Montanism must not be looked upon as a heresy in the ordinary
sense of the term. The movement lay in the sphere of life and
discipline rather than in that of theology. Its fundamental proposition
was the continuance of divine revelation which was begun under the old
Dispensation, was carried on in the time of Christ and his apostles,
and reached its highest development under the dispensation of the
Paraclete, which opened with the activity of Montanus. This Montanus
was a Phrygian, who, in the latter part of the second century, began to
fall into states of ecstasy and to have visions, and believed himself a
divinely inspired prophet, through whom the promised Paraclete spoke,
and with whom therefore the dispensation of that Paraclete began. Two
noble ladies (Priscilla and Maximilla) attached themselves to Montanus,
and had visions and prophesied in the same way. These constituted the
three original prophets of the sect, and all that they taught was
claimed to be of binding authority on all. They were quite orthodox,
accepted fully the doctrinal teachings of the Catholic Church, and did
not pretend to alter in any way the revelation given by Christ and his
apostles. But they claimed that some things had not been revealed by
them, because at that early stage the Church was not able to bear them;
but that such additional revelations were now given, because the
fullness of time had come which was to precede the second coming of
Christ. These revelations had to do not at all with theology, but
wholly with matters of life and discipline. They taught a rigid
asceticism over against the growing worldliness of the Church, severe
discipline over against its laxer methods, and finally the universal
priesthood of believers (even female), and their right to perform all
the functions of church officers, over against the growing
sacerdotalism of the Church. They were thus in a sense reformers, or
perhaps reactionaries is a better term, who wished to bring back, or to
preserve against corruption, the original principles and methods of the
Church. They aimed at a puritanic reaction against worldliness, and of
a democratic reaction against growing aristocracy in the Church. They
insisted that ministers were made by God alone, by the direct endowment
of his Spirit in distinction from human ordination. They looked upon
their prophets—supernaturally called and endowed by the
Spirit—as supreme in the Church. They claimed that all gross
offenders should be excommunicated, and that neither they nor the lax
should ever be re-admitted to the Church. They encouraged celibacy,
increased the number and severity of fasts, eschewed worldly
amusements, &c. This rigid asceticism was enjoined by the
revelation of the Spirit through their prophets, and was promoted by
their belief in the speedy coming of Christ to set up his kingdom on
earth, which was likewise prophesied. They were thus pre-Millenarians
or Chiliasts.
The movement spread rapidly in
Asia Minor and in North Africa, and for a time in Rome itself. It
appealed very powerfully to the sterner moralists, stricter
disciplinarians, and more deeply pious minds among the Christians. All
the puritanically inclined schisms of this period attracted many of the
better class of Christians, and this one had the additional advantage
of claiming the authority of divine revelation for its strict
principles. The greatest convert was Tertullian, who, in 201 or 202,
attracted by the asceticism and disciplinary rigor of the sect,
attached himself to it, and remained until his death its most powerful
advocate. He seems to have stood at the head of a separatist
congregation of Montanists in Carthage, and yet never to have been
excommunicated by the Catholic Church. Montanism made so much stir in
Asia Minor that synods were called before the end of the second century
to consider the matter, and finally, though not without hesitation, the
whole movement was officially condemned. Later, the condemnation was
ratified in Rome and also in North Africa, and Montanism gradually
degenerated, and finally, after two or three centuries, entirely
disappeared.
But although it failed and
passed away, Montanism had a marked influence on the development of the
Church. In the first place, it aroused a general distrust of prophecy,
and the result was that the Church soon came to the conviction that
prophecy had entirely ceased. In the second place, the Church was led
to see the necessity of emphasizing the historical Christ and
historical Christianity over against the Montanistic claims of a
constantly developing revelation, and thus to put great emphasis upon
the Scripture canon. In the third place, the Church had to lay
increased stress upon the organization—upon its appointed and
ordained officers—over against the claims of irregular prophets
who might at any time arise as organs of the Spirit. The development of
Christianity into a religion of the book and of the organization was
thus greatly advanced, and the line began to be sharply drawn between
the age of the apostles, in which there had been direct supernatural
revelations, and the later age, in which such revelations had
disappeared. We are, undoubtedly, to date from this time that exalted
conception of the glory of the apostolic age, and of its absolute
separation from all subsequent ages, which marks so strongly the Church
of succeeding centuries, and which led men to endeavor to gain
apostolic authority for every advance in the constitution, in the
customs, and in the doctrine of the Church. There had been little of
this feeling before, but now it became universal, and it explains the
great number of pseudo-apostolic works of the third and following
centuries. In the fourth place, the Chiliastic ideas of Montanism
produced a reaction in the Church which caused the final rejection of
all grossly physical Premillenarian beliefs which up to this time had
been very common. For further particulars in regard to Montanism, see
the notes on this and the following chapters.
Our chief sources for a
knowledge of Montanism are to be found in the writings of Tertullian.
See, also, Epiphanius, Hær. XLVIII. and XLIX., and
Jerome’s Epistle to Marcella (Migne, Ep. 41). The
fragments from the anonymous anti-Montanistic writer quoted by Eusebius
in this and the following chapter, and the fragments of
Apollonius’ work, quoted in chap. 18, are of the greatest
importance. It is to be regretted that Eusebius has preserved for us no
fragments of the anti-Montanistic writings of Apolinarius and Melito,
who might have given us still earlier and more trustworthy accounts of
the sect. It is probable that their works were not decided enough in
their opposition to Montanism to suit Eusebius, who, therefore, chose
to take his account from somewhat later, but certainly bitter enough
antagonists. The works of the Montanists themselves (except those of
Tertullian) have entirely perished, but a few “Oracles,” or
prophetic utterances, of Montanus, Priscilla, and Maximilla, have been
preserved by Tertullian and other writers, and are printed by
Bonwetsch, p. 197–200. The literature upon Montanism is very
extensive. We may mention here C. W. F. Walch’s
Ketzerhistorie, I. p. 611–666, A. Schwegler’s Der
Montanismus und die christliche Kirche des zweiten Jahrh.
(Tübingen, 1841), and especially G. N. Bonwetzsch’s Die
Geschichte des Montanismus (Erlangen, 1881), which is the best work
on the subject, and indispensable to the student. Compare, also,
Schaff’s Ch. Hist. II. p. 415 sq., where the literature is
given with great fullness, Salmon’s article in the Dict. of
Christ. Biog., and especially Harnack’s
Dogmengeschichte, I. p. 319 sq.