286
6. What counsel then, brethren, do you give us concerning such persons? What should
we do? Shall we have the same judgment and rule as theirs, and observe their decision and
charity, and show mercy to those whom they pitied? Or, shall we declare their decision un-
righteous, and set ourselves as judges of their opinion, and grieve mercy and overturn or-
der?”2104 These words Dionysius very properly added when making mention of those who
had been weak in the time of persecution.
confessors had the power given them to receive the lapsed back again into the Church, and to dispense the
eucharist to them. That was the prerogative of the bishop, and evidently Dionysius has no thought of its being
otherwise. The communion of which he speaks was private fellowship merely, and implied a recognition on the
part of these confessors that the persons in question had truly repented of their sin, and could be recommended
for readmission into the Church. As we see from chap. 44, §2, the recommendation of these persons or of the
people in general was quite necessary, before the bishop would consent to absolve the fallen person and receive
him back again into the Church. And Dionysius’ words in this passage show that he felt that the judgment of
these confessors in regard to the fitness of the lapsed for readmission ought to be received with consideration,
and have influence upon the final decision. Dionysius thus shows great respect to the confessors, but does not
accord them the privileges which they claimed in some places (as we learn from Tertullian’s de Pudicitia, 22,
and from a number of Cyprian’s Epistles) of themselves absolving the lapsed and readmitting them to church
communion. In this he showed again his agreement with Cyprian and with the principles finally adopted in the
Roman and Carthaginian churches (cf. e.g. Cyprian’s Epistles, 9 sq., al. 15; see also Dittrich, p. 51 sq.).
2104 The object of the letter is clearly revealed in these sentences (see chap. 41, note 1).
722
Others of whom Dionysius gives an Account.