Justin I., the unlettered
barbarian, supported the Chalcedonians, but in 544 Belisarius
had made the
Eutychian Vigilius bishop of Rome. When Justinian aspired to become a
second Constantine, and give theological as well as civil law to the
world, it was proposed to condemn in a fifth œcumenical council
certain so-called Nestorian writings, on the plea that such a
condemnation might reconcile the opponents of Chalcedon. The writings
in question were the Letter of Ibas of Edessa to Maris, praising
Theodore of Mopsuestia; the works of Theodore himself, and the writings
of Theodoret against Cyril. These three literary monuments were known
as “the Three Chapters.” Dean
Milman (Lat. Christ. iv, 4), following in the wake of Gibbon, remarks
that “the church was not now disturbed by the sublime, if
inexplicable, dogmas concerning the nature of God, the Persons of the
Trinity, or the union of the divine and human nature of Christ,
concerning the revelations of Scripture, or even the opinions of the
ancient fathers. The orthodoxy or heterodoxy of certain writings by
bishops but recently dead became the subject of imperial edicts of a
fifth so-called Œcumenic Council, held at Constantinople, and a
religious war between the East and the West,” but it was on their
explanation of sublime if inexplicable dogmas that the orthodoxy or
heterodoxy of these bishops depended, and so far as the subject matter
of dispute is concerned, the position in 553 was not very different
from that of 451. In both cases the church was moved at once by honest
conviction and partisan passion; the state was influenced partly by a
healthy desire to promote peace through out the empire, partly by the
meaner ambition of posing as theological arbitrator. Of the
controversy of the Three Chapters it has been said that it
“filled more volumes than it was worth lines.” Gibbon,
chap. xlvii. Schaff Hist. Christ. iii, 770. The Council satisfied nobody. Pope Vigilius,
detained at Constantinople and Marmora with something of the same
violence with which Napoleon I. detained Pius VI. at Valence, declined
to preside over a gathering so exclusively oriental. The West was
outraged by the constitution of the synod, irrespective of its
decisions. The Monophysites were disappointed that the credit of
Chalcedon should be even nominally saved by the nice distinction which
damaged the writings, but professed complete agreement with the council
which had refused to damn the writers. The orthodox wanted no slur cast
upon Chalcedon, and, however fenced, the condemnation of the Three
Chapters indubitably involved such a slur. Practically, the decrees of
the fourth and fifth councils are mutually inconsistent, and it is
impossible to accept both. Theodoret was reinstated at Chalcedon in
spite of what he had written, and what he had written was anathematized
at Constantinople in spite of his reinstatement.