Part
II.—The Apocryphal Acts of the Apostles.
This portion of the volume, extending from page 477 to
page 564, presents us with documents written in a style considerably
different from that of the Apocryphal Gospels properly so called.
There we have without stint the signs that the Jews desired; here we
begin to have some glimpses of the wisdom which the Greeks sought
after, along with a considerable share of
Quidquid Græcia mendax
Audet in historia.
We have less of miracle, more of elaborate discourse. The
Apocryphal Gospels were suited to the
vilis plebecula
,
from which, as Jerome said, the Church originated; the Apocryphal Acts
appeal more to the
Academia.
We have in ancient literature, especially Greek
literature, a long series of fabulous histories attached to the names
of men who made themselves famous either in arts or arms. This
taste for the marvellous became general after the expedition of
Alexander; and from that time down we have numerous examples of it in
the lives of Alexander, of Pythagoras, of Apollonius of Tyana, of
Homer, of Virgil, and others without number; and we all know how much
fabulous matter is apt to gather round the names of popular heroes even
in modern times.
It is not to be
wondered at, then, that round the names of Christ and His apostles, who
had brought about social changes greater than those effected by the
exploits of any hero of old, there should gather, as the result of the
wondering awe of simple-minded men, a growth of the romantic and the
fabulous.
These stories came at length to form a sort of
apostolic cycle, of which the documents following are portions.
They exist also in a Latin form in the ten books of the Acts of the
Apostles, compiled probably in the sixth century, and falsely
attributed to Abdias, the first bishop of Babylon, by whom it was, of
course, written in Hebrew.
1553
We shall now give a brief account of each of the
thirteen documents which make up this part of the volume.
I.
The Acts of Peter and
Paul
.—This book was first published in a complete form by
Thilo in 1837 and 1838. A portion of it had already been
translated into Latin by the famous Greek scholar Constantine Lascaris
in 1490, and had been made use of in the celebrated controversy as to
the situation of the island Melita, upon which St. Paul was
shipwrecked. For his edition Tischendorf collated six
mss.
, the oldest of the end of the ninth
century.
Some portions at least of the book are of an early
date. The
Domine quo vadis
story, p. 485, is referred to
by Origen, and others after him. A book called the Acts of Peter
is condemned in the decree of Pope Gelasius.
II.
Acts of Paul and
Thecla
.—This book is of undoubted antiquity. There
seems reason to accept the account of it given by Tertullian, that it
was written by an Asiatic presbyter in glorification of St. Paul (who,
however, unquestionably occupies only a secondary place in it), and in
support of the heretical opinion that women may teach and
baptize. It is expressly mentioned and quoted by a long line of
Latin and Greek Fathers. The quotations are inserted in
Tischendorf’s
Prolegomena
, p. xxiv.
The text was first edited in 1698 by Grabe from a
Bodleian
ms.
, republished by Jones in
1726. A blank in the Bodleian
ms.
was
supplied in 1715 by Thomas Hearne from another Oxford
ms.
Tischendorf’s text is from a recension of
three Paris
mss.
, each of the eleventh
century.
III.
Acts of Barnabas
.—This
book has more an air of truth about it than any of the others.
There is not much extravagance in the details, and the geography is
correct, showing that the writer knew Cyprus well. It seems to
have been written at all events before 478, in which year the body of
Barnabas is said to have been found in Cyprus.
Papebroche first edited the book in the
Acta
Sanctorum
in 1698, with a Latin translation. The
Vatican
ms.
which he used was an imperfect
one. Tischendorf’s text is from a Parisian
ms.
of the end of the ninth century.
IV.
Acts of Philip
.—A book
under this name was condemned in the decree of Pope Gelasius; and that
the traditions about Philip were well known from an early date, is
evident from the abundant references to them in ancient
documents. The writings of the Hagiographers also, both Greek and
Latin, contain epitomes of Philip’s life.
The Greek text, now first published, is a
recension of two
mss.
,—a Parisian one of
the eleventh century, and a Venetian one. The latter is
noticeable, from being superscribed
From the Fifteenth Act to the
end
, leaving us to infer that we have only a portion of the
book.
V.
