Chapter LXI.
He maintains, moreover, that “no product of
matter is immortal.” Now, in answer to this it may be said,
that if no product of matter is immortal, then either the whole world
is immortal, and thus not a product of matter, or it is not
immortal. If, accordingly, the world is immortal (which is
agreeable to the view of those who say that the soul alone is the work
of God, and was produced from a certain bowl), let Celsus show that the
world was not produced from a matter devoid of qualities, remembering
his own assertion that “no product of matter is
immortal.” If, however, the world is not immortal (seeing
it is a product of matter), but mortal, does it also perish, or does it
not? For if it perish, it will perish as being a work of God; and
then, in the event of the
world
perishing, what will become of
the
soul
, which is also a work of God? Let Celsus answer
this! But if, perverting the notion of immortality, he will
assert that, although
perishable
, it is immortal, because it
does not
really
perish; that it is
capable
of dying, but
does not
actually
die,—it is evident that, according to
him, there will exist something which is at the same time mortal and
immortal, by being capable of both conditions; and that which does not
die will be mortal, and that which is not immortal by nature will be
termed in a peculiar sense immortal, because it does not die!
According to what distinction, then, in the meaning of words, will he
maintain that no product of matter is immortal? And thus you see
that the ideas contained in his writings, when closely examined and
tested, are proved
not
to be sound and
incontrovertible.
3950
And after
making these assertions he adds: “On this point these
remarks are sufficient; and if any one is capable of hearing and
examining further, he will come to know (the truth).” Let
us, then, who in his opinion are unintelligent individuals, see what
will result from our being able to listen to him for a little, and so
continue our investigation.
3950
διελέγχεται
οὐκ
ἐπιδεχόμενα
τὸ γενναῖον
καὶ
ἀναντίῤῥητον
.