Excursus on the Subsequent History of the Easter Question.
(Hefele: Hist. of the Councils, Vol. I., pp. 328 et seqq.)
The differences in the way of fixing the period of Easter did not indeed disappear after
the Council of Nicea. Alexandria and Rome could not agree, either because one of the two
Churches neglected to make the calculation for Easter, or because the other considered it
inaccurate. It is a fact, proved by the ancient Easter table of the Roman Church, that the
cycle of eighty-four years continued to be used at Rome as before. Now this cycle differed
in many ways from the Alexandrian, and did not always agree with it about the period for
Easter—in fact (a), the Romans used quite another method from the Alexandrians; they
calculated from the epact, and began from the feria prima of January. (b.) The Romans
were mistaken in placing the full moon a little too soon; whilst the Alexandrians placed it
a little too late. (c.) At Rome the equinox was supposed to fall on March 18th; whilst the
Alexandrians placed it on March 21st. (d.) Finally, the Romans differed in this from the
Greeks also; they did not celebrate Easter the next day when the full moon fell on the Sat-
urday.
Even the year following the Council of Nicea—that is, in 326—as well as in the years
330, 333, 340, 341, 343, the Latins celebrated Easter on a different day from the Alexandrians.
In order to put an end to this misunderstanding, the Synod of Sardica in 343, as we learn
from the newly discovered festival letters of S. Athanasius, took up again the question of
Easter, and brought the two parties (Alexandrians and Romans) to regulate, by means of
mutual concessions, a common day for Easter for the next fifty years. This compromise,
after a few years, was not observed. The troubles excited by the Arian heresy, and the division
which it caused between the East and the West, prevented the decree of Sardica from being
put into execution; therefore the Emperor Theodosius the Great, after the re-establishment
of peace in the Church, found himself obliged to take fresh steps for obtaining a complete
uniformity in the manner of celebrating Easter. In 387, the Romans having kept Easter on
March 21st, the Alexandrians did not do so for five weeks later—that is to say, till April
25th—because with the Alexandrians the equinox was not till March 21st. The Emperor
Theodosius the Great then asked Theophilus, Bishop of Alexandria for an explanation of
the difference. The bishop responded to the Emperor’s desire, and drew up a chronological
table of the Easter festivals, based upon the principles acknowledged by the Church of Alex-
andria. Unfortunately, we now possess only the prologue of his work.
56
Upon an invitation from Rome, S. Ambrose also mentioned the period of this same
Easter in 387, in his letter to the bishops of Æmilia, and he sides with the Alexandrian
computation. Cyril of Alexandria abridged the paschal table of his uncle Theophilus, and
fixed the time for the ninety-five following Easters—that is, from 436 to 531 after Christ.
Besides this Cyril showed, in a letter to the Pope, what was defective in the Latin calculation;
and this demonstration was taken up again, some time after, by order of the Emperor, by
Excursus on the Subsequent History of the Easter Question.
129
Excursus on the Subsequent History of the Easter Question.