3. What, I ask, is the meaning of these portentous words
and of this grotesque description? Would you not think he was in a
feverish dream, or that he was seized with madness and ought to be put
into the strait jacket which Hippocrates prescribed? However often I
read him, even till my heart sinks within me, I am still in uncertainty
of his meaning. Ibi est
distinctio. Instead of clearness we have to make a choice between
possible meanings. Everything
starts from, everything depends upon, something else. It is impossible
to make out any connection; and, excepting the proofs from Scripture
which he has not dared to exchange for his own lovely flowers of
rhetoric, his words suit all matter equally well, because they suit no
matter at all. This circumstance led me shrewdly to suspect that his
object in proclaiming the excellence of marriage was only to disparage
virginity. For when the less is put upon a level with the greater, the
lower profits by comparison, but the higher suffers wrong. For
ourselves, we do not follow the views of Marcion lived
about a.d. 150, and was co-temporary with
Polycarp, who is said to have had a personal encounter with him at
Rome. Unlike other Gnostics he professed to be purely Christian in his
doctrines. He is specially noted for his violent treatment of
Scripture: he rejected the whole of the Old Testament, while of the New
he acknowledged only the Gospel of S. Luke and ten of S. Paul’s
Epistles, and from these he expunged whatever he did not approve of.
His sect lasted until the sixth century.Marcion and Manichæus, and
disparage marriage; nor, deceived by the error of By birth an
Assyrian, and a pupil of Justin Martyr. His followers were called
Encratites, or Temperates, from their great austerity.
They also bore the names Water-drinkers and
Renouncers.Tatian, the leader of the Encratites,
do we think all intercourse impure; he condemns and rejects not only
marriage but also food which God created for the use of man. We know
that in a great house, there are not only vessels of gold and silver,
but also of wood and earthenware. And that upon the foundation, Christ,
which Paul the master-builder laid, some build gold, silver, precious
stones: others, on the contrary, hay, wood, straw. We are not ignorant
of the words, Heb. xiii. The Revised Ver. translates “let
marriage be, etc.” There is no verb in the original, the sentence
being probably designed to be a Christian proverb, and capable of
serving either as an assertion or as a precept. The revised
rendering is preferred by the chief modern commentators.“Marriage is honourable among
all, and the bed undefiled.” We have read God’s first
command, Gen. i. 28. “Be fruitful, and multiply,
and replenish the earth”; but while we honour marriage we prefer
virginity which is the offspring of marriage. Will silver cease to be
silver, if gold is more precious than silver? Or is despite done to
tree and corn, if we prefer the fruit to root and foliage, or the grain
to stalk and ear? Virginity is to marriage what fruit is to the tree,
or grain to the straw. Although the hundred-fold, the sixty-fold, and
the thirty-fold spring from one earth and from one sowing, yet there is
a great difference in respect of number. The thirty-fold has reference
to marriage. The very way the For much
interesting information relating to counting on the fingers, and for
authorities on the subject, see Mayor’s note on Juvenal x.
249.fingers are
combined—see how they seem to embrace, tenderly kiss, and pledge
their troth either to other—is a picture of husband and wife. The
sixty-fold applies to widows, because they are placed in a position of
difficulty and distress. Hence the upper finger signifies their
depression, and the greater the difficulty in resisting the allurements
of pleasure once experienced, the greater the reward. Moreover (give
good heed, my reader), to denote a hundred, the right hand is used
instead of the left: a circle is made with the same fingers which on
the left hand represented widowhood, and thus the crown of virginity is
expressed. In saying this I have followed my own impatient spirit
rather than the course of the argument. For I had scarcely left
harbour, and had barely hoisted sail, when a swelling tide of words
suddenly swept me into the depths of the discussion. I must stay my
course, and take in canvas for a little while; nor will I indulge my
sword, anxious as it is to strike a blow for virginity. The farther
back the catapult is drawn, the greater the force of the missile. To
linger is not to lose, if by lingering victory is better assured. I
will briefly set forth our adversary’s views, and will drag them
out from his books like snakes from
the holes where they hide, and will separate the venomous head from the
writhing body. What is baneful shall be discovered, that, when we have
the power, it may be crushed.