But let
us see what is the next addition that follows upon this profanity, an
addition which is in fact the key of their defence of their doctrine.
For those who would degrade the majesty of the glory of the
Only-begotten to slavish and grovelling conceptions think that they
find the strongest proof of their assertions in the words of the Lord
to Mary, which He uttered after His resurrection, and before His
ascension into heaven, saying, “Touch Me not, for I am not yet
ascended to My Father: but go to My brethren and say unto them, I
ascend unto My Father and your Father, and to My God and your God S. John xx. 17.” The orthodox interpretation of these
words, the sense in which we have been accustomed to believe that they
were spoken to Mary, is I think manifest to all who have received the
faith in truth. Still the discussion of this point shall be given by us
in its proper place; but meantime it is worth while to inquire from
those who allege against us such phrases as “ascending,”
“being seen,” “being recognized by touch,” and
moreover “being associated with men by brotherhood,”
whether they consider them to be proper to the Divine or to the Human
Nature. For if they see in the Godhead the capacity of being seen and
touched, of being supported by meat and drink, kinship and brotherhood
with men, and all the attributes of corporeal nature, then let them
predicate of the Only-begotten God both these and whatsoever else they
will, as motive energy and local change, which are peculiar to things
circumscribed by a body. But if He by Mary is discoursing with His
brethren, and if the Only-begotten has no brethren, (for how, if He had
brethren, could the property of being Only-begotten be preserved?) and
if the same Person Who said, “God is a Spirit S. John iv. 24,” says to His disciples, “Handle
Me S. Luke xxiv. 39.,” that He may show that while the
Human Nature is capable of being handled the Divinity is intangible,
and if He Who says, “I go,” indicates local change, while
He who contains all things, “in Whom,” as the Apostle says,
“all things were created, and in Whom all things consist Col. i. 16,
17.,” has nothing in existent things
external to Himself to which removal could take place by any kind of
motion, (for motion cannot otherwise be effected than by that which is
removed leaving the place in which it is, and occupying another place
instead, while that which extends through all, and is in all, and
controls all, and is confined by no existent thing, has no place to
which to pass, inasmuch as nothing is void of the Divine fulness,) how
can these men abandon the belief that such expressions arise from that
which is apparent, and apply them to that Nature which is Divine and
which surpasseth all understanding, when the Apostle has in his speech
to the Athenians plainly forbidden us to imagine any such thing of God,
inasmuch as the Divine power is not discoverable by touch Cf. Acts xvii. The precise reference
is perhaps to verse 27., but by intelligent contemplation and faith?
Or, again, whom does He Who did eat before the eyes of His disciples,
and promised to go before them into Galilee and there be seen of
them,—whom does He reveal Him to be Who should so appear to them?
God, Whom no man hath seen or can see The
reference is perhaps to 1 Tim. vi. 16; but the
quotation is not verbal. See also S. John i. 18.?
or the bodily image, that is, the form of a servant in which God was?
If then what has been said plainly proves that the meaning of the
phrases alleged refers to that which is visible, expressing shape, and
capable of motion, akin to the nature of His disciples, and none of
these properties is discernible in Him Who is invisible, incorporeal,
intangible, and formless, how do they come to degrade the very
Only-begotten God, Who was in the beginning, and is in the Father, to a
level with Peter, Andrew, John, and the rest of the Apostles, by
calling them the brethren and fellow-servants of the Only-begotten? And
yet all their exertions are directed to this aim, to show that in
majesty of nature there is as great a distance between the Father and the
dignity, power, and essence of the Only-begotten, as there is between
the Only-begotten and humanity. And they press this saying into the
support of this meaning, treating the name of the God and Father as
being of common significance in respect of the Lord and of His
disciples, in the view that no difference in dignity of nature is
conceived while He is recognized as God and Father both of Him and of
them in a precisely similar manner.