Basil is called ‘hasty’ and ‘insolent,’
and in both characters ‘a liar’ by this man who
‘would in patience and meekness educate those of a contrary
opinion to himself;’ for such are the airs he gives himself when
he speaks of him, while he omits no hyperbole of bitter language, when
he has a sufficient opening to produce it. On what grounds, then, does
he charge him with this hastiness and insolence? Because ‘he
called me a Galatian, though I am a Cappadocian;’ then it was
because he called a man who lived on the boundary in an obscure corner
like Corniaspine ἐν
ἀνωνύμῳ τινι
Κορνιασπινῆς
ἐσχατί& 139·. Cf. μεγὰ χρῆμα
ὑ& 232·ς (Herod.) for the
use of this genitive. In the next sentence εἰ ἀντὶ, though it gives the sense translated in the text, is not so good
as ᾗ ἀντὶ (i.e. ἐσχατία), which Oehler suggests, but does not adopt.
With regard to
Eunomius’ birthplace, Sozomen and Philostorgius give Dacora
(which the former describes as on the slopes of Mt. Argæus: but
that it must have been on the borders of Galatia and Cappadocia is
certain from what Gregory says here): ‘Probably Dacora was his
paternal estate: Oltiseris the village to which it belonged’
(Dict. Christ. Biog.; unless indeed Corniaspa, marked on the maps as a
town where Cappadocia, Galatia and Pontus join, was the spot, and
Oltiseris the district. Eunomius died at Dacora. a Galatian instead of an Oltiserian;
supposing, that is, that it is proved that he said this. I have not
found it in my copies; but grant it. For this he is to be called
‘hasty,’ ‘insolent,’ all that is bad. But the
wise know well that the minute charges of a faultfinder furnish a
strong argument for the righteousness of the accused; else, when eager
to accuse, he would not have spared great faults and employed his
malice on little ones. On these last he is certainly great, heightening
the enormity of the offence, and making solemn reflections on
falsehood, and seeing equal heinousness in it whether in great or very
trivial matters. Like the fathers of his heresy, the scribes and
Pharisees, he knows how to strain a gnat carefully and to swallow at
one gulp the hump-backed camel laden with a weight of wickedness. But
it would not be out of place to say to him, ‘refrain from making
such a rule in our system; cease to bid us think it of no account to
measure the guilt of a falsehood by the slightness or the importance of
the circumstances.’ Paul telling a falsehood and purifying
himself after the manner of the Jews to meet the needs of those whom he
usefully deceived did not sin the same as Judas for the requirement of
his treachery putting on a kind and affable look. By a falsehood Joseph
in love to his brethren deceived them; and that too while swearing
‘by the life of Pharaoh Gen. xlii. 15.;’ but his
brethren had really lied to him, in their envy plotting his death and
then his enslavement. There are many such cases: Sarah lied, because
she was ashamed of laughing: the serpent lied, tempting man to disobey
and change to a divine existence. Falsehoods differ widely according to
their motives. Accordingly we accept that general statement about man
which the Holy Spirit uttered by the Prophet Psalm cxv. 11.,
‘Every man is a liar;’ and this man of God, too, has not
kept clear of falsehood, having chanced to give a place the name of a
neighbouring district, through oversight or ignorance of its real name.
But Eunomius also has told a falsehood, and what is it? Nothing less
than a misstatement of Truth itself. He asserts that One who always is
once was not; he demonstrates that One who is truly a Son is falsely so
called; he defines the Creator to be a creature and a work; the Lord of
the world he calls a servant, and ranges the Being who essentially
rules with subject beings. Is the difference between falsehoods so very
trifling, that one can think it matters nothing whether the falsehood
is palpable ἐψεῦσθαι
δοκεῖν. in this way or in that?