Letter LXXIII.
(a.d. 404.)
To Jerome, My Venerable and Most Esteemed Brother and Fellow-Presbyter Augustin
Sends Greeting in the Lord.
Chap. I.
1. Although I suppose that, before this reaches you, you have received through our son
the deacon Cyprian, a servant of God, the letter which I sent by him, from which you would
be apprised with certainty that I wrote the letter of which you mentioned that a copy had
been brought to you; in consequence of which I suppose that I have begun already, like the
rash Dares, to be beaten and belaboured by the missiles and the merciless fists of a second
Entellus1890 in the reply which you have written; nevertheless I answer in the meantime the
letter which you have deigned to send me by our holy son Asterius, in which I have found
many proofs of your most kind goodwill to me, and at the same time some signs of your
having in some measure felt agrieved by me. In reading it, therefore, I was no sooner soothed
by one sentence than I was buffeted in another; my wonder being especially called forth by
this, that after alleging, as your reason for not rashly accepting as authentic the letter from
me of which you had a copy, the fact that, offended by your reply, I might justly remonstrate
with you, because you ought first to have ascertained that it was mine before answering it,
you go on to command me to acknowledge the letter frankly if it is mine, or send a more
reliable copy of it, in order that we may, without any bitterness of feeling, address ourselves
to the discussion of scriptural doctrine. For how can we engage in such discussion without
bitterness of feeling, if you have made up your mind to offend me? or, if your mind is not
made up to this, what reason could I have had, when you did not offend me, for justly
complaining as having been offended by you, that you ought first to have made sure that
the letter was mine, and only then to have replied, that is to say, only then to have offended
me? For if there had been nothing to offend me in your reply, I could have had no just
330
ground of complaint. Accordingly, when you write such a reply to that letter as must offend
me, what hope is left of our engaging without any bitterness in the discussion of scriptural
doctrine? Far be it from me to take offence if you are willing and able to prove, by incontro-
vertible argument, that you have apprehended more correctly than I have the meaning of
that passage in Paul’s Epistle [to the Galatians], or of any other text in Holy Scripture: nay,
more, far be it from me to count it aught else than gain to myself, and cause of thankfulness
to you, if in anything I am either informed by your teaching or set right by your correction.
2. But, my very dear brother, you could not think that I could be offended by your reply,
had you not thought that you were offended by what I had written. For I could never have
entertained concerning you the idea that you had not felt yourself offended by me if you so
1890 See Jerome’s Letter, LXVIII., sec. 2, p. 325.
To Jerome
743
To Jerome