This work against Hermogenes is no longer extant. Harnack (p. 294
ff.) gives strong grounds for supposing that it was the common source
from which Tertullian, in his work ad Hermogenem, Hippolytus, in
his Phil. VIII. 10 and X. 24, and Clement of Alexandria, in his
Proph. Selections, 56, all drew. If this be true, as seems
probable, the Hermogenes attacked by these various writers is one man,
and his chief heresy, as we learn from Tertullian and Hippolytus, was
that God did not create the world out of nothing, but only formed it
out of matter which, like himself, was eternally existent.