virtuous, as well as a love of our neighbour. What he maintains, then, is, that the love of ourselves, of our
neighbour, our nation, or any private system whatever, if detached from a tendency of affection to universal
being, is not truly virtuous. And what is this, more or less, than what all judicious divines have maintained, that
he who does not really love god, does not truly love his neighbour? If Mr. E. uses language more philosophically
exact, and investigates the principle on which a commonly received truth is founded, he certainly deserves
commendation, rather than blame. 12. On Mr. E’s principles, the particular affections are so far from being
“useless,” that their operations are not at all affected by those principles, except in being more exalted and refined.
When the heart is enlarged to the love of being in general, it includes all particular objects: and then the attachment
to them is for the sake of the whole system of being. Thus a truly virtuous love of our neighbour, springs from
our love to God: or without a supreme regard to God, there is no genuine, or, in the highest sense, praiseworthy,
love to our neighbour. And so far are particular affections from being “pernicious,” on Mr. E’s principles, that
they are highly useful. Those objects which contain, or are apprehended to contain, only a secondary beauty,
attract a particular affection which is useful in various respects, as explained by our author; and those which
contain the primary beauty, attract affections still more useful. For governors, and subjects, and friends, and
relatives to feel attachment to their subjects, governors, friends, and relatives, must be useful, even when not
virtuous; but when these attachments are animated, regulated, and ennobled by the love of God, or benevolence
to universal being, they must be still more so. Benevolent affections are like a pleasant flame; a flame which is
not lessened by an addition of fuel. Zeal at home is not found in fact to be weakened by the extension of zealous
and benevolent affections abroad. National reform, and religious revival, will not be impeded by a truly benevolent
missionary spirit. Neither will the love of God, or of universal being, prove detrimental to “particular affections.”
13. Respecting the “particular affections,” Mr. H. remarks, that “their immediate, nay their necessary tendency
is, to attract to their object a proportion of attention, which far exceeds their comparative value in the general
scale.” But surely “attention” is a very different thing from “attachment.” A man who is about to buy a horse,
has his attention attracted very forcibly to the size, the shape, the age, and the action of the animal; but does this
imply attachment. The word Satan may attract our “attention” to the malevolent being signified by it; but does
this prove that the “immediate, nay the necessary tendency” of the word is to attract to this object any degree
of “attachment?” It would be difficult to find either man, woman, or child, but has much “attention attracted’
to what he does not esteem, and to which he feels no attachment. If a person feels an attachment to any object
not founded on the “comparative value” of that object, let the “particular affection” be denominated as we please,
but let us not attach to it the idea of true virtue. For why should we be tempted to call that truly virtuous which
has no relation to God, the object and fountain of all excellence? 14. It is but justice to our author to say, that
his definition of virtue, against which Mr. H. objects, by no means countenances that perversion of our powers
which is but too justly ascribed to modern infidels. No one acting on the principles of this Dissertation, will be
less amiable in private life, than when acting on any others which Mr. H. might point out. This hypothesis,
which we believe is the scriptural one, and which, in substance, has been maintained by theological writers and
holy men of every age, pours no chilling influence on the affections, encourages no unscriptural disregards or
antipathies in society, nor does it countenance any neglect of private duties under pretence of public utility. We
are assured, by an authority from which, in the views of Christians, there lies no appeal, that “to love God with
all our heart,” is the first and great commandment. We would fain know, if knowable, wherein this requisition
917
CHAPTER VII. The reasons of many mistakes