322 ON THE TEINITY. [BOOK XIII.
wliich he loves beyond all else. A life therefore cannot both
be blessed, and yet quit a man against his will, since no one
becomes blessed against his will ; and hence how much more
does it make a man miserable by quitting him against his will,
when it would make him miserable if he had it against his
will ! But if it quit him with his will, even so how was
that a blessed life, which he who had it willed should perish ?
It remains for them to say that neither ofthese is in the mind
of the blessed man ; that is, that he is neither unwilling nor
willing to be quitted by a blessed life, when through death life
quits him altogether ; for that he stands firm with an even
heart, prepared alike for either alternative. But neither is
that a blessed life which is such as to be unworthy of his
love whom it makes blessed. For how is that a blessed life
which the blessed man does not love ? Or how is that loved,
of which it is received indifferently, whether it is to flourish
or to perish ? Unless perhaps the virtues, which we love in
this way on account of blessedness alone, venture to persuade
us that we do not love blessedness itself. Yet if they did
this, we should certainly leave off loving the virtues them-
selves, when we do not love that on account of which alone
we loved them. And further, how will that opinion be true,
which has been so tried, and sifted, and thoroughly strained,
and is so certain, viz. that all men will to be blessed, if they
themselves who are already blessed neither will nor do not
will to be blessed ? Or if they will it, as truth proclaims, as
nature constrains, in which indeed the supremely good and
unchangeably blessed Creator has implanted that will ; if, I say,
they will to be blessed who are blessed, certainly they do not
will to be not blessed. But if they do not will not to be blessed,
without doubt they do not will to be annihilated and perish
in regard to their blessedness. But they cannot be blessed
except they are alive ; therefore they do not will so to perish
in regard to their life. Therefore, whoever are either truly
blessed or desire to be so, will to be immortal. But he does
not live blessedlywho has not that which he wills. Therefore
it follows that in no way can life be truly blessed unless it
be eternal.