Acts of Philip in
Hellas
.—This also is published for the first time by
Tischendorf. It is obviously a later document than the preceding,
though composed in the same style. It is from a Parisian
ms.
of the eleventh century.
VI.
Acts of Andrew
.—In the decree of Pope Gelasius (
d
.
496), a book under this name is condemned as apocryphal.
Epiphanius (
d
. 403) states that the Acts of Andrew were in
favour with the Encratites, the Apostolics, and the Origenians;
Augustine (
d
. 430) mentions that the Acts of the Apostles
written by Leucius Charinus—
discipulus
diaboli
, as Pope Gelasius calls him—were held in
estimation by the Manichæans. The authorship generally is
attributed to Leucius by early writers; Innocentius I. (
d
. 417),
however, says that the Acts of Andrew were composed by the philosophers
Nexocharis and Leonidas. This book is much the same in substance
with the celebrated
Presbyterorum et Diaconorum Achaiæ
de martyrio S. Andreæ apostoli epistola encyclica
, first
edited in Greek by Woog in 1749, and by him considered to be a genuine
writing of the apostolic age, composed about
a.d.
80. Thilo, while dissenting from this opinion of
Woog’s, concludes that it is a fragment from the Acts of Leucius,
expurgated of most of its heresy, and put into its present shape by an
orthodox writer. Cardinals Baronius and Bellarmine assign the
epistle to the apostolic age; Fabricius thinks it much
later.
The probability is that the book was written by Leucius,
following earlier traditions, and that it was afterwards revised and
fitted for general reading by an orthodox hand.
Though some of the traditions mentioned in the book are
referred to by authors of the beginning of the fifth century, there
does not seem to be any undoubted quotation of it before the eighth and
the tenth centuries. Some portions of Pseudo-Abdias, however, are
almost in the words of our Greek Acts.
The text is edited chiefly from two
mss.
,—the one of the eleventh, the other of the
fourteenth century.
The Greek of the original is good of the kind, and
exhibits considerable rhetorical skill.
VII.
Acts of Andrew and
Matthias
.—Thilo assigns the authorship of these Acts also to
Leucius, and the use of them to the Gnostics, Manichæans, and
other heretics. Pseudo-Abdias seems to have derived his account
of Andrew and Matthias from the same source. Epiphanius the monk,
who wrote in the tenth century, gives extracts from the history.
There is, besides, an old English—commonly called
Anglo-Saxon—poem, Andrew and Helene, published by Jacob Grimm in
1840, the argument of which in great part coincides with that of the
Acts of Andrew and Matthias.
There is considerable doubt as to whether it is
Matthias or Matthew that is spoken of. Pseudo-Abdias, followed by
all the Latin writers on the subject, calls him Matthew. The
Greek texts hesitate between the two. Tischendorf edits Matthias,
on the authority of his oldest
ms.
There
is also some discrepancy as to the name of the town. Some
mss.
say Sinope, others Myrmene or Myrna:
they generally, however, coincide in calling it a town of
Æthiopia.
Thilo, and Tischendorf after him, made use chiefly
of three
mss.
, only one of which, of the
fifteenth century, contains the whole book. The oldest is an
uncial
ms.
of about the eighth
century.
The Acts of Peter and Andrew, from the Bodleian
ms.
, are inserted as an appendix to the Acts of
Andrew and Matthias.
VIII.
Acts of Matthew
.—This
book is edited by Tischendorf for the first time. It is a much
later production than the last, written in bad Greek, and in a style
rendered very cumbrous by the use of participial phrases.
On the authority of the oldest
ms.
, Matthew, not Matthias, is the name here. It is
probably owing to this confusion between the names, that there is much
uncertainty in the traditions regarding St. Matthew.
Tischendorf gives, in his
Prolegomena
, a
long extract from Nicephorus, which shows that he was acquainted with
this book, or something very like it.
The text is edited from two
mss.
,—a Parisian of the eleventh century, and a
Viennese of a later date.
IX.
