Athanasius was elected bishop by general consent.
Alexander, as we have seen, had practically nominated him, and a large
body of popular opinion clamoured for his election, as “the good, the pious, a Christian, one
of the ascetics, a genuine bishop.” The actual election appears
(p. 103) to have rested with the bishops of Egypt and Libya, who
testify ten years later (ib.) that the majority Eager
opposition, however, was not lacking. The accounts are confused, but
the statement of the bishops leaves room for a strong minority of
malcontents, who may have elected ‘Theonas’ (was he
the exiled Arian bishop of Marmarica? the electors of
‘Theonas’ in Epiph. Hær. 68 are Meletians, but
there is no Theonas in the Meletian catalogue of 327; the Arians and
Meletians very likely combined; the latter properly had no votes, but
they were not likely to regard this; see Gwatkin, p. 66, note,
Church Quarterly Review. xvi. p. 393). The protests of the
opposition were apparently disregarded and Athanasius consecrated
before the other side considered the question as closed, (The statement
of Epiph. Hær. 69, that the Arians chose one Achillas, is
unsupported.) Athanasius was probably only just thirty years old, and
his opponents did not fail to question whether he were not under the
canonical age. of their
body elected him.