Chapter 9.—14. "This, moreover," says he, "Agrippinus, a man of excellent memory,
with the rest, bishops with him, who at that time governed the Church of the Lord in the
province of Africa and Numidia, did establish and, after the investigation of a mutual
Council had weighed it, confirm; whose sentence, being both religious and legitimate and
salutary in accordance with the Catholic faith and Church, we also have followed." 1244 By
this witness he gives sufficient proof how much more ready he would have been to bear his
testimony, had any Council been held to discuss this matter which either embraced the
whole Church, or at least represented our brethren beyond the sea.1245 But such a Council
had not yet been held, because the whole world was bound together by the powerful bond
of custom; and this was deemed sufficient to oppose to those who wished to introduce what
was new, because they could not comprehend the truth. Afterwards, however, while the
question became matter for discussion and investigation amongst many on either side, the
new practice was not only invented, but even submitted to the authority and power of a
plenary Council,—after the martyrdom of Cyprian, it is true, but before we were born.1246
432
But that this was indeed the custom of the Church, which afterwards was confirmed by a
plenary Council, in which the truth was brought to light, and many difficulties cleared away,
is plain enough from the words of the blessed Cyprian himself in that same letter to Jubaianus,
which was quoted as being read in the Council.1247 For he says, "But some one asks, What
then will be done in the case of those who, coming out of heresy to the Church, have already
been admitted without baptism?" where certainly he shows plainly enough what was usually
done, though he would have wished it otherwise; and in the very fact of his quoting the
Council of Agrippinus, he clearly proves that the custom of the Church was different. Nor
indeed was it requisite that he should seek to establish the practice by this Council, if it was
already sanctioned by custom; and in the Council itself some of the speakers expressly declare,
1244 Cypr. Ep. lxxi. 4.
1245 Transmarinum vel universale Concilium.
1246 The plenary Council, on whose authority Augustin relies in many places in this work, was either that
of Arles, in 314 A.D., or of Nicæa, in 325 A.D., both of them being before his birth, in 354 A.D. He quotes the
decision of the same council, contra Parmenianum, ii. 13, 30; de Hæresibus 69: Ep. xliii. 7, 19. Contra Parmeni-
anum, iii. 4, 21: "They condemned," he says, "some few in Africa, by whom they were in turn vanquished by
the judgment of the whole world;" and he adds, that "the Catholics trusted ecclesiastical judges like these in
preference to the defeated parties in the suit." Ib. 6, 30: He says that the Donatists, "having made a schism in
the unity of the Church, were refuted, not by the authority of 310 African bishops, but by that of the whole
world." And in the sixth chapter of the first book of the same treatise, he says that the Donatists, after the decision
at Arles, came again to Constantine, and there were defeated "by a final decision," i.e. at Milan, as is seen from
Ep. xliii. 7, 20, in the year 316 A.D. Substance of note in Benedictine ed. reproduced in Migne.
1247 See above, ch. ii. 3.
Chapter 9
744
Chapter 9