Acts of Thomas
.—The substance of this book is of great
antiquity, and in its original form it was held in great estimation by
the heretics of the first and second centuries. The main heresy
which it contained was that the Apostle Thomas baptized, not with
water, but with oil only. It is mentioned by Epiphanius,
Turribius, and Nicephorus, condemned in the decree of Gelasius, and in
the Synopsis of Scripture ascribed to Athanasius, in which it is
placed, along with the Acts of Peter, Acts of John, and other books,
among the
Antilegomena
. St. Augustine in three passages
refers to the book in such a way as to show that he had it in something
very like its present form. Two centuries later, Pseudo-Abdias
made a recension of the book, rejecting the more heretical portions,
and adapting it generally to orthodox use. Photius attributes the
authorship of this document, as of many other apocryphal Acts, to
Leucius Charinus.
The Greek text was first edited, with copious
notes and prolegomena, by Thilo in 1823. The text from which the
present translation is made is a recension of five
mss.
, the oldest of the tenth century.
X.
Consummation of Thomas
.—This
is properly a portion of the preceding book. Pseudo-Abdias
follows it very closely, but the Greek of some chapters of his
translation or compilation has not yet been discovered.
The text, edited by Tischendorf for the first
time, is from a
ms.
of the eleventh
century.
XI.
Martyrdom of
Bartholomew
.—This Greek text, now for the first time edited
by Tischendorf, is very similar to the account of Bartholomew in
Pseudo-Abdias. The editor is inclined to believe, not that the
Greek text is a translation of Abdias, which it probably is, but that
both it and Abdias are derived from the same source. Tischendorf
seems inclined to lay some weight upon the mention made by Abdias of a
certain Crato, said to be a disciple of the Apostles Simon and Judas,
having written a voluminous history of the apostles, which was
translated into Latin by Julius Africanus. The whole story,
however, is absurd. It is very improbable that Julius Africanus
knew any Latin; it is possible, however, that he may have compiled some
stories of the apostles, that these may have been translated into
Latin, and that Pseudo-Crato and Pseudo-Abdias may have derived some of
their materials from this source.
The Greek text is edited from a Venetian
ms.
of the thirteenth century.
XII.
Acts of
Thaddæus
.—This document, of which our text is the
editio princeps
, is of some consequence, as giving in
another form the famous letters of Christ to Abgarus. Eusebius
(
H. E
., i. 13) says that he found in the archives of Edessa the
letters written by their own hands, and that he translated them from
the Syriac. The story of the portrait was a later
invention. It is found in Pseudo-Abdias (x. 1), and with great
detail in Nicephorus (
H. E
., ii. 7). There is considerable
variety in the texts of the letters. They were probably written
in Syriac in the third century by some native of Edessa, who wished to
add to the importance of his city and the antiquity of his
church. See the whole subject discussed in Dr. Cureton’s
Ancient Syriac Documents relative to the earliest establishment of
Christianity in Edessa.
The Greek text, which is probably of the sixth or
seventh century, seems, from allusions to the synagogue, the hours of
prayer, the Sabbath-day, etc., to have been written by a Jew. It
is edited from a Paris
ms.
of the eleventh
century, and a Vienna one of a later date.
XIII.
Acts of John
.—A book
under this title is mentioned by Eusebius, Epiphanius, Photius, among
Greek writers; Augustine, Philastrius, Innocent I., and Turribius among
Latin writers. The two last named and Photius ascribe the
authorship to Leucius,
discipulus diaboli
, who got
the credit of all these heretical
brochures
. It is not
named in the decree of Gelasius.
Augustine (
Tractat
. 124
in Johannem
)
relates at length the story of John going down alive into his grave,
and of the fact of his being alive being shown by his breath stirring
about the dust on the tomb. This story, which has some
resemblance to the Teutonic legend of Barbarossa, is repeated by
Photius.
There is a
Latin document published by Fabricius,
Pseudo-Melitonis liber de
Passione S. Johannis Evangelistæ
, which the author professed
to write with the original of Leucius before his eyes. It has
considerable resemblances in some passages to the present text.
The only passages in Pseudo-Abdias that appear to have any connection
with the present document are those which refer to the apostle’s
burial.
The text is edited from a Paris
ms.
of the eleventh century, and a Vienna one, to which no
date is assigned.
It is doubtful whether the narrative part of the Acts of
John be by the same hand as the discourses.
1553
[That is, this is
the tradition. Of such Hebrew original there is no
trace.—R.]