Chapter XXXVII.
When, after an interval of some time had elapsed, Athanasius, finding that Marcellus
was by no means sound in the faith, suspended him from communion. And he had this
degree of modesty, that, being censured by the judgment of so great a man, he voluntarily
gave way. But though at a former period innocent, yet confessedly afterwards becoming
heretical, it may be allowed to conclude that he was really then guilty when judgment was
pronounced regarding him. The Arians, then, finding an opportunity of that kind, conspire
to subvert altogether the decrees of the Synod of Sardes. For a certain coloring of right
seemed to be furnished them in this fact, that a favorable judgment had as unjustly been
formed on the side of Athanasius, as Marcellus had been improperly acquitted, since now,
even in the opinion of Athanasius himself, he was deemed a heretic. For Marcellus had stood
forward as an upholder of the Sabellian heresy.327 But Photinus had already brought forward
a new heresy, differing indeed from Sabellius with respect to the union of the divine persons,
but proclaiming that Christ had his beginning in Mary. The Arians, therefore, with cunning
design, mix up what was harmless with what was blameworthy, and embrace, under the
same judgment, the condemnation of Photinus, and Marcellus, and Athanasius. They un-
doubtedly did this with the view of leading the minds of the ignorant to conclude, that those
had not judged incorrectly regarding Athanasius, who, it was admitted, had expressed a
well-based opinion respecting Marcellus and Photinus. At that time, however, the Arians
concealed their treachery; and not daring openly to proclaim their erroneous doctrines,
they professed themselves Catholics. They thought that their first great object should be to
get Athanasius turned out of the church, who had always presented a wall of opposition to
their endeavors, and they hoped that, if he were removed, the rest would pass over to their
evil328 opinion. Now, that part of the bishops which followed the Arians accepted the con-
demnation of Athanasius with delight. Another part, constrained by fear and faction, yielded
115
to the wish of the Arian party; and only a few, to whom the true faith was dearer than any
other consideration, refused to accept their unjust judgment. Among these was Paulinus,
the bishop of Treves. It is related that he, when a letter on the subject was placed before him,
thus wrote, that he gave his consent to the condemnation of Photinus and Marcellus, but
did not approve that of Athanasius.
327 As Epiphanius remarks, Sabellius taught that the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost were all the same person,
only under different appellations.
328 “libidinem.”
Chapter XXXVII.
278
Chapter XXXVII.