The
date of the martyrdom of James, given here by Josephus, is 61 or 62
a.d. (at the time of the Passover, according
to Hegesippus, §10, above). There is no reason for doubting this
date which is given with such exactness by Josephus, and it is further
confirmed by Eusebius in his Chron., who puts James’s
martyrdom in the seventh year of Nero, i.e. 61 a.d., while Jerome puts it in the eighth year of Nero. The
Clementines and the Chronicon Paschale, which state that James
survived Peter, and are therefore cited in support of a later date, are
too late to be of any weight over against such an exact statement as
that of Josephus, especially since Peter and James died at such a
distance from one another. Hegesippus has been cited over and over
again by historians as assigning the date of the martyrdom to 69 a.d., and as thus being in direct conflict with
Josephus; as a consequence some follow his supposed date, others that
of Josephus. But I can find no reason for asserting that Hegesippus
assigns the martyrdom to 69. Certainly his words in this chapter, which
are referred to, by no means necessitate such an assumption. He
concludes his account with the words καὶ εὐθὺς
Οὐεσπασιανὸς
πολιορκεῖ
αὐτούς.
The πολιορκεῖ
αὐτούς is
certainly to be referred to the commencement of the war (not to the
siege of the city of Jerusalem, which was undertaken by Titus, not by
Vespasian), i.e. to the year 67 a.d., and in
such an account as this, in which the overthrow of the Jews is
designedly presented in connection with the death of James, it is
hyper-criticism to insist that the word εὐθύς must
indicate a space of time of only a few months’ duration. It is a
very indefinite word, and the most we can draw from Hegesippus’
account is that not long before Vespasian’s invasion of Judea,
James was slain. The same may be said in regard to Eusebius’
report in Bk. III. chap. 11, §1, which certainly is not definite
enough to be cited as a contradiction of his express statement in his
Chronicle. But however it may be with this report and that of
Hegesippus, the date given by Josephus is undoubtedly to be accepted as
correct.