basis of mere justice, and had gone no further than this required, he might have demanded
of Adam and all his posterity, that they should perform perfect perpetual obedience, without
ever failing in the least instance, on pain of eternal death; and might have made this demand
without the promise of any positive reward for their obedience. For perfect obedience is a
debt, that every one owes to his Creator; and therefore is what his Creator was not obliged
to pay him for. None is obliged to pay his debtor for discharging his just debt.—But such
was evidently the constitution with Adam, that an eternal happy life was to be the con-
sequence of his persevering fidelity, to all such as were included within that constitution,
(of which the tree of life was a sign,) as well as eternal death to be the consequence of his
disobedience.—I come now to consider the
Second difficulty.—It being thus manifest, that this constitution, by which Adam and
his posterity are dealt with as one, is not unreasonable on account of its being injurious and
hurtful to the interest of mankind, the only thing remaining in the objection, against such
a constitution, is the impropriety of it, as implying falsehood, and contradiction to the true
nature of things; as hereby they are viewed and treated as one, who are not one, but wholly
distinct; and no arbitrary constitution can ever make that to be true, which in itself considered
is not true.
This objection, however specious, is really founded on a false hypothesis, and wrong
notion of what we call sameness or oneness, among created things; and the seeming force
of the objection arises from ignorance or inconsideration of the degree, in which created
identity or oneness with past existence, in general, depends on the sovereign constitution
and law of the supreme Author and Disposer of the universe.
Some things are entirely distinct, and very diverse, which yet are so united by the estab-
lished law of the Creator, that by virtue of that establishment, they are in a sense one. Thus
a tree, grown great, and a hundred years old, is one plant with the little sprout, that first
came out of the ground from whence it grew, and has been continued in constant succession;
though it is now so exceeding diverse, many thousand times bigger, and of a very different
form, and perhaps not one atom the very same: yet God, according to an established law of
nature, has in a constant succession communicated to it many of the same qualities, and
most important properties, as if it were one. It has been his pleasure, to constitute an union
in these respects, and for these purposes, naturally leading us to look upon all as one.—So
the body of man at forty years of age, is one with the infant body which first came into the
world, from whence it grew; though now constituted of different substance, and the greater
part of the substance probably changed scores (if not hundreds) of times: and though it be
now in so many respects exceeding diverse, yet God, according to the course of nature,
which he has been pleased to establish, has caused, that in a certain method it should com-
municate with that infantile body, in the same life, the same senses, the same features, and
many the same qualities, and in union with the same soul; and so, with regard to these
1154
CHAPTER III. The Imputation of Adam's Sin stated.