reason,
they require the Acts to be communicated, “that we, too,”
say they, “may confirm them.” The proceedings
themselves will declare what that confirmation means. After that,
at the request of the Legates, the Acts against Nestorius were given
them, they thus report about them at the third procedure:
“We have found all things judged canonically, and according to
the Church’s discipline.” Therefore judgments of the
Apostolic See are canonically and, according to the Church’s
discipline, reconsidered, after deliberation, in a General Council, and
judgment passed upon them. After the Legates had approved the
Acts against Nestorius communicated to them, they request that all
which had been read and done at Ephesus from the beginning, should be
read afresh in public Session, “in order,” they say,
“that obeying the form of the most holy Pope Celestine, who hath
committed this care to us, we may be enabled to confirm the judgment
also of your Holiness.” After these all had been read
afresh, and the Legates agreed to them, Cyril proposes to the holy
Council, “That the Legates, by their signature, as was customary,
should make plain and manifest their canonical agreement with the
Council.” To this question of Cyril the Council thus
answers, and decrees that the Legates, by their subscription, confirm
the Acts; by which place this confirmation, spoken of by the Council,
is clearly nothing else but to make their assent plain and manifest, as
Cyril proposed.
Finally, Celestine himself, after the conclusion of the
whole matter, sends a letter to the holy Council of Ephesus, which he
thus begins: “At length we must rejoice at the conclusion
of evils.” The learned reader understands where he
recognizes the conclusion; that is, after the condemnation of Nestorius
by the infallible authority of an Ecumenical Council, viz., of the
whole Catholic Church. He proceeds: “We see, that
you, with us, have executed this matter so faithfully
transacted.” All decree, and all execute, that is, by
giving a common judgment. Whence Celestine adds, “We have
been informed of a just deposition, and a still juster
exaltation:” the deposition of Nestorius, begun, indeed, by
the Roman See, but brought to a conclusion by the sentence of the
Council; to a full and complete settlement, as we have seen
above: the exaltation of Maximianus, who was substituted in place
of Nestorius immediately after the Ephesine decrees; this is the
conclusion of the question. Even Celestine himself recognises
this conclusion to lie not in his own examination and judgment, but in
that of an Ecumenical Council. And this was done in that Council
in which it is admitted that the authority of the Apostolic See was
most clearly set forth, not only by words, but by deeds, of any since
the birth of Christ. At least the Holy Council gives credence to
Philip uttering these true and magnificent encomiums, concerning the
dignity of the Apostolic See, and “Peter the head and pillar of
the Faith, and foundation of the Catholic Church, and by Christ’s
authority administering the keys, who to this very time lives ever, and
exercises judgment, in his successors.” This, he says,
after having seen all the Acts of the Council itself, which we have
mentioned, so that we may indeed understand, that all these privileges
of Peter and the Apostolic See entirely agree with the decrees of the
Council, and the judgment entered into afresh, and deliberation upon
matters of Faith held after the Apostolic See.