for correction is precisely as usual. The doctrines of universality and unity and charity are
incidentally brought forward. Circumcelliones, Secundus and Maximianists furnish the
concluding parallels.
Book II. Gaudentius had written a reply to Augustin’s first book. He had taken refuge
under the example of Cyprian; but Augustin now refers him to the writings of Cyprian on
De Simplicitate Prælatorum seu De Catholicæ Ecclesiæ unitate, showing Cyprian’s belief in
the universality of the Church which Augustin expands by the explanation of the term
Catholic. Purgation of the Church is not by separation, but by toleration, as Cyprian too
held in his letter to Maximus and others. The explanation of the field not as the Church,
but rather as the world outside of the Church, had been supported at the Conference and
is repeated by Gaudentius; and also its alternative, that were the field the Church then it
must have perished from the tares which were in it. If so, says Augustin, then the ancestors
of the Donatists would have perished. The period of separation is at the end, when the
Gospel shall have been preached in the whole world. As to their theme of rebaptism, Au-
gustin replies that he had already before referred him to his Maximianist practice, so that
the action of Agrippinus and Cyprian are vain for him. And then too, according to Cyprian’s
own confession, and Stephen’s testimony, there were crimes in the Church in their day; did
the Church perish then? If so where was Donatus born? If not, then why did the party of
Donatus separate? They are guilty of the very schism which Cyprian particularly deprecated
as a cure, instead of toleration and discipline, for the ills of the Church. As to baptism: The
Catholics recognize the Donatist rite, for the sacrament cannot be lost upon those who receive
it among Catholics and then pass over to heretics; they have the truth but in iniquity; the
truth is not the property of the Donatists. The apostle recognized such truth as he found
among the Gentiles. Gaudentius had vindicated his reference to the tribune’s letter, as to
the Donatists having the names of God and of his Christ, and quoted the passage in proof.
Augustin acknowledges his mistake, which, however, was not intentional, and he apologizes
for the tribune’s error as that of a military man who was not familiar with theology. Since
Gaudentius had called the tribune religious in his first letter, Augustin accuses him of insin-
cerity and berates him as superstitious. He also corrects Gaudentius for saying that God
sent Jonah not to the king but only to the people of Nineveh, for the king compelled the
humiliation of his subjects. In conclusion he quotes from Cyprian’s letter to Maximus in
behalf of universality and tolerant unity. His exordium is an earnest appeal to the Catholics
to maintain all the notes of the Church. [Cp. Retractt. II. lix.].
403
Felicia had been a Donatist originally and was converted by force. She had devoted
herself to the virgin life and apparently had become head of a religious house; but by reason
of some wicked deeds of the clergy, possibly the extortion and rapacity of Antonius at Fussala,
she was much disturbed and seemed inclined to relapse into her earlier puristic notions, if
not to return to the body that upheld them. To quiet her doubts Augustin writes Ep. ccviii.
686
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.