260 THE SEVEN BOOKS OF [Book v.
but if you can neither present another supposition in each
case, nor appeal to’ the context as a whole, why do you make
that obscure,’ by means of fair-seeming allegories, which has
been spoken plainly, and disclosed to the understanding of all?
36. But you will perhaps say that these allegories are not
[found] in the whole body of the story, but that some parts
are written so as to be understood by all, while others have
a double meaning, and are veiled in ambiguity. That is
refined subtlety, and can be seen through by the dullest.
For because it is very difficult for you to transpose, reverse,
and divert [to other meanings] all that has been said, you
choose out some things which suit your purpose, and by
means of these you strive to maintain that false and spuri-
ous versions were thrown about the truth which is under
them? But yet, supposing that we should grant to you that
it is just as you say, how do you know, or whence do you
learn, which part of the story is written without any double
meaning, which, on the other hand, has been covered with
jarring and alien senses? For it may be that what you
believe to be so? is otherwise, that what you believe to be
otherwise? has been produced with different, and [even]
opposite modes of expression. For where, in a consistent
whole, one part is said to be written allegorically, the other
in plain and trustworthy language, while there is no sign
in the thing itself to point out the difference between what
is said ambiguously and what is said simply, that which is
simple may as well be thought to have a double meaning,
as what has been written ambiguously be believed to be
wrapt in obscurity.’ But, indeed, we confess that we do
not understand at all by whom this? is either done, or can
be believed to be possible.
1 The Ms. omits ad, supplied by Ursinus.
2 So all edd., except Hild. and Oehler, reading obscur-atis for the Ms.
-itatibus.
? Lit., ** were placed above the interior truth.”
* Lit., ** with simple senses." 5 i.e. involved in obscurity.
6 i.e, free from ambiguity. * Lit., ** of shut off obscurities.”
3 The reference is to the words in the middle of the chapter, ** how do