Mr. P—was here this week, and requested my opinion, with respect to the proper
treatment of a number of persons, who have absented themselves from your meeting, and
have since attended public worship in W ——. I declined giving any opinion, except a very
general one, to him; but, on reflection, have concluded to express my thoughts to you, as a
friend, leaving you to attach to them such weight as you may see cause.
“As to differences, among professing Christians, of opinion and practice, about things
that appertain to religion, and the worship of God, I am ready to think that you and I are
agreed, as to the general principles of liberty of conscience; and that men’s using methods
with their neighbours, to oblige them to a conformity to their sentiments or way, is in
nothing so unreasonable, as in the worship of God; because that is a business, in which each
person acts for himself, with his Creator and Supreme Judge, as one concerned for his own
acceptance with him; and on which depends his own, and not his neighbour’s, eternal hap-
piness, and salvation from everlasting ruin. And it is an affair, wherein every man is infinitely
more concerned with his Creator than he is with his neighbour. And so I suppose that it
will be allowed, that every man ought to be left to his own conscience, in what he judges
will be most acceptable to God, or what he supposes is the will of God, as to the kind, or
manner, or means of worship, or the society of worshippers he should join with in worship.
Not but that a great abuse may be made of this doctrine of liberty of conscience in the
worship of God. I know that many are ready to justify every thing in their own conduct,
from this doctrine, and I do not suppose that men’s pretence of conscience is always to be
regarded, when made use of to justify their charging the society of worshippers they unite
with, or the means of their worship, or indeed the kind or manner of their worship. Men
may make this pretence at times under such circumstances, that they may, obviously, be
worthy of no credit in what they pretend. It may be manifest from the nature and circum-
stances of the case, and their own manner of behaviour, that it is not conscience, but petu-
lancy, and malice, and wilfulness, and obstinacy, that influence them. And, therefore, it
seems to me evident, that, when such pleas are made, those that are especially concerned
with them as persons that are peculiarly obliged to take care of their souls, have no other
way to do, but to consider the nature and circumstances of the case, and from thence to
judge whether the case be such as will admit of such a plea, or whether the nature of things
will admit of such a supposition, that the men act conscientiously in what they do, consid-
ering all things that appertain to the case. And in this, I conceive, many things are to be
considered and laid together, as—the nature of that thing is the subject of controversy, or
wherein they differ from others, or have changed their own practice—the degree in which
it is disputable, or how it may be supposed liable to diversity of opinion, one way or the
other, as to its agreeableness to the word of God, and as to the importance of it, with regard
to men’s salvation or the good of their souls—the degree of knowledge or ignorance of the
149
Chapter XIII. First Interview with David Brainerd--Separations From Churches--Letter…