AGAINST JOVINIANUS.— BOOK I. 373
subjection with all chastity." See what chas- tity is required in a bishop ! If his child be
unchaste, he himself cannot be a bishop, and
he offends God in the same way as did ' Eli the priest, who had indeed rebuked his sons,
but because he had not put away the offend-
ers, fell backwards and died before the lamp
of God went out. a " Women in like manner
must be chaste," and so on. In every grade, and in both sexes, chastity has the chief place.
You see then that the blessedness of a bishop,
priest, or deacon, does not lie in the fact
that they are bishops, priests, or deacons,
but in their having the virtues which their
names and offices imply. Otherwise, if a
deacon be holier than his bishop, his lower
grade will not give him a worse standing with
Christ. If it were so, Stephen the deacon,
the first to wear the martyr's crown, would be less in the kingdom of heaven
than many bishops, and than Timothy and
Titus, whom I venture to make neither in-
ferior nor yet superior to him. Just as in
the legions of the army there are generals,
tribunes, centurions, javelin-men, and light-
armed troops, common soldiers, and com-
panies, but once the battle begins, all dis-
tinctions of rank are dropped, and the one
thing looked for is valour : so too in this
camp and in this battle, in which we contend
against devils, not names but deeds are
needed : and under the true commander,
Christ, not the man who has the highest
title has the greatest fame, but he who is the bravest warrior.
36. But you will say: "If everybody were a virgin, what would become of the human
race " ? Like shall here beget like. If every- one were a widow, or continent in marriage,
how will mortal men be propagated ? Upon
this principle there will be nothing at all for
fear that something else may cease to exist.
To put a case : if all men were philosophers,
there would be no husbandmen. Why speak
of husbandmen ? there would be no orators,
no lawyers, no teachers of the other profes-
sions. If all men were leaders, what would be-
come of the soldiers? If all were the head,
whose head would they be called, when there were no other members ? You are afraid that
if the desire for virginity were geneaal there
would be no prostitutes, no adulteresses, no
wailing infants in town or country. Every
day the blood of adulterers* is shed, adul- terers are condemned, and lust is raging and
rampant in the very presence of the laws and
the symbols of authority and the courts of
justice. Be not afraid that all will become
1 i Sam. ii. and iv. » i Tim. iii. n.
1 The Code of Constantino, following the Mosaic law, im- posed the penalty of death for adultery. Sec Gibbon, ch. xliv.
virgins : virginity is a hard matter, and there- •
fore rare, because it is hard : " Many are
called, few chosen." Many begin, few perse- vere. And so the reward is great for those
who have persevered. If all were able to be
virgins, our Lord would never have said :
1 " He that is able to receive it, let him re-
ceive it : " and the Apostle would not have
hesitated to give his advice, — a " Now con- cerning virgins I have no commandment of
the Lord." Why then, you will say, were the organs of generation created, and why were
we so fashioned by the all-wise creator, that
we burn for one another, and long for nat-
ural intercourse ? To reply is to endanger our
modesty : we are, as it were, between two
rocks, the s Symplegades of necessity and vir- tue, on either side ; and must make shipwreck
of either our sense of shame, or of the cause
we defend. If we reply to your suggestions,
shame covers our face. If shame secures si-
lence, in a manner we seem to desert our post,
and to leave the ground clear to the raging
foe. Yet it is better, as the story goes, to
shut our eyes and fight like the 4 blindfold gladiators, than not to repel with the shield of truth the darts aimed at us. I can indeed
say : " Our hinder parts which are banished
from sight, and the lower portions of the ab-
domen, which perform the functions of na-
ture, are the Creator's work." But inasmuch as the physical conformation of the organs
of generation testifies to difference of sex, I
shall briefly reply : Are we never then to fore-
go lust, for fear that we may have members of
this kind for nothing? Why then should a
husband keep himself from his wife ? Why
should a widow persevere in chastity, if we
were only born to live like beasts? Or what harm does it do me if another man lies with
my wife ? For as the teeth were made for
chewing, and the food masticated passes into
the stomach, and a man is not blamed for
giving my wife bread : similarly if it was in- tended that the organs of generation should
always be performing their office, when my
vigour is spent let another take my place, and,
if I may so speak, let my wife quench her
burning lust where she can. But what does
the Apostle mean by exhorting to continence,
if continence be contrary to nature ? What does our Lord mean when He instructs us in
the various kinds of eunuchs.6 Surely "the Apostle who bids us emulate his own chas-
tity, must be asked, if we are to be consistent,
Why are you like other men, Paul ? Why are
1 S. Matt. xix. la. a i Cor. vii. 25.
1 "Two rocky islands in the Euxine, that, according- to the fable, floated about, dashing against and rebounding from each other, until at length they oecame fixed on the passage of the
Argo between them." 4 Andabatae. • Matt. xix. is. • i Cor. vii. 7.