Whether the whole of the previous account, or only the close of
it, was taken by Eusebius from Aristo of Pella, we do not know. Of
Aristo of Pella himself we know very little. Eusebius is the first
writer to mention him, and he and Maximus Confessor (in his notes on
the work De mystica Theol. cap. I. p. 17, ed. Corderii) are the
only ones to give us any information about him (for the notices in
Moses Chorenensis and in the Chron. Paschale—the only
other places in which Aristo is mentioned—are entirely
unreliable). Maximus informs us that Aristo was the author of a
Dialogue of Papiscus and Jason, a work mentioned by many of the
Fathers, but connected by none of them with Aristo. The dialogue,
according to Maximus, was known to Clement of Alexandria and therefore
must have been written as early as, or very soon after, the middle of
the second century; and the fact that it recorded a dialogue between a
Hebrew Christian and an Alexandrian Jew (as we learn from the epistle
of Celsus, De Judaica Incredulitate, printed with the works of
Cyprian, in Hartel’s edition, III. p. 119–132) would lead
us to expect an early date for the work. There can be found no good
reason for doubting the accuracy of Maximus’ statement; and if it
be accepted, we must conclude that the writer whom Eusebius mentions
here was the author of the dialogue referred to. If this be so, it is
quite possible that it was from this dialogue that Eusebius drew the
account which he here ascribes to Aristo; for such an account might
well find a place in a dialogue between two Hebrews. It is possible, of
course, that Aristo wrote some other work in which he discussed this
subject; but if it had been an historical work, we should expect
Eusebius, according to his custom, to give its title. Harnack is quite
correct in assuming that Eusebius’ silence in regard to the work
itself is significant. Doubtless the work did not please him, and hence
he neither mentions it, nor gives an account of its author. This is
just what we should expect Eusebius’ attitude to be toward such a
Jewish Christian work (and at the same time, such a
‘simple’ work, as Origen calls it in Contra Cels.
IV. 52) as we know the dialogue to have been. We are, of course, left
largely to conjecture in this matter; but the above conclusions seem at
least probable. Compare Harnack’s Ueberlieferung der griech.
Apol., p. 115 sq.; and for a discussion of the nature of the
dialogue (which is no longer extant), see his Altercatio Simonis
Judæi et Theophili Christiani (Texte und
Untersuchungen, I. 3), p. 115 sq. (Harnack looks upon this Latin
altercatio as, in part at least, a free reproduction of the lost
dialogue). See, also, the writer’s Dialogue between a
Christian and a Jew (᾽Αντιβολὴ
Παπίσκου καὶ
φίλωνος
᾽Ιουδαίων
πρὸς μοναχόν
τινα), p. 33.
The town of Pella lay
east of the Jordan, in Perea. See Bk. III. chap. 5, note 10,
above.